
#1
Nov507, 03:50 PM

P: 233

Has anyone taken a look at it yet? I would kind of like to get my grubby hands on it, but I'm not about to shell out $130. Thanks, but no thanks.




#2
Nov507, 04:05 PM

Astronomy
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 22,809

http://www.amazon.com/CanonicalRela...dp/0521842638/ Earlier Amazon was listing it for $130, I think, but when it actually came out the price posted was $140. The Cambridge website has more information about the book, including the full Table of Contents. http://www.cambridge.org/catalogue/c...=9780521842631 It looks like it could be a useful book, when institutional libraries have it on the shelf. I'll certainly walk over to the physics library and peruse, but shell out bux for it I'll not. In case anyone is curious, it has salesrank around #67,000 at the moment. I've seen worse. Despite its whopping price, the book is selling. 



#3
Nov607, 07:58 PM

P: 32

I have a copy if you have any questions about it. A nice feature is that there are well over two hundred pages devoted to mathematical methods which is quite difficult to find all in one place.




#4
Nov907, 07:49 AM

P: 124

Thomas Thiemann's book
I have it, it's absolutely amazing and in my opinion worth the price tag. I was going to get it a few months ago but I decided to wait until I got to uni' so that I could use the 15% discount that Cambridge students get on CUP books.




#5
Nov907, 11:00 AM

P: 344

Are there major differences between the published book and the draft available from the arxiv?
BTW, does someone have information on Kiefer's (also expensive) book? Thanks, Christine 



#6
Nov907, 11:12 AM

Astronomy
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 22,809

In case anyone wants to look I will post the link http://arxiv.org/abs/grqc/0110034 this was posted in October 2001 and the arxiv version has not been revised or updated since then. So the actual published version is different by 5 or 6 years the 2001 draft is 301 pages. a lot has changed since 2001 and the published version has twice as many pages so I would guess it is totally different 



#7
Nov907, 11:30 AM

P: 344

Hi Marcus,
You're correct; I see now that the preprint has not been updated. Thanks Christine 



#8
Nov907, 11:58 AM

Astronomy
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 22,809

For those of us who are not students at Cambridge, enjoying a 15 percent discount, there is always the hope that the book will be available secondhand for less. Or that the local campus library will soon have the book available to lend. From my standpoint, in the USA, part of the price must be due to the declining dollar. Anyway, it sounds like Geoff and Perturbation are pretty happy with it! 



#9
Nov907, 12:11 PM

P: 344

Hi Marcus,
The book is expensive, yes. But I can purchase it. The problem that I'm facing now is to choose from a huge list of books which one(s) I'll be purchasing for myself as a christmas gift. I must take the opportunity that US$1.00 now is "only" R$1.75 (Brazilian reals). Christine 



#10
Nov1507, 01:18 PM

P: 27

I stumbled upon the book by accident when browsing at the UC Davis Library yesterday when I was trying to buy printer paper. I couldn't hold back, I bought the book and wrote a review of it (or what I've read so far, I'm plowing through chapter 4 as we speak).
The content from the introduction to the last page of chapter 33 totals some 774 pages long, 34 pages additionally are used for the bibliography, and to top it off it's hardcover (which is probably why it's so expensive). Personally I prefer hard cover books because they're durable, and most books I have I read many times (I don't have a TV, so I read for enjoyment...so having paperback books is a bad idea since they get well worn fast; for example my copy of Misner, Thorne, and Wheeler's Gravitation is already starting to fall apart after two years of intensive study!). If you're not a diehard reader like me, you'll probably want to wait for the paperback version to come out...but this may be a year or two, I don't know how Cambridge University Press works :( 



#11
Nov1507, 01:29 PM

Astronomy
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 22,809

I look forward to reading the review at your blog! 



#12
Nov1507, 03:17 PM

P: 76

Loved your review of the book, Angry.
I just don't have the will, mental stamina, mathematical background, and $130 lying around to go out and get that monster. 



#13
Nov1507, 03:40 PM

P: 27

Heck, my cold is so bad I sleep only a few hours at night. More time to study this fantastic text! The book is very mathematical, but unlike your average "high level" math textbook Thiemann can actually write in a very engaging manner. That perhaps saddens me most seeing a math textbook being little more than a grocery list of definitions and theorems. It's so...boring! I don't know about others, but after reading a topology textbook for the first time, my initial response was "So...what? How is this 'open ball' thing useful in anyway? It seems like this author just needed a few extra bucks and decided to write a textbook to get by." (A very smart maneuver for math professors ) I don't know how, but Thiemann actually makes the math come alive. I would love to meet Dr. Thiemann sometime, he really knows his stuff and can communicate it clearly with ease. Compare this to another book I got recently: Lectures on Quantum Mechanics by Paul Dirac! For the lazy layperson that hasn't read anything by Dirac, Dirac is notorious for letting the math do the explanation. (I actually had a T.A. lead my very first calculus section that couldn't speak English, he spoke Chinese. He also had to learn arabic numerals too; it was fascinating watching him work using Chinese numerals and translate them into arabic ones! In order to communicate, we had to write equations on the chalk board and give hand waves, grunt "Huh?" when we got lost, and he would in turn go step by step on the chalk board with what he'd do grunting "Uhuh?"; Paul Dirac was, as I understand it, exactly like this during a lecture. Except when asked a question to clarify an equation, Dirac would simply shake his head.) I also loved the forward; I love hearing about people's stories about how they decided to come into their respective fields. And Dr. Christopher Isham is a researcher I have the utmost regard for, reading his story  even if it was 3 paragraphs long (out of 2 pages)  was a pleasure. Dr. Isham appears to have tremendous faith in Thiemann though. Isham writes in the forward: emphasis added. No pressure Dr. Thiemann, but the entire fate of canonical quantum gravity lies on your shoulders! 



#14
Nov1507, 04:26 PM

P: 76

I may have to look into this book, are there any excerpts online? 



#15
Nov1507, 04:34 PM

P: 27

The closest thing to an excerpt is from Amazon.com. Just what I could find... 



#16
Nov1507, 04:39 PM

P: 76

Thanks very much for all your help Angry 



#17
Nov1507, 04:47 PM

P: 27

Now if Thiemann would only pay me commission I'd be set




#18
Jan2808, 05:43 AM

P: 21

The book is now much cheaper, also amazon lets you search in the book now.
Any more comments from people who have read the book already? 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Peter Woit's book is out (Thomas Larsson just received a copy)  Beyond the Standard Model  28  
George Thomas Ebook wanted  Calculus  3  
Thiemann's Latest  Conroversy  Beyond the Standard Model  2  
Thiemann's time  Beyond the Standard Model  2  
Thiemann's new theory  Cosmology  4 