Register to reply

CIRCUIT ANALYSIS: 7 resistors, 2 Indep. Volt Source, V.C.C.S, V.C.V.S. - find I

by VinnyCee
Tags: analysis, circuit, indep, resistors, source, vccs, vcvs, volt
Share this thread:
VinnyCee
#1
Jan16-07, 05:09 AM
P: 492
1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data

For the circuit below find [itex]I_1[/itex] and [itex]I_2[/itex]:




2. Relevant equations

KVL
KCL
Ohm's Law


3. The attempt at a solution

I tried the problem many times, but I always get crazy answers. It seems that every time I need one new equation to have a system of solveable equations, I have to add a new variable and hence I need another equation. It's a vicious cycle that when I get up to 13 variables for all of the V's at the resistors and different I's at nodes 1-4, I get a crazy answer like -1.35 mA for [itex]I_1[/itex]. Does that seem right?

Any suggestion on what to do about the one-more variable, one-more equation problem? I tried a super-node between nodes 2 and 3. Didn't help though.
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Physical constant is constant even in strong gravitational fields
Montreal VR headset team turns to crowdfunding for Totem
Researchers study vital 'on/off switches' that control when bacteria turn deadly
AlephZero
#2
Jan16-07, 05:27 AM
Engineering
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 7,298
Start by finding the voltages. You can write down the voltage at nodes 4, 3, 2 (two different ways) and 1 (in that order) without knowing any currents.

The two ways of getting the voltage at node 2 gives you a relation between Va and Vb, so eliminate one of them.

Then start finding the currents in terms of the voltages.

You don't need to add any more nodes.
VinnyCee
#3
Jan17-07, 04:47 AM
P: 492
Ok, so I get these for the node voltages(4,3,2,2,1):

[tex]V_4\,-\,0[/tex]

[tex]V_3\,+\,5V[/tex]

[tex]V_2\,-\,0[/tex]

[tex]V_2\,-\,2\,-\,V_4\,=\,0[/tex]
[tex]V_2\,=\,V_4\,+\,2[/tex]

[tex]V_1\,-\,0[/tex]

Are these right? If not, how am I supposed to make these voltage equations?

Also, I am stuck again, I don't know where to go from here (even if the voltage EQs are correct)!

Should I use KVL or KCL? I tried to add 2 current variables at Node 2. I used KCL there and I made some EQs for the currents there (that I had an R for) using [itex]i\,=\,\frac{V}{R}[/itex]. I am seriously stuck now though!!!

Can someone walk me through the most logical way to proceed from here, I am really confused. Thanks

AlephZero
#4
Jan17-07, 06:35 AM
Engineering
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
Thanks
P: 7,298
CIRCUIT ANALYSIS: 7 resistors, 2 Indep. Volt Source, V.C.C.S, V.C.V.S. - find I

I don't understand exactly what those expresssions are.

The way I would do this is by looking at the circuit and thinking about what you know, not trying to apply the K. laws in a mechanical way.

It's "obvious" from the circuit diagram that

V4 = VA

V3 = V4 = VA (the current source has no internal resistance so no voltage across it)

V2 = V4 - 2 = VA - 2 (from the 2V voltage source)
and also V2 = VB so VB = VA - 2

V1 = V2 - 2VA = -2 - VA

Now try and find a node which doesn't have the unknown currents I1 and I2 flowing into it: there is one, node 3. Find all the currents flowing into node 3 by Ohms law. By KCL they add up to zero. That will give you an equation for VA.

Now you know all the voltages, you can use Ohms law and KCL to find the other currents.
doodle
#5
Jan18-07, 12:04 AM
P: 161
Okay Vinny, we'll use nodal analysis or KCL for the problem if that is fine with you. And for the moment, let's avoid supernodes but stick with the conventional nodes.

To get you started, do this for me: Note down the 4 equations corresponding to the 4 nodes using KCL, i.e., the sum of currents entering/leaving the node equals zero. And do that with only the variables V1, V2, V3, V4, I1, I2 and no other variables.

Quote Quote by AlephZero View Post
...
V3 = V4 = VA (the current source has no internal resistance so no voltage across it)
Not true. The current source could present a voltage drop/gain without any internal resistance.
VinnyCee
#6
Jan18-07, 12:08 AM
P: 492
OK, I have added 3 currents to the diagram (in green).



[tex]V_4\,=\,V_a\,=\,V_3[/tex]

[tex]V_2\,=\,V_4\,-\,2\,=\,V_b[/tex]

[tex]V_b\,=\,V_a\,-\,2[/tex]

[tex]V_1\,=\,V_\,2\,-\,2\,V_a[/tex]

Just what you said above. Now, I use [itex]i\,=\,\frac{V}{R}[/itex] to get the new currents in green.

KCL: [tex]I_3\,+\,I_4\,+\,I_5\,+\,\frac{V_b}{4K\Omega}\,=\,0[/tex]

[tex]I_3\,=\,\frac{(5\,V)}{4000\Omega}\,=\,0.00125\,A\,=\,1.25\,mA[/tex]

[tex]I_4\,=\,\frac{V_2\,-\,V_3}{2000\Omega}[/tex]

[tex]I_5\,=\,\frac{V_1\,-\,V_3}{4000\Omega}[/tex]

Now if I combine those four equations above:

[tex]\frac{V_2\,-\,V_3}{2000\Omega}\,+\,\frac{V_1\,-\,V_3}{4000\Omega}\,+\,\frac{V_4\,-\,2}{4000\Omega}\,=\,-1.25\,A[/tex]

How do you proceed?
VinnyCee
#7
Jan18-07, 12:23 AM
P: 492
Ok, lets try NODE 1 first:

[tex]\left(\frac{-V_1}{1000\Omega}\right)\,+\,\left[\left(\frac{V_3\,-\,V_1}{4000\Omega}\right)\,+\,\left(\frac{V_4\,-\,V_1}{3000\Omega}\right)\right]\,=\,I_1[/tex]

Is that correct?
doodle
#8
Jan18-07, 12:30 AM
P: 161
Quote Quote by VinnyCee View Post
[tex]V_4\,=\,V_a\,=\,V_3[/tex]
As I have said earlier, to claim that V3 = V4 is incorrect. Read my earlier post.

Quote Quote by VinnyCee View Post
Just what you said above. Now, I use [itex]i\,=\,\frac{V}{R}[/itex] to get the new currents in green.

KCL: [tex]I_3\,+\,I_4\,+\,I_5\,+\,\frac{V_b}{4K\Omega}\,=\,0[/tex]
Well yes, that is right. But you do know that the above expression gives only 1 nodal equation, that is, the nodal equation for node 3. You would have to do the same thing for the other 3 nodes.

Quote Quote by VinnyCee View Post
[tex]I_3\,=\,\frac{(5\,V)}{4000\Omega}\,=\,0.00125\,A\,=\,1.25\,mA[/tex]
This is not right- you're forgetting V3.

Quote Quote by VinnyCee View Post
[tex]I_4\,=\,\frac{V_2\,-\,V_3}{2000\Omega}[/tex]

[tex]I_5\,=\,\frac{V_1\,-\,V_3}{4000\Omega}[/tex]
These are correct.

And yes, combine these terms into an equation. Note that Vb = V2. Also, at the moment, let's forget about V2 = V4-2. Now write down again the nodal equation for node 3.
doodle
#9
Jan18-07, 12:32 AM
P: 161
Quote Quote by VinnyCee View Post
Ok, lets try NODE 1 first:

[tex]\left(\frac{-V_1}{1000\Omega}\right)\,+\,\left[\left(\frac{V_3\,-\,V_1}{4000\Omega}\right)\,+\,\left(\frac{V_4\,-\,V_1}{3000\Omega}\right)\right]\,=\,I_1[/tex]

Is that correct?
That's right. :)
VinnyCee
#10
Jan18-07, 12:41 AM
P: 492
Cool! NODE 2 now:

[tex]I_1\,+\,\left(\frac{-V_2}{2000\Omega}\right)\,+\,\left(\frac{V_2\,-\,V_3}{2000\Omega}\right)\,=\,I_2[/tex]

Is that right?

Is [itex]V_b[/itex] still equal to [itex]V_2[/itex]?
doodle
#11
Jan18-07, 12:52 AM
P: 161
Quote Quote by VinnyCee View Post
Cool! NODE 2 now:

[tex]I_1\,+\,\left(\frac{-V_2}{2000\Omega}\right)\,+\,\left(\frac{V_2\,-\,V_3}{2000\Omega}\right)\,=\,I_2[/tex]

Is that right?

Is [itex]V_b[/itex] still equal to [itex]V_2[/itex]?
A small mistake here, check the equation again. Yes, Vb = V2. Two more nodal equations to go (nodes 3 and 4). Keep it up!
VinnyCee
#12
Jan18-07, 01:27 AM
P: 492
The mistake fixed?

[tex]I_1\,+\,\left(\frac{-V_2}{2000\Omega}\right)\,+\,\left(\frac{V_3\,-\,V_2}{2000\Omega}\right)\,=\,I_2[/tex]
doodle
#13
Jan18-07, 01:29 AM
P: 161
That's right, now move on to the other 2 equations.
VinnyCee
#14
Jan18-07, 01:36 AM
P: 492
OK, for NODE 3:

[tex]\left(\frac{V_1\,-\,V_3}{4000\Omega}\right)\,+\,\left(\frac{V_2\,-\,V_3}{2000\Omega}\right)\,+\,\left(\frac{5\,-\,V_3}{4000\Omega}\right)\,=\,\left(\frac{-V_2}{4000\Omega}\right)[/tex]

And for NODE 4:

[tex]\left(\frac{-V_4}{4000\Omega}\right)\,+\,\left(\frac{V_1\,-\,V_4}{3000\Omega}\,+\,I_2\right)\,=\,\left(\frac{V_2}{4000\Omega}\righ t)[/tex]

Are those right? Or did I mess up the path with the 5V independent voltage source and 4Kohm resistor?
doodle
#15
Jan18-07, 01:57 AM
P: 161
Very good. Now, I would like to have these equations simplified a bit. As an example, for node 4, you wrote:

[tex]\left(\frac{-V_4}{4000\Omega}\right)\,+\,\left(\frac{V_1\,-\,V_4}{3000\Omega}\right)\,+\,I_2\,=\,\left(\frac{V_2}{4000\Omega}\righ t)[/tex]

I want it simplified to become:

[tex]\frac{1}{3}V_1 - \frac{1}{4}V_2 - \frac{7}{12}V_4 + I_2 = 0[/tex]

Specifically, I have ignored the '000 in the R's (the V's are still as before but the I's are now in milliamperes) and arranged the equations such that on the left side are the unknowns, ordered V1, V2, V3, V4, I1, I2 and on the right side, the constants. There's a reason for doing all these of course. :)

Do the same for the other 3 equations and we will proceed from there.
VinnyCee
#16
Jan18-07, 02:21 AM
P: 492
NODE3: [tex]V_1\,+\,3\,V_2\,-\,4\,V_3\,=\,-5[/tex]

NODE2: [tex]2000\,I_1\,-\,2000\,I_2\,-\,2\,V_2\,+\,V_3\,=\,0[/tex]

NODE1: [tex]-4000\,I_1\,-\,\frac{19}{3}\,V_1\,+\,V_3\,+\,\frac{4}{3}\,V_4\,=\,0[/tex]

Right?
doodle
#17
Jan18-07, 02:48 AM
P: 161
Okay, that's close enough. Let me edit a bit...

Node 1: [tex]-\frac{19}{12}V_1 + \frac{1}{4}V_3 + \frac{1}{3}V_4 - I_1 = 0[/tex]

Node 2: [tex]-V_2 + \frac{1}{2}V_3 + I_1 - I_2 = 0[/tex]

Node 3: [tex]V_1 + 3V_2 - 4V_3 = -5[/tex]

Node 4: [tex]\frac{1}{3}V_1 - \frac{1}{4}V_2 - \frac{7}{12}V_4 + I_2 = 0[/tex]

I prefer to have the equations in the manner above, with the I's in milliamperes. Now, note that there's a voltage source across nodes 1 and 2, similarly a voltage source between nodes 2 and 4. Due to that, we ought to form a supernode, that is, to combine nodes 1, 2 and 4 into a single supernode. The result is the elimination of the unknown variables I1 and I2. To do that, try combining equations 1, 2 and 4 above into a single equation such that the unknowns I1 and I2 disappear.
VinnyCee
#18
Jan18-07, 03:14 AM
P: 492
OK, I did N1 + N2 + N4.

[tex]-\frac{5}{4}\,V_1\,-\,\frac{5}{4}\,V_2\,+\,\frac{3}{4}\,V_3\,-\,\frac{1}{4}\,V_4\,=\,0[/tex]

Is this what the supernode would look like?



Register to reply

Related Discussions
CIRCUIT ANALYSIS: 2 resistors, Indep. Current Source, V.C.C.S - find v0 Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework 37
CIRCUITS: Three resistors, two Indep. Voltage sources, one Indep. Current source Introductory Physics Homework 5
CIRCUITS: Current Controlled Voltage source, Indep. Voltage source, Four resistors... Introductory Physics Homework 1
CIRCUIT ANALYSIS: Use superposition - 2 Current source, 1 Voltage source, 4 resistors Advanced Physics Homework 6
EECS: Find i_0 in a circuit with 4 resistors and 1 indep. current source Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework 5