Chloroplasts as organisms


by FireBones
Tags: chloroplasts, organisms
FireBones
FireBones is offline
#1
Mar20-10, 11:56 AM
P: 103
I know that most people believe that chloroplasts and mitochondria evolved in eukaryotic cells by endosymbiosis, but has there been any push (or even any discussion) on whether they should actually be considered independent organisms living in symbiosis with the cell?

They fulfill most (if not all) the criteria for a "living thing."

My efforts at research through google ran up against a brick wall since the keywords I thought of all led me to the endosymbiosis theory itself rather than the question of classification.
Phys.Org News Partner Biology news on Phys.org
Humpback protections downgrade clears way for pipeline
Researchers discover the most effective animal signal strategies
Maine baby lobster decline could end high catches
mazinse
mazinse is offline
#2
Mar20-10, 04:30 PM
P: 190
They are not considered living organisms in present cells because they lost a lot of genes necessary to survive independently and need host proteins to perform functions for them
FireBones
FireBones is offline
#3
Mar20-10, 06:18 PM
P: 103
Quote Quote by mazinse View Post
They are not considered living organisms in present cells because they lost a lot of genes necessary to survive independently and need host proteins to perform functions for them
Thanks, but I was under the impression that the ability to survive independently was not required so long as the entity could undergo metabolism (at all)...aren't there several bacteria that require this type of help as well?

mazinse
mazinse is offline
#4
Mar20-10, 06:25 PM
P: 190

Chloroplasts as organisms


Quote Quote by FireBones View Post
Thanks, but I was under the impression that the ability to survive independently was not required so long as the entity could undergo metabolism (at all)...aren't there several bacteria that require this type of help as well?
well thats an interesting way of putting it. if you really want to hit that gray area then yeah, think of them that way.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Thoughts on Chloroplasts and Mitochodria Biology 14
Are all organisms relatives of each other? Biology 6
pressure on organisms Introductory Physics Homework 3
putting chloroplasts into animal cells? Biology 4
organisms that are almost all restriction endonucleases isolated from? Biology 2