
#1
Apr1712, 06:26 AM

P: 135

Why are pure numbers like 1 , 2 , 3 .... dimensionless and Avogadro's Number, Plank's Constant, Gravitational Constant dimensional ?




#2
Apr1712, 08:11 AM

Math
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 38,894

Because the latter have dimensions! The Gravitational constant, G, appears in F= GmM/r^2. In the metric system (mks), r has units of meters, both m and M have units of kg so that "mM/r^2" have units of [itex]kg^2/m^2[/itex]. F, a force, has units of "[itex]kg m^2/sec^2[/itex]". In order to make the units on both sides of the equation the same, G must have units of [itex]1/(kg sec^2)[/itex].
Avogadro's number is the number of molecules per mole. The number of molecules does not depend on any units so Avogadro's number has units of [itex]mol^{1}[/itex]. Plank's constant is the "h" in [itex]h\nu[/itex] where E is energy, and so has units of [itex]kg m^2/sec^2[/itex] while [itex]\nu[/itex], a frequency, is "number of cycles per second". "Number of cycles", like "number of molecules" is just a number without units. Since we need to have left "[itex]kg m^2/sec^2[/itex]" we need . That means that h must have units of [itex]kg m^2[/itex] in the numerator and one "sec" in the denominator: [itex]kg m^2/sec[/itex]. 



#3
Apr1712, 08:24 AM

P: 135

Why is 1/2 in 1/2 mv^2 dimensionless ?




#4
Apr1712, 08:31 AM

P: 5

Dimensionless Quantities
Because mv^2 has the unit same as that of Energy.




#5
Apr1712, 08:43 AM

P: 135





#6
Apr1712, 09:58 AM

P: 642

Let this constant (which turns out to be 1/2) be C. Let k and k' be different dimensionless numbers. It's quite easy to see that we can set up
[tex]C\cdot k\cdot \left(1\ \mathrm{J}\right)=k'\cdot\left(1\ \mathrm{J}\right)[/tex] And so [tex]C=\dfrac{k'}{k}[/tex] And so C's dimensionless. I wanted to point out that c, the speed of light, is dimensionless, equal to 1, in Special (and General, I'd imagine) Relativity. Basically, [itex]299792458\ \mathrm{m}=1\ \mathrm{s}[/itex]. I've always found it useful to think of units as constants that are, in some cases, incompatible with one another, so the simplest form is just their product. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Dimensionless physical quantities  Introductory Physics Homework  2  
Dimensionless equations  General Physics  3  
dimensionless anaylsis  Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework  0  
is the radius dimensionless?  Introductory Physics Homework  3  
dimensionless schrodinger EQ  Advanced Physics Homework  2 