Difficult Questions


by Adjuster
Tags: difficult
Adjuster
Adjuster is offline
#1
Jan5-10, 12:58 PM
P: 206
Hello,

Here is a question from a newcomer to this forum, in need of advice on what best to do about a certain type of questioning. I've fouled up handling this, and would rather not repeat that mistake.

The problem begins when someone asks something on a topic which he or she appears to have little knowledge of. On receiving a reply, the original poster raises objections to the answer, based on arguments that do not agree with accepted ideas on the subject in hand. The argument continues as they proceed to ask - or demand - answers to further questions, always in line with their eccentric ideas about the subject. It seems quite difficult to avoid this sort of thing turning into a slanging match - how best to proceed?

I would be grateful for your comments.

Adjuster
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Simplicity is key to co-operative robots
Chemical vapor deposition used to grow atomic layer materials on top of each other
Earliest ancestor of land herbivores discovered
berkeman
berkeman is offline
#2
Jan5-10, 01:27 PM
Mentor
berkeman's Avatar
P: 39,589
Quote Quote by Adjuster View Post
Hello,

Here is a question from a newcomer to this forum, in need of advice on what best to do about a certain type of questioning. I've fouled up handling this, and would rather not repeat that mistake.

The problem begins when someone asks something on a topic which he or she appears to have little knowledge of. On receiving a reply, the original poster raises objections to the answer, based on arguments that do not agree with accepted ideas on the subject in hand. The argument continues as they proceed to ask - or demand - answers to further questions, always in line with their eccentric ideas about the subject. It seems quite difficult to avoid this sort of thing turning into a slanging match - how best to proceed?

I would be grateful for your comments.

Adjuster
One thing that helps is if you can give them a link or two to further (mainstream) reading on the matter. Then it's not just you giving the answer. Also, definitely use the Report button if a thread has problems or is degrading. The mentors will take a look and see if anything should be done.
story645
story645 is offline
#3
Jan5-10, 02:54 PM
P: 670
Quote Quote by Adjuster View Post
The problem begins when someone asks something on a topic which he or she appears to have little knowledge of.
You got me interested so I looked through your posting history and saw the crazy repeating key thread. When you're dealing with someone like that, just shrug it off and walk away. The guy didn't even realize that what he considered the answer had already been said by someone in prose form. That's the kind of situation where it doesn't really matter what you put down, 'cause the poster wanted someone to give him a cookie cutter solution he could run off and try.

Adjuster
Adjuster is offline
#4
Jan6-10, 08:15 AM
P: 206

Difficult Questions


Quote Quote by berkeman View Post
One thing that helps is if you can give them a link or two to further (mainstream) reading on the matter. Then it's not just you giving the answer. Also, definitely use the Report button if a thread has problems or is degrading. The mentors will take a look and see if anything should be done.
Thank you Berkemann,

I suppose that there comes a point when it's best to stop replying. There is a temptation to have the last word, - to be resisted, I guess.

Adjuster


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Difficult Precalc Questions Precalculus Mathematics Homework 5
Difficult polynomial questions Calculus & Beyond Homework 6
Easy Questions, Difficult Answers Linear & Abstract Algebra 18
Some difficult questions Chemistry 14
A few questions i'm finding difficult. Introductory Physics Homework 9