Why is my spring angular frequency negative when it should be positive?

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
shanepitts
Messages
84
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


In image below

Homework Equations


Fs=-kx

The Attempt at a Solution


In image below

Handwritten derivation: a mass hanging from two springs k1 and k2 attached to a ceiling bar, with the prompt 'Show that angular frequency is w = [(k1+k2)/m]^1/2', followed by working that yields -w = [(k1+k2)/m]^1/2 and a crossed-out step marked not equal to w.


This question might be amateurish

Why does my answer equate to negative angular frequency when the given result is positive?
[/B]

 
Firstly , mg = (k1 + k2)x and not it's negative .

Secondly , what have you done here ?
Why have you equated mg to keqx ? This only gives you the equilibrium position .

Correct derivation would be - find keq , then write the formula for w interms of k and m .

Hope this helps .
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: shanepitts
Qwertywerty said:
Firstly , mg = (k1 + k2)x and not it's negative .

Secondly , what have you done here ?
Why have you equated mg to keqx ? This only gives you the equilibrium position .

Correct derivation would be - find keq , then write the formula for w interms of k and m .

Hope this helps .

Thank you, it helps. But I am wondering how do I find
keq?
 
shanepitts said:
Thank you, it helps. But I am wondering how do I find
keq?
There is a certain spring constant, keq, such that if we put a single spring with that spring constant in place of the other two springs, it would have the same effect.

So if you displace the mass by Δx, then the two springs exert a total force of F on the mass. That means (by the above definition) the effective spring constant is F/Δx.

So now try to find this total force F (from the springs) in terms of the given spring constants and Δx.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: shanepitts and fireflies
Nathanael said:
There is a certain spring constant, keq, such that if we put a single spring with that spring constant in place of the other two springs, it would have the same effect.

So if you displace the mass by Δx, then the two springs exert a total force of F on the mass. That means (by the above definition) the effective spring constant is F/Δx.

So now try to find this total force F (from the springs) in terms of the given spring constants and Δx.

Thank you