Why does buoyant force add to scale reading, not tension?

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
TkoT
Messages
7
Reaction score
2
Homework Statement
A cylindrical beaker of mass mb = 1.3 kg contains 1.5 x 10^3 ml of water. The beaker is placed on a scale and then a rock of mass mr = 2.2 kg, suspended by a massless string, is totally immersed in the water. The water level rises by 1.5 cm. The diameter of the beaker is 0.2m
a) What mass does the scale measure before the rock is lowered into the water?
b) What mass does the scale measure after the rock is lowered into the water?
Relevant Equations
F=mg
my solution:
a)
Hand-drawn free-body diagram of a beaker of water on a scale, with downward arrows labelled Fb and Fw, and the beaker's contents indicated by a waterline.

F(upward)=Fb +Fw
=(1.3+1.5)X9.8
=27.44N
total Mass = 2.8kg
b)
Free-body diagram of a rock in a water tank on a scale: T pulls up on the rock, Fb buoyant force points up, and mg points down.

Volume increased = π(0.2/2)^2 x 1.5/100
=4.7x10-4 m^3

T+Fb =mg
T=mg-Fb
T=2.2x9.8 -1000 x 4.7x10-4 x 9.8
T=17.4N
T is the apparent weight of the rock, so the mass of the rock in the water is 1.74kg
So, the total mass measured by the scale = 1.74 +2.8 = 4.54kg

Question:
I am confused about the part b after I checked the answer. For me, I think the tension represents the apparent weight of the rock. So apparent mass of the rock can be obtained by the tension. But, In the answer, buoyant force is considered as the extra weight added to the scale. That confuses me and I don’t understand why.

answer attached below
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten diagram of a cylinder of water with a rock suspended by a string, labeled after and before, with Archimedes' principle stated and the setup before the rock is suspended worked out.
    answer1.png
    23.3 KB · Views: 151
  • Handwritten force diagrams: a rock suspended by a string in a beaker of water, with forces T, Fb and mg on the rock, and Fs' on the water and beaker, with notes on the action-reaction pair.
    answer2.png
    26.7 KB · Views: 166
  • Handwritten solution calculating displaced volume as A times delta h giving 4.7 x 10^-4 m^3, buoyant force F_b = rho A delta h g giving 4.6 N, and scale reading F_s' = 4.6 N + 27.44 N = 32.1 N.
    answer3.png
    15.5 KB · Views: 179
Last edited:
TkoT said:
Homework Statement:: A cylindrical beaker of mass mb = 1.3 kg contains 1.5 x 10^3 ml of water. The beaker is placed on a scale and then a rock of mass mr = 2.2 kg, suspended by a massless string, is totally immersed in the water. The water level rises by 1.5 cm. The diameter of the beaker is 0.2m
a) What mass does the scale measure before the rock is lowered into the water?
b) What mass does the scale measure after the rock is lowered into the water?
Relevant Equations:: F=mg

That confuses me and I don’t understand why.
Without the rock the scale reads just the weight of the water, ##m_{\text{water}}g##. When the rock is placed under water, the water exerts buoyant force BF up. By Newton's 3rd law, the rock exerts force BF down on the water. The scale reads the sum of the two because it must exert normal force ##N=BF+m_{\text{water}}g## up to keep the water from accelerating.