View Full Version : Time vs Space
Did Einstein meant by space-time continuous that time is just another dimension, like the other 3?
If so, why are we experiencing this one that differently? (Should this have gone in the phylosophy section?)
Severian596
Mar15-04, 07:19 AM
First thing I think of is we have no influence over our location in time. It's decided for us by nature. We can influence our locaiton in 3-space.
At least Einstein ment that the dimensions of space and the dimension of time where connected and not independent of each other. I find it hard to put them on equal footing, but itīs a good question...
pmb_phy
Mar15-04, 08:33 AM
Originally posted by cripkd
Did Einstein meant by space-time continuous that time is just another dimension, like the other 3?
If so, why are we experiencing this one that differently? (Should this have gone in the phylosophy section?)
Mathematically? Yes. Physically? No.
Ok, then what is time physically ? :)
I know this is an OLD question, and i'm asking it rethoricaly. Could someone point me to some resources on what time is, other than specutlations, at least what modern physics considers it to be , today :)
ahrkron
Mar15-04, 11:25 AM
Here (http://www.fortunecity.com/emachines/e11/86/whattime.html)'s a nice essay from Lee Smolin (at the end, there is a little bio sketch of Smolin).
Just to add my own (short version of an) answer: we define time as that which is measured by clocks. It's flux depends on relative motion and gravity, and the process by which we accumulate information can only go in one direction with respect to that flux.
You know how when you have a circle and you take a straight line perpendicular on the circle, in it's center, and sliding the circle along the line produces a cilinder?
Well this is how i see time, it generates the 4 - dimensional universe, with the 3 spatial dimension sliding in one direction along the line and perceve this movement as passing of time.
In my vision the universe, if looked upon from outside the 4 dimensional space-time continuous, would look motionless, every object having 'motion trails' that are in fact it's states in time.
Originally posted by cripkd
Did Einstein meant by space-time continuous that time is just another dimension, like the other 3?
If so, why are we experiencing this one that differently? (Should this have gone in the phylosophy section?)
You mean continuum? It is "just" another dimention, but a timelike dimention differs from a spacelike dimention in that for displacement along the timelike direction ds^2 has an overall sign difference from a dispacement along a spacelike direction. So they are indeed both mathematically and physically different types of dimention.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2012, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.