Why does perturbation in infinite well give zero energy correction?

7 replies · 3K views · last reply
Dammes
Messages
14
Reaction score
0
in the infinite well with small potential shown in the attachment.
I calculated the total energy by using the time independent Schrödinger equation and adding the correction energy to the equation of the slope k=(Vo/L)x.

E=h^2/8mL^2 +∫ ψkψ dx

ψ=√(2/L) sin⁡(∏/L x)

when integrating ∫ ψkψ dx between 0 and L
I got Zero, ∫ ψkψ dx=0
∴ total energy=h^2/8mL^2 +0

so what i don't understand is when adding a small potential it doesn't affect the total energy of the system? that is what it shows when i integrated it.
 
Attachments
  • Graph of V(x) against x: an infinite square well from 0 to x=L with a straight line rising from zero at x=0 to height Vo at x=L, shaded regions outside the walls, Vo marked by a bracket.
    1-D_Box.jpg
    5.1 KB · Views: 549
Dammes said:
i
when integrating ∫ ψkψ dx between 0 and L
I got Zero, ∫ ψkψ dx=0

I don't believe that integral is zero. Check your work to see if you might have made a mistake.
 
i have looked over and did it again, i still get zero.
could you please try out the integral
∫ ψkψ dx

where ψ=√(2/L) sin⁡((∏/L) x)
and
k=(Vo/L)x
 
Maybe you can show some of the steps of how you integrated [itex]\int_0^L sin^2(\pi x/L)\; x \;dx[/itex]. Note that the integrand is positive throughout the range of integration. So, it's got to yield a positive result.
 
the pictures in the attachment shows some of my working
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation of a first-order perturbation integral for an infinite square well: integral from 0 to L of sqrt(2/L) sin(pi x/L) times (V0 x/L) times sqrt(2/L) sin(pi x/L) dx, then rewritten with sin squared and the double-angle cosine identity.
    Photo on 10-7-12 at 6.37 PM.jpg
    32.3 KB · Views: 569
  • Handwritten integration working on lined paper: 2/L times the integral from 0 to L of (1/2 - 1/2 cos(2πx/L)) times V0 x / L dx, then integration by parts with u = V0 x / 2L and v = cos(2πx/L), and evaluation of the bracketed result at the limits 0 and L.
    Photo on 10-7-12 at 6.38 PM #2.jpg
    31.9 KB · Views: 582
looking over it again i see where i went wrong, i used integration in the product rule. sorry for wasting your time and thank you very much!
 
sorry, please don't read my previous comment. i see where i acutely went wrong, i have to use integration by parts. i have a problem of mixing up integration and differentiation.
hope I am correct this time
sorry and thank you
 
No need to be sorry. Glad to be of help.