When should I use internal energy U or enthalpy H?

  • Thread starter yecko
  • Start date
6 replies · 11K views · last reply
yecko
Gold Member
Messages
275
Reaction score
15

Homework Statement


Textbook problem 4-34: an insulated piston-cylinder device holds 5 L of saturated liquid water at 175 kPa, stirred by a paddle wheel while 8 A flows through a resistor for 45 min; asks for source voltage (answer 224 V) and a P-v diagram.


Homework Equations


E =Q + W
U(internal energy)=m(u2-u1)
H(enthalpy)=m(h2-h1)

The Attempt at a Solution


Worked solution for a closed-cylinder water heating problem: energy balance W_e,in + W_pw,in = m(h2 - h1) with constant-pressure enthalpy, property values, and electrical voltage V = 223.9 V, plus a piston diagram and P-v plot.

1st question: I understand in this case as no heat change, the work done should be equal to internal energy change... but why it used m(h2-h1) in this case for enthalpy change in this case?

2nd question: generally speaking, when should i use enthalpy and internal energy for calculating energy change?

Thank you very much!
 
Attachments
  • Textbook problem 4-34: an insulated piston-cylinder device holds 5 L of saturated liquid water at 175 kPa, stirred by a paddle wheel while 8 A flows through a resistor for 45 min; asks for source voltage (answer 224 V) and a P-v diagram.
    螢幕快照 2017-10-19 下午8.09.07.png
    11.8 KB · Views: 3,739
  • Worked solution for a closed-cylinder water heating problem: energy balance W_e,in + W_pw,in = m(h2 - h1) with constant-pressure enthalpy, property values, and electrical voltage V = 223.9 V, plus a piston diagram and P-v plot.
    螢幕快照 2017-10-19 下午8.08.57.png
    55.7 KB · Views: 5,166
Enthalpy is used because it is simpler in this case. As you are told, "ΔU + Wb = ΔH during a constant pressure quasi-equilibrium process" and therefore We + Wpw = ΔH. Substituting known values gives you an equation with one unknown, V, which is what you want to determine. There is no need to separately calculate ΔU and/or Wb. That would just complicate things without helping to answer the given question.
Generally speaking, you need to take an approach like that above, write down an equation with all the relevant quantities, and determine what ΔU and ΔH are each equal to, and decide which is more appropriate to calculate for your problem.
 
mjc123 said:
As you are told, "ΔU + Wb = ΔH during a constant pressure quasi-equilibrium process" and therefore We + Wpw = ΔH.
mjc123 said:
There is no need to separately calculate ΔU and/or Wb.
Energy balance derivation: Ein - Eout equals change in system energy, with boxed W_e,in - W_b,out = dU = m(u2 - u1) since KE = PE = 0, then W_e,in = W_b,out + m(u2 - u1), W_e,in = H2 - H1 = m(h2 - h1) = mh_fg, and rate form W_dot_e,in dt = m h_fg.

indeed solution of all these kind of questions would work done to the system equal to change of internal energy first, by m(u2-u1) first... and then it suddenly equals to m(h1-h2) which doubt me... why?

or do you mean just because there are volume change, on top of state and temperature, we should only use enthalpy instead of internal energy?
or should any kind of work done should just use enthalpy instead of internal energy data?

thanks
 
Attachments
  • Energy balance derivation: Ein - Eout equals change in system energy, with boxed W_e,in - W_b,out = dU = m(u2 - u1) since KE = PE = 0, then W_e,in = W_b,out + m(u2 - u1), W_e,in = H2 - H1 = m(h2 - h1) = mh_fg, and rate form W_dot_e,in dt = m h_fg.
    螢幕快照 2017-10-19 下午9.03.32.png
    5.3 KB · Views: 5,199
Diagram of a spring-loaded piston-cylinder device containing steam, with a coil spring above the piston, a heat input labelled Q at the bottom, and the steam region labelled Steam, captioned FIGURE P4-39.

Worked solution to a closed-system energy balance for a spring-loaded piston-cylinder water problem, with a P-v diagram showing a process line from 75 kPa to 225 kPa.

on the other hand, question like this used only internal energy instead of using enthalpy for the total energy... why?
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a spring-loaded piston-cylinder device containing steam, with a coil spring above the piston, a heat input labelled Q at the bottom, and the steam region labelled Steam, captioned FIGURE P4-39.
    螢幕快照 2017-10-19 下午10.00.56.png
    14.8 KB · Views: 3,002
  • Worked solution to a closed-system energy balance for a spring-loaded piston-cylinder water problem, with a P-v diagram showing a process line from 75 kPa to 225 kPa.
    螢幕快照 2017-10-19 下午10.03.16.png
    53.7 KB · Views: 2,902
m(u2-u1) does not "suddenly equal" m(h2-h1). Can you not read what's in front of your face? A term is transferred from one side of the equation to the other. As is given in your example:
We - Wb = ΔU = m(u2-u1)
Add Wb to each side:
We = Wb + m(u2-u1) = m(h2-h1)
ΔH = ΔU + Δ(PV), and as explained above, in a constant-pressure process Δ(PV) = PΔV = Wb. In your second example the pressure is not constant, so Wb = ∫PdV ≠ Δ(PV), and Wb ≠ ΔH - ΔU. In this case, since the process is linear, if you had the enthalpy data you could work from that just as easily.
 
So to conclude, h is only being used when pressure is constant, Q=H,
u is being used when volume is constant (or even it is not constant, whenever when pressure is not constant?), Q=E+W=U+W... right?
 
Not necessarily. U and H are always both there; they are state functions of the system. (The relation between them is particularly simple at constant pressure.) Which you use in your calculations depends on which is more convenient - and sometimes, on which you have data for. (A lot of tabulated thermodynamic data is given in terms of enthalpy; e.g. enthalpies of formation, phase transitions etc. You could fairly easily calculate ΔU values from them, but ΔH values are what you are given.)
As I said above, do what your examples do - write down all the relevant energy terms in an equation of the form Ein - Eout = ΔEsystem. What is known and what is unknown? What assumptions are being made (e.g. constant pressure, insulated system etc.)? How do you calculate terms like Wb in the given scenario?