Why is Quadrant 1 Vol x 4 Incorrect for Problem #13?

  • Thread starter namehere
  • Start date
4 replies · 2K views · last reply
namehere
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Moved from a technical forum and thus no template
Here on problem #13 i am getting a false solution when only taking the volume of the region in quadrant 1 and multiplying it by 4. The later photo contains the correct solution which is obtained by taking the volume of the entire region. Can someone explain to me why the former is incorrect.
Printed textbook page listing triple integral problems 10 to 15 over solid regions E, with integrands such as y dV, xy dV, xz dV, x^2 e^y dV, (x + 2y) dV and x dV, each bounded by planes, tetrahedra, or parabolic cylinders.

Handwritten triple integral setup and evaluation on paper: a sketch of the region bounded by a paraboloid-like surface, the planes x = 1 and x = -1, and the plane z = 1 - y^2, followed by iterated integration steps ending in the result 4/3, which is crossed out.

Handwritten pencil work on tracing paper with a sketch of intersecting curves and lines at top right, followed by triple integral setup and a series of evaluated terms ending in 8/(3e).
 
namehere said:
Here on problem #13 i am getting a false solution when only taking the volume of the region in quadrant 1 and multiplying it by 4. The later photo contains the correct solution which is obtained by taking the volume of the entire region. Can someone explain to me why the former is incorrect.
Just because you are calculating a triple integral, it doesn't mean you are calculating a volume. If the integrand was ##1##, you would be, and your method would be correct. But your integrand is ##x^2e^y##, and ##e^y## is not symmetric about ##y=0##. So you don't get the same answer for each quadrant.
 
namehere said:
Here on problem #13 i am getting a false solution when only taking the volume of the region in quadrant 1 and multiplying it by 4. The later photo contains the correct solution which is obtained by taking the volume of the entire region. Can someone explain to me why the former is incorrect.
View attachment 204190
View attachment 204191
View attachment 204192

Your images are unreadable. Type out your work if you really want help.
 
I tried the problem myself. Is anyone else getting ##\frac{8}{3}e^{-1}##?
 
Eclair_de_XII said:
I tried the problem myself. Is anyone else getting ##\frac{8}{3}e^{-1}##?
Yes, that's correct.