Would overcharging an extremal black hole tear it apart?

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Thread starter kcajrenreb
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Black holes Holes
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
5 replies · 2K views
kcajrenreb
Messages
49
Reaction score
0
If you were to greatly increase the elctrical charge of an extremal Black Hole, (ie, drop a lot of electron in) what exactly would happen to it? I know the electrical repulsion would become more powerful than the gravity, so would it tear itself apart?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
I've never heard of the electromagnetic force overcoming the gravitational pull of a black hole. Are you sure about that?
 
Drakkith said:
I've never heard of the electromagnetic force overcoming the gravitational pull of a black hole. Are you sure about that?

Yes, well, its a hypothetical situation, but it can certainly happen.
 
kcajrenreb said:
If you were to greatly increase the elctrical charge of an extremal Black Hole, (ie, drop a lot of electron in) what exactly would happen to it? I know the electrical repulsion would become more powerful than the gravity, so would it tear itself apart?
If you just added more electrons to it, it would just stay an extremal black-hole with a larger charge and mass... if you magically added only charge, and not mass---well, GR says you can't do that.

Drakkith said:
I've never heard of the electromagnetic force overcoming the gravitational pull of a black hole. Are you sure about that?
Its not quite as simple as EM 'overcoming' gravity, nothing can 'overcome' the gravity. But you can get very exotic spacetime geometries... perhaps even naked singularities according to some loop quantum gravity, and pure GR extrapolations...
 
zhermes said:
If you just added more electrons to it, it would just stay an extremal black-hole with a larger charge and mass... if you magically added only charge, and not mass---well, GR says you can't do that.

Specifically imagine that you add a lot of electrons to the black hole. The electrons all have negative charges so they are repelling each other. However, those negative charges have stored potential energy and that energy has an equivalent mass (E=mc^2).

So if you try to add enough charge to blow the black hole apart, what happens is that that charge has potential energy which has mass which has gravity which keeps the black hole together.
 
twofish-quant said:
Specifically imagine that you add a lot of electrons to the black hole. The electrons all have negative charges so they are repelling each other. However, those negative charges have stored potential energy and that energy has an equivalent mass (E=mc^2).

So if you try to add enough charge to blow the black hole apart, what happens is that that charge has potential energy which has mass which has gravity which keeps the black hole together.

Thanks.