View Single Post
Q-reeus
Q-reeus is offline
#48
Oct19-11, 02:31 PM
P: 1,115
Quote Quote by DaleSpam View Post
Originally Posted by Q-reeus: "Please, concede on this one. The task of getting a consistent physics here is impossible."

Prove it.
Was meant as good advice, based on what I wrote in #40
"Oh, here's a possible fly in the ointment. Add the tiniest puff of fresh, pure mountain air inside the shell. Just a touch. Just enough to reverse the sign of shell hoop stresses and blow the amplitude up by, say, a mere factor of one million."
If you choose to reject the basic logic of that bit, then recall - you have committed to proving me wrong by calculations I consider doomed to failure - but go ahead and show that I'm the mistaken one.