Who is Penrose Sir Roger Penrose? Insights from His Recent Interviews

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread discusses insights from recent interviews with Sir Roger Penrose, focusing on his contributions to mathematics and physics, his life experiences, and his perspectives on various scientific topics. The scope includes personal anecdotes, historical context, and reflections on his work in general relativity, consciousness, and geometry.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants express admiration for Penrose as a polymath and a true classical pure mathematician who has made significant contributions to both physics and mathematics.
  • One participant compares Penrose to historical universalists, suggesting he is a modern equivalent due to his broad interests and ability to engage the public.
  • Another participant shares their enjoyment of Penrose's interviews, particularly highlighting his storytelling about the early days of general relativity and cosmology.
  • Some participants mention their interest in other types of videos, suggesting a light-hearted diversion from the main topic while still expressing appreciation for Penrose's work.
  • There is a general enthusiasm for the interviews shared, with participants noting their potential to reach a wider audience, especially younger physicists and mathematicians.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on their admiration for Penrose and the value of his interviews, but there is no consensus on specific interpretations of his work or the broader implications of his ideas.

Contextual Notes

Some discussions touch on the historical context of Penrose's contributions and the perception of his work among different audiences, but these points remain open to interpretation and are not fully resolved.

Auto-Didact
Messages
747
Reaction score
554
Sir Roger Penrose, famous for his numerous contributions to mathematics and physics, is approaching 90 but still pretty active. In this thread I'll post some of his most recent and best interviews.

The interviews tend to be a mixture of him talking about some new idea of his, his prior academic work interlaced with colorful stories about his early life growing up, his time in school and at Cambridge and events later in life working together with other scientists and mathematicians.

Interviewed by Joe Rogan:


Interviewed by Hannah Fry (public lecture, interview starts around 32 minute mark):


Interviewed by Andrew Hodges:


Interviewed by DAI Heidelberg:


Interviewed by Howard Burton:
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vela, Greg Bernhardt, DennisN and 4 others
Science news on Phys.org
Thanks for sharing these videos here.

What is your interest in Prof Penrose?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: AlexCaledin
Just a fan really. I share a lot of his interests such as GR, the measurement problem, geometry, the hard problem of consciousness, mathematically non-standard ways of doing standard physics, and doing mathematics for the fun of it.

Penrose, unlike pretty much all other living famous physicists, is actually a polymath: a true classical pure mathematician, a geometer turned physicist, a truly bold and independent thinker and a marvelous teacher, writer and communicator.

Historically, this practically puts him in the same category of thinkers known as the universalists, i.e. a small group of elite 17th-20th century mathematicians (starting with Newton and Leibniz), who were also physicists, who moreover weren't put off by philosophy.

It is often said that Poincaré was the last surviving universalist when Hilbert and his followers took over. This isn't entirely accurate, since I can name a few others e.g. Mandelbrot, 't Hooft and Atiyah, while today most potential universalists seem to end up stuck in (applied) mathematics (e.g. Tao, Strogatz, Frenkel).

Unlike those named above however, Penrose seems to be the only real universalist after Poincaré, because he both did mainstream work at the highest levels, in physics as well as mathematics, and at the same time could capture the public's attention a bit as well.

Somehow, most people, especially outside of physics/mathematics, seem to have heard of his recreative works, but remain woefully unaware of the rest, while many younger physicists and mathematicians, already flooded by other content, are totally oblivious; I'm hoping my posts will reach them.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: OCR, pinball1970, AlexCaledin and 2 others
Penrose is on Sean Carroll's podcast:


They start off recounting the events of his experiences of the early GR days, cosmology and other topics. I just started listening, it's pretty good, definitely if you're a fan of GR, cosmology and/or just like hearing story about the history of physics as recounted by physicists who were literally there.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DennisN
Auto-Didact said:
The interviews tend to be a mixture of him talking about some new idea of his, his prior academic work interlaced with colorful stories about his early life growing up, his time in school and at Cambridge and events later in life working together with other scientists and mathematicians.
Thanks for posting the videos! They seem very interesting, so now I have something else besides cat videos to watch on youtube tonight. :smile:
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DennisN
OCR said:
Well, you could watch Machine Shop videos, also... . :wink:

This Old Tony - YouTube
Off topic, but I'm a fan of his as well. I've seen a number of Tony's videos, as well as the next guy on your list. Others in a similar vein are Keith Appleton, who works with model steam engines, and Tubalcain AKA mrpete222.
OCR said:
Abom79 - YouTube

Stefan Gotteswinter - YouTube

Haas Automation, Inc. - YouTube

Check some of them out out... I like them all, but This Old Tony is classic !

I have a lot more bookmarked... . :olduhh: . :approve:BTW... Sir Roger Penrose is beyond compare !
.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: OCR
Auto-Didact said:
Penrose is on Sean Carroll's podcast:

They start off recounting the events of his experiences of the early GR days, cosmology and other topics. I just started listening, it's pretty good, definitely if you're a fan of GR, cosmology and/or just like hearing story about the history of physics as recounted by physicists who were literally there.

I really enjoyed this interview! :smile: The scope of the conversation was vast, but I sometimes enjoy that, depending on who the participants are. An besides science, I think Sean Carroll has an extra talent in communication. I think he is a very good communicator.