Register to reply

What is the best book for linear algebra?

Share this thread:
Jow
#1
Nov10-12, 04:37 PM
P: 67
I want to beginning learning linear algebra. I will be studying it on my own, so I was wondering what the best book would be.
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Experts defend operational earthquake forecasting, counter critiques
EU urged to convert TV frequencies to mobile broadband
Sierra Nevada freshwater runoff could drop 26 percent by 2100
micromass
#2
Nov10-12, 04:44 PM
Mentor
micromass's Avatar
P: 18,331
Depends on you. There is no objective best book, there are only book which you like or dislike.

Anyway, what kind of math do you know already?? Are you familiar with matrices and determinants?? Are you familiar with proofs?? "Analytic" geometry?? Abstract algebra?? Are you wanting to be a physicist or a mathematician?? etc.
Jow
#3
Nov10-12, 05:45 PM
P: 67
Quote Quote by micromass View Post
Depends on you. There is no objective best book, there are only book which you like or dislike.

Anyway, what kind of math do you know already?? Are you familiar with matrices and determinants?? Are you familiar with proofs?? "Analytic" geometry?? Abstract algebra?? Are you wanting to be a physicist or a mathematician?? etc.
I want to be a physicist. I am familiar with proofs, although only basic geometry proofs (high school stuff). By analytic geometry I assume you mean coordinate geometry, so yes I am familiar with it. I am not familiar with matrices or determinants or abstract algebra. I have done Calculus 1 on my own and some of Calculus 2.

Klungo
#4
Nov10-12, 06:09 PM
P: 136
What is the best book for linear algebra?

One good question would be:

Do you want a computational emphasis on linear algebra?

Or a more theoretical approach? (Which requires proficiency in proof writing and logical reasoning)

Usually, the proof based course covers the computational side in sufficient detail. Think of the theoretical side as making all the formulas and algorithms in the computational linear algebra course legitimate.
Jow
#5
Nov10-12, 07:44 PM
P: 67
Quote Quote by Klungo View Post
One good question would be:

Do you want a computational emphasis on linear algebra?

Or a more theoretical approach? (Which requires proficiency in proof writing and logical reasoning)

Usually, the proof based course covers the computational side in sufficient detail. Think of the theoretical side as making all the formulas and algorithms in the computational linear algebra course legitimate.
Well I am sure I would enjoy a theoretical approach more, but I think a more computational emphasis would be better for me. The reason I am self studying all of these topics is so that when I get into university I will already have a decent understanding of the topics.
chiro
#6
Nov11-12, 12:38 AM
P: 4,573
Quote Quote by Jow View Post
Well I am sure I would enjoy a theoretical approach more, but I think a more computational emphasis would be better for me. The reason I am self studying all of these topics is so that when I get into university I will already have a decent understanding of the topics.
While I do recommend getting familar with things before the course, I would also not recommend doing too much before a course starts unless the course is really demanding, covers a lot of stuff, and goes very quickly.

The reason is simple: if you learn everything before the course starts and then go in, you will get very bored very quickly.

The thing is that you need to understand what the expectations are of the teachers giving it, and most teachers will not expect that their students have done a lot of study on the subject which means that they will make things really basic and spend more time teaching the material to people as if they were expecting that this is all new and unfamiliar to the students (and for the majority it should be).

If you haven't started university, then I would bet that your first classes won't be too heavy in terms of expectations relative to later years: I'm not saying they won't be serious, but I am saying that universities know that the transition to university life, particularly for subjects like physics, mathematics, engineering, computer science, and similar kinds of subjects will be daunting.

I don't know your situation, your level of understanding and knowledge, or your aptitude, but I can say that if you spend too much time learning stuff before you start the class, then you will be absolutely bored out of your brain and it may have negative consequences for your grades and also for your attitude of the subject in a detrimental way.

So prepare by all means, but don't end up doing the course (or too much of it) before the course actually starts.
Jow
#7
Nov11-12, 12:28 PM
P: 67
chiro, the reason I am doing this all is to prepare myself, but also because I am bored to death in high school. I must assure you that your concerns of my boredom in later years affecting my grades will not be a problem. Very few things can come between me and my grades.
But that is beside the point. Thank you for your concern, but I really just want a book recommendation.
DrummingAtom
#8
Nov11-12, 01:19 PM
P: 661
For my style of learning the best book has been Poole's Linear Algebra. It's very visual and intuitive in terms of introducing the topics. I don't learn well when the generalizations happen at the start and that's exactly what he avoids in his book. He starts with a simple case and then moves onto making it more abstract and general.

I have Axler's book also which is very rigorous in comparison and I couldn't follow anything when I first got it. After getting through most of Poole's book I can understand much more of what Axler is saying because I have a simple picture of all the concepts. If you can learn from generalizations and abstractions from the start then get a book like Axler's, otherwise get Poole's. Some of my friends do actually learn starting with abstractions but I certainly don't.
Vargo
#9
Nov12-12, 03:01 PM
P: 350
There are lots of books on the subject and it is hard to agree on a best book. I learned from Hoffman and Kunze, but that's a bit dry for some (see Amazon reviews). Since you want to go into physics, a good Russian standard would probably serve you well.

http://www.amazon.com/Linear-Algebra.../dp/048663518X
micromass
#10
Nov12-12, 03:19 PM
Mentor
micromass's Avatar
P: 18,331
Quote Quote by Vargo View Post
There are lots of books on the subject and it is hard to agree on a best book. I learned from Hoffman and Kunze, but that's a bit dry for some (see Amazon reviews). Since you want to go into physics, a good Russian standard would probably serve you well.

http://www.amazon.com/Linear-Algebra.../dp/048663518X
Shilov is an excellent book!! But are you sure it is suitable for somebody who doesn't know anything about matrices??
Vargo
#11
Nov12-12, 03:54 PM
P: 350
Good point. I am definitely not sure whether it is suitable for someone still in high school who does not know about matrices. But its a Dover book, so it is cheap :) At least, it would be great alongside another book that is more elementary. In the worst case scenario, if it is too hard, you can put it on the shelf and take it down again when you are ready.
halo31
#12
Nov12-12, 04:25 PM
P: 51
Best book would be Matrix Analysis and Applied Linear Algebra Book by Carl Meyer's. The author has even put it out for free as a pdf file with the entire solutions manual on his website.
Jow
#13
Nov12-12, 05:41 PM
P: 67
Quote Quote by Vargo View Post
Good point. I am definitely not sure whether it is suitable for someone still in high school who does not know about matrices. But its a Dover book, so it is cheap :) At least, it would be great alongside another book that is more elementary. In the worst case scenario, if it is too hard, you can put it on the shelf and take it down again when you are ready.
Due to these comments I have looked into matrices. I know how to add, subtract and find their inverses, as well as how to solve system of equations and vector combination problems. Not to say that I know a lot about matrices, but I at least know some of the basics.
Vargo
#14
Nov12-12, 07:04 PM
P: 350
Quote Quote by Jow View Post
Due to these comments I have looked into matrices. I know how to add, subtract and find their inverses, as well as how to solve system of equations and vector combination problems. Not to say that I know a lot about matrices, but I at least know some of the basics.
It sounds like you are pretty motivated. Any book that you can learn the basics from should be fine. Halo's recommendation is available online so that would be a good place to start. As the author states in the preface, it is tilted toward computational applications. If you get into the middle of it and then want more proofs, you could easily supplement it with a book more oriented toward the basic theory such as Shilov, Hoffman/Kunze, Axler, or Lang. (I am suspicious Axler because he put "done right" in his title.)
Sankaku
#15
Nov17-12, 10:23 PM
P: 717
Two free books:

http://linear.ups.edu/

http://joshua.smcvt.edu/linearalgebra/

and some online notes:

http://tutorial.math.lamar.edu/Class...lg/LinAlg.aspx


Axler, Shilov, Fiedberg, and Hoffman are all good books but better suited to a more advanced (second?) course.

One piece of advice: There is no such thing as too much linear algebra!
mathwonk
#16
Nov20-12, 05:44 PM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
mathwonk's Avatar
P: 9,488
here's another nice book for beginners, written by a stanford professor. the new copy is $125 but the used copy is only $1.

http://www.amazon.com/Elementary-Lin.../dp/0879011211


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Book for Linear Algebra Science & Math Textbooks 2
Linear Algebra book Science & Math Textbooks 14
I need a better Linear Algebra book Science & Math Textbooks 13
Another Linear Algebra Book Academic Guidance 1
Best linear algebra book Science & Math Textbooks 8