Understanding Moduli Spaces: O(d, d,R) & Beyond

  • Context: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Thread starter wam_mi
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the concept of moduli spaces, specifically focusing on the group O(d, d, R) and its implications in the context of mathematical physics. Participants seek to understand the definitions, roles, and structures associated with moduli spaces, particularly in relation to quotient groups and their applications in various equations.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • One participant asks for clarification on what a moduli space is and the meaning of the generating group O(d, d, R).
  • Another participant explains that 'O' stands for Orthogonal, 'd' likely indicates the dimension, and 'R' suggests the matrices have real entries. They also describe the process of forming a quotient group and the concept of cosets.
  • A different participant elaborates that the moduli space represents the "space of all solutions" to certain equations, such as the Dirac equation or Maxwell's equations, and discusses the significance of gauge transformations in this context.
  • Some participants express uncertainty about the group O(d, d, R) while providing insights into the quotient group formation and its implications for understanding solutions in moduli spaces.
  • One participant acknowledges the clarity of the explanation regarding group "division" and its relation to quotient groups.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express varying levels of understanding regarding the definitions and implications of moduli spaces and the group O(d, d, R). There is no consensus on the complete understanding of these concepts, and multiple viewpoints are presented without resolution.

Contextual Notes

Some discussions involve assumptions about the definitions of groups and the nature of moduli spaces, which may not be universally agreed upon. The mathematical steps involved in forming quotient groups and their applications remain partially explored.

wam_mi
Messages
78
Reaction score
1
Hi there,

Could someone explain to me what a moduli space is.

(i) What does the generating group O(d, d,R) mean?
(ii) Why is it then the modular space is written as O(d,d,R)/O(d,R)×O(d,R)
What role does the division play here?

Thanks a lot!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
wam_mi said:
(ii) Why is it then the modular space is written as O(d,d,R)/O(d,R)×O(d,R)
What role does the division play here?
Not sure what that group is, but the 'O' stands for Orthogonal and indicates that orthogonal matrices make up the group. The 'd' is most probably the dimension of the group, and the R could indicate that the entries of the matrices are taken from the reals.

As for the division, that's how you form a quotient group: by 'dividing' one group by another. It's really a modulus: the group A/B is the group A modulo the action of B. What this means is pretty simple. You take an element of A and act on it with each element of B. This forms a set of numbers, \{ab|\forall b \in B\}, called a coset. Now, do this for each a \in A. Then you get a group of cosets. Each coset is now an element of the group A/B. You've modded out by the group B in that you've 'removed' its action. You've done this by taking elements that differ by B's action and calling them one element -- the coset.

To offer a nice example, consider how you construct the group Z_2, the group of two integers, 0 and 1 mod2. Start with the additive group of integers, Z. Next take the additive group of all even integers, 2Z. Now, just form the quotient group: Z/2Z. You've modded out by the action of adding an even number each element of Z. Even numbers remain even numbers when you add an even number, and odd remain odd. And so there are only 2 elements of the group Z_2: an even element (really the coset of all even numbers, represented by just a single element), 0, and an odd element, 1.
 
Last edited:
The moduli space is, generally speaking, the "space of all solutions" to some equations. You can think of the Dirac equation, Maxwell's equations or the Yang-Mills equations as a mapping from one space to another. In the presence of sources such equations take on the form

<br /> D\Psi(x,t) = J(x,t)<br />

I've simply wrote down the equations of motion here. D is the (differential) operator corresponding to the equations of motion you are considering (e.g the Dirac operator for the Dirac Equation). J is some source distribution and \Psi[/tex] is a scalar field, a vector field, or a gauge field etc. If the field \Psi is a solution to this equation, then it is said to live in the moduli space of the operator D. In the absence of sources it is also lives in the kernel of D (the right hand side becomes zero). So the moduli space is nothing but your space of solutions to this equation, also called the parameter space.<br /> <br /> It has a special name, because this moduli space can have all sorts of nice algebraic, geometric or topological features which you can study. Identifying the moduli space can tell you a great deal about the properties of the solutions, without the need to explicitly solve the differential equations. <br /> <br /> As I said before the moduli space itself is a space on its own, frequently identifyable as a type of manifold. The manifold itself can be endowed with a group structure turning it into a Lie group. The group multiplication acting on the moduli space takes you from one solution to another -- think of it as performing a Lorentz transformation. This changes the solution is written down, but it&#039;s still a solution if the theory is Lorentz invariant.<br /> <br /> Another class of symmetries are, ofcourse, the gauge symmetries. A gauge transformation also maps one solution into another. However, physically we do not distinguish two solutions which are gauge equivalent. Hence we want two gauge equivalent solutions to be represented by the _same_ point in the moduli space. This is accomplished by &quot;modding out&quot; the gauge group from your moduli space. The resulting space is a coset space, described by bapowell above. It basically means that a gauge transformation induces a transformation in the way you write your solution, but not in your solution \emph{space}. This also shows some advantages of moduli spaces: the gauge redundancy is eliminated, so any topological/geometrical property of your moduli space is automatically physical.
 
bapowell said:
Not sure what that group is, but the 'O' stands for Orthogonal and indicates that orthogonal matrices make up the group. The 'd' is most probably the dimension of the group, and the R could indicate that the entries of the matrices are taken from the reals.

As for the division, that's how you form a quotient group: by 'dividing' one group by another. It's really a modulus: the group A/B is the group A modulo the action of B. What this means is pretty simple. You take an element of A and act on it with each element of B. This forms a set of numbers, \{ab|\forall b \in B\}, called a coset. Now, do this for each a \in A. Then you get a group of cosets. Each coset is now an element of the group A/B. You've modded out by the group B in that you've 'removed' its action. You've done this by taking elements that differ by B's action and calling them one element -- the coset.

To offer a nice example, consider how you construct the group Z_2, the group of two integers, 0 and 1 mod2. Start with the additive group of integers, Z. Next take the additive group of all even integers, 2Z. Now, just form the quotient group: Z/2Z. You've modded out by the action of adding an even number each element of Z. Even numbers remain even numbers when you add an even number, and odd remain odd. And so there are only 2 elements of the group Z_2: an even element (really the coset of all even numbers, represented by just a single element), 0, and an odd element, 1.
I think this may be the first clear explanation I've seen of what group "division" means - thanks!
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
5K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
2K