
#1
Mar407, 05:30 AM

P: 61

If X and Y are gamma distributed random variables, then the ratio X/Y, I was told follows a beta distribution, but all I can find so for is that the ratio X/(X+Y) follows a beta distrinbution.
So is it true that X/Y follows a beta distribution? 



#2
Mar407, 06:04 AM

P: 61

Ok, I found the answer (just had a bit of a brain freeze!!). It is X/(X+Y), and not X/Y




#3
Mar407, 01:20 PM

P: 372

X/Y does follow a beta distribution! (Assuming they have the same second parameter. This is very important). It's called the beta distribution of the second kind with parameters alpha_x and alpha_y. The F distribution is simply b*X/Y where b>0.
I'll show you why X/Y is called the beta distribution of the second kind. Suppose X~[tex]\Gamma(\alpha_1,\beta)[/tex] and Y~[tex]\Gamma(\alpha_2,\beta)[/tex], X and Y independent. What is the distribution of [tex]U_1=\frac{X}{Y}[/tex]? Now this is a multivariate transformation, (http://www.ma.ic.ac.uk/~ayoung/m2s1/...formations.PDF see here if you don't know how to do these), so we will use [tex]U_2=Y[/tex] as an auxillary equation. So, [tex]g_1(x,y)=x/y[/tex] and [tex]g_2(x,y)=y[/tex] where x,y are positive reals (because they come from a gamma distribution) now it should be clear to see that [tex]g_1^{1}(x,y)=xy[/tex] and [tex]g_2^{1}(x,y)=y[/tex]. Note how g_1 and g_2 have range (0,+infty). Therefore, [tex]f_{(U_1,U_2)}(u_1,u_2)=f_{(x,y)}(g_1^{1}(u_1,u_2),g_2^{1}(u_1,u_2))J[/tex]. As an exercise you can show that [tex]J=u_2[/tex] Since X and Y are independent [tex]f_{(X,Y)}=f_X f_Y[/tex] Now [tex]f_{(U_1,U_2)}(u_1,u_2)=f_x(u_1u_2)f_y(u_2)u_2=\frac{e^{\frac{1}{\beta}(1+u_1)u_2}u_1^{\alpha_11}u_2^{\alpha_1+\alpha_21}}{\beta^{\alpha_1+\alpha_2}\Gamma(\alpha_1)\Gamma(\alpha_2)}[/tex] (I have done some simplifying) Now, we don't want the pdf of (U_1,U_2) we want the pdf of U_1, so we integrate over the joint to get the marginal distribution of U_1. [tex]f_{U_1}(u_1)=\frac{u_1^{\alpha_11}}{\beta^{\alpha_1+\alpha_2}\Gamma(\alpha_1)\Gamma(\alpha_2)}\int_0^{+ \infty}u_2^{\alpha_1+\alpha_21}e^{\frac{1}{\beta}(1+u_1)u_2}du_2[/tex] But the integral is just a gamma function (after we change variables). So this means that [tex]\int_0^{+\infty}u_2^{\alpha_1+\alpha_21}e^{\frac{1}{\beta}(1+u_1)u_2}du_2=\frac{\Gamma(\alpha_1+\alpha_2)\beta^{\a lpha_1+\alpha_2}}{(1+u_1)^{\alpha_1+\alpha_2}}[/tex]. Plugging this in we get [tex]f_{U_1}(u_1)=\frac{\Gamma(\alpha_1+\alpha_2)u_1^{\alpha_11}}{\Gamma(\alpha_1)\Gamma(\alpha_2)(1+u_1)^{\alpha_1+\alpha_2}}=\frac{ u_1^{\alpha_11}}{\beta(\alpha_1,\alpha_2)(1+u_1)^{\alpha_1+\alpha_2}}[/tex] So there we go! U_1=X/Y is distributed as that. Now why is this called a beta distribution of the second kind? If you do some transformations you should see that [tex]\beta(\alpha_1,\alpha_2)=\int_0^1x^{\alpha_1}(1x)^{\alpha_21}dx=\int_0^{+\infty}\frac{x^{\alpha_11}}{(1+x)^{\alpha_1+\alpha_2}}dx[/tex] I hope someone finds this interesting ;0 



#4
Jan2510, 02:43 AM

P: 1

Ratio of 2 Gamma distributions
Hello!
I desperately need a proof of the fact that x/(x+y) has a beta distribution. 



#5
Jan2510, 10:35 PM

P: 2,490

Edit: Look up the PDF and the MGF of the beta distribution. I assume you know the relationship between the gamma and beta functions. By the way, just saying x/(x+y) doesn't mean much by itself. I'm assuming it's relevant to the ratio of two independent gamma distributions. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Mass Ratio to Mole Ratio  Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework  3  
ratio simplification using ratio series.  Calculus & Beyond Homework  7  
Dirac Gamma matrices including gamma^5, and the Spacetime Metric g_uv  General Physics  8  
Relation of g^uv = (1/2) {gamma^u,gamma^v} to gravitational fields  General Physics  15  
Gamma Function, Gamma 1/2=root pi  Calculus & Beyond Homework  4 