Recomendations for the best Statistical Mechanics books

[AHolico]

I'm planing on learning Statistical Mechanics by myself. I would like to hear recomendations on what you think are the best Statistical Mechanics books. My interest right now would be books that are on a undergraduate level, with detailed explanation, examples and problems, but you could also recomend higher level books for future references. Please, include your opinion on why you think is good.

If this have been discussed before, or if you know a link with info about this, let me know too by posting the complete link. Thanks in advance.

[Ambitwistor]

I'm mostly familiar with the more advanced books... I like Chandler, because it's modern and clear (but it's a short book, so it doesn't go into a lot of detail). Pathria has more detail and covers more topics; it's a thorough text. I dislike Huang, which I thought was confusing or unmotivated in places, and I also dislike Kittel and Kroemer's undergraduate Thermal Physics as being too superficial (I think they have other stat mech books though). I've heard mixed opinions of Reif; it's often recommended, but I've never used it myself.

[Mike H]

Didn't see this until today.

An undergraduate text which is reasonably modern is Thermal Physics (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0521590825/qid=1070754465/sr=1-2/ref=sr_1_2/102-0357124-2634501?v=glance&s=books) by Ralph Baierlein. Since it's available as a Dover reprint and is therefore nicely priced, Introduction to Statistical Thermodynamics (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0486652424/qid=1070754570/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/102-0357124-2634501?v=glance&s=books) by Terrell Hill would probably be worth the effort to find. As for Reif, I have no great urge to recommend it despite it being on my bookshelf from my undergrad days. I've been told An Introduction to Thermal Physics (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0201380277/qid=1070754773/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/102-0357124-2634501?v=glance&s=books) by Daniel Schroeder (of Peskin & Schroeder QFT text fame) is quite good, but have not read or used the book myself.

As for higher level texts, I second the recommendation for Pathria and to avoid Huang. If your interests are more inclined towards chemical physics, you may want to take a look at MacQuarrie, although YMMW for that one. You of course have the two volume statistical physics set from R. Kubo & Co (Springer Series in Solid State Sciences), the first of which covers equilibrium stat. mech. and the second NESM. I've been told Robert Zwanzig's NESM tome is nice, although must admit have not looked at it yet.

In terms of specialty books, Allen & Tildesley's Computer Simulation of Liquids (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0198556454/qid=1070755339/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/102-0357124-2634501?v=glance&s=books) is a nice intro to actually doing MC and MD if you're into that sort of thing. A bit on the well worn side (last update was late 1980s), but nice if you're a newcomer.

[mmwave]

I've been told An Introduction to Thermal Physics (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0201380277/qid=1070754773/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/102-0357124-2634501?v=glance&s=books) by Daniel Schroeder (of Peskin & Schroeder QFT text fame) is quite good, but have not read or used the book myself.


I just finished reading Schroeder's Thermal Physics and found it explains concepts well but could use more examples. The author expects you to read every single problem whether you do it or not and there are some problems you must do or you will be missing an important concept.

For example, you have to derive the maxwell relations yourself. Schroeder doesn't even give you the answers for use in other problems!

The main defect for self study is that there are no answers to the problems in the text whatsoever so you get no feedback. You may have really learned something or just think you have.

[roch]

Originally posted by AHolico
I'm planing on learning Statistical Mechanics by myself. I would like to hear recomendations on what you think are the best Statistical Mechanics books. My interest right now would be books that are on a undergraduate level, with detailed explanation, examples and problems, but you could also recomend higher level books for future references. Please, include your opinion on why you think is good.

If this have been discussed before, or if you know a link with info about this, let me know too by posting the complete link. Thanks in advance.

I found that the following reference is a good book to start with for statistical mechanics

Statistical Physics (Manchester Physics Series)
by F. Mandl, John Wiley and Sons Ltd

it has quite many clear examples and it carries you through the different physical concepts step by step.

[Tom Mattson]

By all means, stay away from Huang's book. I took Stat Mech with that book, and the professor was equally obtuse, so I was really lost. Wish I had known about Pathria at the time: go with that one.

[shetland]

Originally posted by Ambitwistor
I'm mostly familiar with the more advanced books... I like Chandler, because it's modern and clear (but it's a short book, so it doesn't go into a lot of detail). Pathria has more detail and covers more topics; it's a thorough text. I dislike Huang, which I thought was confusing or unmotivated in places, and I also dislike Kittel and Kroemer's undergraduate Thermal Physics as being too superficial (I think they have other stat mech books though). I've heard mixed opinions of Reif; it's often recommended, but I've never used it myself.

I'm about to start a grad level course using Chandler. The brief perusing I've done, I would agree - it appears that it gets directly to the point. As a bonus, tackles modern problems, such as monte carlo simulations.

I had Reif as an undergrad, and still refer to this today - II think Chandler might not be the best recommendation for someone who hasn't had previous experience? I would go with Reif, it spends a bit more time on some of the fundamental basics (such as random walk) and has quite a few more worked out examples.

[Steven S]

I like S.K. Ma's book Statistical Mechanics.
From a different perspective there is Roberson's "Statistical Themophysics" which is good though somewhat mathematical.

Recently I saw Leo Kadanoff had a new book out on Stat Mech that looked fairly interesting and easy to read.

[BlackBaron]

My choices would be:

Introductory level:
Thermal Physics
by C. Kittel and H. Kroemer.
(this one has pretty much the same content as "Thermal Physics" by Kittel alone, but a LOT better organized)

Advanced level:
Course of Theoretical Physics, Volume 5:
Statistical Physics, Part 1
by L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshi.tz (Lifshi.tz is without the dot, but if I put it all together the forum thinks I'm cursing and puts Lif****z)

More advanced level:
Course of Theoretical Physics, Volume 9:
Statistical Physics, Part 2
by L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshi.tz (Lifshi.tz is without the dot, but if I put it all together the forum thinks I'm cursing and puts Lif****z)

[Dr Transport]

BlackBaron has a good point, I'd just make the following additions.

Statistical Physics by F. Reif (Berkley Series). Commonly known as Baby Reif.

Statistical and Thermal Physics by F Reif.

Do the Berkely series first, it will get you going then do the second book. I then could work with Landau's book more easily.

dt