Why does my adiabatic equation derivation not match the textbook answer?

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
MotoPayton
Messages
96
Reaction score
0
I have been struggling to find my mistake for over 2 hours now and I still haven't exactly matched my answers with the books solution. I feel that my method should give the same answer the solution manual obtained however they are slightly off.

I understand the book method completely.

Can someone tell me why my method doesn't work or find a way to make it work. I won't be able to sleep until I know.

Thanks

Book Question:

Figure P21.71: two diagrams of a horizontal cylinder with an insulating piston dividing it into two compartments. Diagram a is labeled T1i = 550 K and T2i = 250 K. Diagram b shows the piston at equilibrium with final temperatures T1f and T2f.


Book Solution:

Worked solution to problem P21.45 from a textbook: adiabatic gas compartments with equations (1) T1f + T2f = T1i + T2i = 800 K and (2) T1f/T2f = (550/250)^(1/1.4) = 1.756, giving T1f = 510 K and T2f = 290 K.


My solution:

Handwritten derivation on lined paper titled 'My attempt': a sketch of two connected cylinders with pistons, initial temperatures 650 K and 250 K, adiabatic relations, ideal gas law and energy equations, with boxed results T_if = 503.1 K and T_bf = 286 K.


Derivation of adiabatic equation to avoid confusion:

Handwritten derivation of adiabatic relations: T_f V_f^(Cv/R) = T_o V_o^(Cv/R); using PV = nRT, T_f^(Cv/R+1)/P_f = T_o^(Cv/R+1)/P_o; and T_f^(Cp/R)/P_f = T_o^(Cp/R)/P_o.