Register to reply 
Scalar waves, is this a complete fabrication? 
Share this thread: 
#1
Jun408, 12:26 PM

P: 516

Many of you will have heard of these. Does anyone knowledgeable on conventional electromagnetics, suspect there may be some truth in it?



#2
Jun408, 02:31 PM

Mentor
P: 41,334




#3
Jun408, 03:27 PM

P: 516

Why don't you transfer it into the scepticism and debunking section. Hopefully some experts from here will give it an informed assessment.



#4
Jun408, 04:06 PM

Mentor
P: 41,334

Scalar waves, is this a complete fabrication?



#5
Jun408, 04:08 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 1,571

Frankly, I'm with berkeman with this.
Barring your location of a credible reference there is nothing to discuss. Experimental error is easy to achieve. An actual odd result is a different matter. 


#6
Jun408, 05:02 PM

P: 516




#7
Jun408, 05:34 PM

Mentor
P: 41,334

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/neutrino/missing.html . 


#8
Jun408, 05:40 PM

Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 2,734

You must have watched the NOVA program on neutrinos last night. Very good.



#9
Jun408, 05:55 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 1,571

At least I've never seen a good explanation. There is also the sticky in this section which has quite a list. 


#10
Jun508, 03:37 AM

P: 516

Here's another such case perhaps. The dynamical Casimir effect, that is claimed to indicate fluctuations of vacuum and standing scalar waves between two mirrors, or something like that:
http://www.lanl.gov/orgs/t/publicati...it_Casimir.pdf Count Iblis, I hope you have some insights on this. 


#11
Jun1008, 01:00 AM

P: 4,512

Using only the classical Maxwell equations on the spacetime of general relativity, I obtain a currentcharge wave propagating at c, accompanied by a Coulomb wave (scalar to you folks). I was looking for chargecurrent density solutions that satisfied Laplace's equation. I'd have to look again to see if there were a standing wave solution in the potential that didn't transport charge or contain charge.



#12
Jun1008, 01:07 AM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 12,501




#13
Jun1008, 01:53 AM

P: 516

Tom Bearden's scalar waves are supposed to be longitudinal. Is your Coulomb wave so? What about the currentcharge wave, is it longitudinal? 


#14
Jun1008, 01:54 AM

P: 516




#15
Jun1008, 02:17 PM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 12,501

I was talking about the post above mine. If we have a formal reference, we can use it, but personal theories will result in the thread being locked, and penalty points will be assigned.



#16
Jun1008, 02:26 PM

P: 4,512

I try to imagine what physics would be like without mathematics. I think it would be like this "scalar wave" business. A lot of guys coming up with ideas and swapping lies 'cause math is hard.
In leaving out the rather vague notion that fields originate on charge and that charge is associated with massive matter, using only Maxwell's 4 equations, after 5 or so pages of rather dense calculations I come up with a nonphysical result. Reading these posts, it occured to me that a standing wave may cancel the charge density and leave a propagating coulomb potenital in place. Ivan Nothing new is invented, nor publishable. I was simply doing a little survey of classical electromagnetism. I'm certainly not advancing a 'personal theory'. I've read some of the wikipedia article on this scalar potential. If it's accurate there's nothing in common with this goofy notion of bubbles between magnets 'n stuff. 


#17
Jun1008, 02:30 PM

Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 12,501

Okay, but please avoid speculation or personal derivations. Something like this requires that we stick to papers publilshed in mainstream journals.



#18
Jun1008, 05:33 PM

P: 4,512

now it's personal derivations. can't have any of that going on. I think perhaps personal opinions are a bit of a problem, as well.



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
From the scalar of curvature (NewmanPenrose formalism) to the Ricci scalar  Special & General Relativity  8  
Longitudinal Scalar Waves?  Beyond the Standard Model  0  
Could scalar waves do thisallow me this question for physicists and meteorologists..  General Discussion  10  
Gravity and Scalar Waves  General Physics  0  
Scalar Waves  General Discussion  2 