Why position times mass is equal to 0 here (vanishes)?

2 replies · 1K views · last reply
Istiak
Messages
158
Reaction score
12
Homework Statement
Why position times mass is 0 inside Sigma summation?
Relevant Equations
F=ma
$$\sum_i m_ir_i$$

Why the term always vanishes?
Equation for total angular momentum L as a sum over particles: L = sum_i R x m_i v + sum_i r'_i x m_i v'_i + (sum_i m_i r'_i) x v + R x d/dt sum_i m_i r'_i. Below it, text says the last two terms vanish because both contain the factor sum_i m_i r'_i.
There's some more equations where the mr was vanished. But, they didn't explain why it vanish. Why the term vanish? I think that's for position 0,isn't it?
 
Attachments
  • Equation for total angular momentum L as a sum over particles i of R cross m_i v plus the sum of r'_i cross m_i v'_i plus (sum m_i r'_i) cross v plus R cross d/dt of sum m_i r'_i, followed by a sentence that the last two terms vanish because they contain the factor sum m_i r'_i.
    Screenshot from 2021-08-23 00-39-56.png
    6.2 KB · Views: 160
Last edited:
If the origin is taken as the centre of mass, then the sum is zero by definition.
 
PeroK said:
If the origin is taken as the centre of mass, then the sum is zero by definition.
I think the origin is at an arbitrary position. Vector ##\vec R## is the position of the CM of a rigid body relative to the origin. This looks like part of the proof that the angular momentum of a rigid body is the sum of the angular momentum of the CM (orbital) and about the CM (spin). The primed coordinate ##\vec {r_i}'## is the location of element ##dm_i## relative to the CM, i.e. ##\vec {r_i}'=\vec r-\vec R##. Otherwise yes, the sums are zero by definition of the CM.
Istiakshovon said:
There's some more equations where the mr was vanished. But, they didn't explain why it vanish. Why the term vanish?
Define ##\vec R## as the position of the CM relative to an arbitrary origin and ##\vec r## and ##\vec {r_i}'## respectively as the position of ##m_i## relaitve to the origin and relative to the CM. Then ##\vec r_i = \vec R+\vec {r_i}'## so you can write the position of the CM relative to the origin, $$\vec X=\frac{\sum_i m_i\vec r_i}{\sum_i m_i}=\frac{\sum_{i} m_i(\vec R+\vec {r_i}')}{\sum{_i} m_i}=\vec R+\frac{\sum{_i} m_i\vec {r_i}'}{\sum{_i} m_i}.$$ By definition, ##\vec X = \vec R##. The only way for this to be true is to have ##\dfrac{\sum_i m_i\vec {r_i}'}{\sum_i m_i}=0.##