Why pre-multiplying by e^x instead of factoring by e^(-x) gives wrong answer

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
3 replies · 1K views · last reply
chwala
Gold Member
Messages
2,854
Reaction score
436
Homework Statement
##7 \sinh x + 3 \cosh x = 9##
Relevant Equations
hyperbolic trig. equations
My question is on the highlighted part (circled in red);

Why is it wrong to pre-multiply each term by ##e^x##? to realize ,

##5e^{2x} -2-9e^x=0## as opposed to factorising by ##e^{-x} ## ?

The other steps to required solution ##x=\ln 2## is quite clear and straightforward to me.



Handwritten working solving 7 sinh x + 3 cosh x = 9 using exponential forms, reducing to 5e^x - 2e^(-x) - 9 = 0, then a boxed step e^(-x)[5e^(2x) - 9e^x - 2] = 0 crossed out with the note: cannot pre-multiply both sides by e^x as a variable.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
...because of this next step:

Handwritten integral of 1/(7 sinh x + 3 cosh x - 9) dx rewritten as integral of e^x/((5e^x + 1)(e^x - 2)) dx, then substitution e^x = u giving integral of 1/((5u+1)(u-2)) du, partial fractions, and result (1/11) ln|(e^x - 2)/(5e^x + 1)| + k.


I think i get it now...to find the solution for ##x##, we can solve it as i had indicated but for the integration bit; we have to make use of all the transforms...
 
Last edited:
That solves an entirely different question than the one you asked. The one you asked about asked for the solutions of a particular equality. What that thing is is integrating 1 divided by one of the sides of the equality.