What happens to light when it reaches the edge of the universe?


by fbsthreads
Tags: edge, light, reaches, universe
fbsthreads
fbsthreads is offline
#1
Apr26-04, 07:00 PM
P: 40
What happens to light when it reaches the edge of the universe?

it couldn't keep on travelling into nothingingness could it? becuase that nothingness would be space.

it couldn't reflect off something unless there was matter at the edge to reflect off.

the light must do something, it can't disappear can it? that would contradict the 'can't create or destory energy' law.
Phys.Org News Partner Astronomy news on Phys.org
Computers beat brainpower when it comes to counting stars
The changing laws that determine how dust affects the light that reaches us from the stars
ESO image: A study in scarlet
LURCH
LURCH is offline
#2
Apr26-04, 09:03 PM
Sci Advisor
P: 2,507
It would keep going. "The edge of the universe" is the distance to which this light has gotten, (at least).
kurious
kurious is offline
#3
Apr27-04, 03:38 AM
P: 653
If the universe is the same everywhere - as stephen hawking says it must be to make calculations relevant -then light can't reach an "edge" because an edge would be different from the rest of the universe! On the event horizon of a black hole the
kinetic energy of a mass = potential energy and this is the same for the furthest distance light is from the Earth - using the Newtonian idea that the universe is a sphere.The universe isn't a black hole, this just shows that the universe is like a black hole in that it won't allow a mass to escape from it.

fbsthreads
fbsthreads is offline
#4
Apr30-04, 07:25 PM
P: 40

What happens to light when it reaches the edge of the universe?


maybe space is so curved that light just gets bent when it reaches the edge and flows along the edge of the universe.
jcsd
jcsd is offline
#5
Apr30-04, 07:38 PM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 2,226
The universe (in all credibel cosmological models) doesn't have an edge, it's as simple as that.
hitssquad
hitssquad is offline
#6
May1-04, 02:56 AM
hitssquad's Avatar
P: 1,382
Quote Quote by fbsthreads
What happens to light when it reaches the edge of the universe?
The universe's three dimensional space is curved back on itself in the same way that the 2-dimentional surface of the earth is curved back on itself. If you keep walking in one direction on Earth, eventually you will reach your starting point. Similarly, light travelling in one direction through the universe will eventually reach its starting point (if it travels long enough and outruns any expansion of the universe).

Because the universe is curved, if you could see far enough, and if there was a clear view in front of and behind you, you would see the back of your head. If you could see far enough and looked up, you would see the other side of the earth.

The implication here, though, is that whatever direction you look in you will see your starting place. Since this Earth-in-the-sky would logically have to be continuous, wherever you happen to be located at any given moment will be continuously projected in reverse against the "sky" of the universe.
Nereid
Nereid is offline
#7
May1-04, 06:52 AM
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 4,005
hitssquad's description applies if the universe is closed; if it's open you wouldn't be able to see yourself (and flat is in between). There's the small matter of the speed of expansion, which is not a question of the geometry of the universe.

The WMAP site has a nice alien illustration of closed, flat and open.
geometer
geometer is offline
#8
May1-04, 10:12 AM
P: 196
Correct me if I am wrong, but there is no requirement for the universe itself to be moving(expanding) at or less than the speed of light, and with the recent discoveries concerning dark energy, it appears that its expansion is accelerating. Hence, the "edge" of the universe could be moving faster than the speed of light, and a "beam" of light couldn't reach it!
fbsthreads
fbsthreads is offline
#9
May1-04, 10:39 AM
P: 40
Quote Quote by geometer
Hence, the "edge" of the universe could be moving faster than the speed of light, and a "beam" of light couldn't reach it!
but if it is accelerating all the time then there must have been a time when light could easily reach the edge.

also, if big bang is to be believed then any light from the big bang 'explosion' would have been at the edge of the small universe in no time.

if light could never reach the edge, you could still see the big bang if you were at the edge.
geometer
geometer is offline
#10
May1-04, 02:12 PM
P: 196
The initial expansion of the universe was much faster than the speed of light (the inflationary period), and so the "edge" has probably always been receeding at faster than the speed of light.
jcsd
jcsd is offline
#11
May1-04, 02:31 PM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 2,226
Quote Quote by geometer
The initial expansion of the universe was much faster than the speed of light (the inflationary period), and so the "edge" has probably always been receeding at faster than the speed of light.
No:

It is possible for objects in the visible universe (with respect to some obsever) to have recession velocities faster than the speed of light, but, you have to relaize that the recession velocity of an object is depenednet on the distance of the observer from that object. A beam of light emitted by the observer would never recah your hypothetical edge, but it would be possible for a beam of light within the observable universe that is considerably closer to the edge to reach and go past that edge.

As I said before, whatever the geometry of the universe is (whether it is postive, negative, or flat curavture or whether it is infinite or finite), it doesn't have an edge, it really is as simple as that.
jcsd
jcsd is offline
#12
May1-04, 02:32 PM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 2,226
Basically expansion is global, not local.
Sariaht
Sariaht is offline
#13
May1-04, 03:09 PM
P: 358
When the vu the BB-scientists calculate the universe to expand in equals the speed of light, c, the ether will fall back to it's previous energylevel, and the gates god built will not stay in the condition it had earlier.
jcsd
jcsd is offline
#14
May1-04, 03:14 PM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 2,226
Sariah, though I siad exapnsion, is global not local, the measure rate of expansion is local not global, so the expansion rate is not a velocty, but a function of distance and velocity (it will give you the recession velocity v of two objects in a co-moving sphere of radius r) and therfore can't equal c as it has different units.
Sariaht
Sariaht is offline
#15
May1-04, 03:18 PM
P: 358
time went and radius grew. r/t is not c yet.
Sariaht
Sariaht is offline
#16
May1-04, 03:34 PM
P: 358
though the universe is not really expanding, i still think this is what happens when dr/dt = c
jcsd
jcsd is offline
#17
May1-04, 03:43 PM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 2,226
The rate of expansion of the universe is measure by Hubble's constant, which is equal to vr/d, so you should be able to see that even if Hubbles constant is very small, as long as the distance between the two objects (d)is large enough the recession velocity (vr) will exceed c. In an infinite expanding universe there must be a distance where vr exceeds c.
cangus
cangus is offline
#18
May1-04, 07:31 PM
P: 26
Quote Quote by hitssquad
The universe's three dimensional space is curved back on itself in the same way that the 2-dimentional surface of the earth is curved back on itself. If you keep walking in one direction on Earth, eventually you will reach your starting point. Similarly, light travelling in one direction through the universe will eventually reach its starting point (if it travels long enough and outruns any expansion of the universe).
if this was the case, would the darkness of space even exist? wouldnt there be everlasting light in every single direction at every single point of time?


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Light Waves at Edge of Universe Question Astrophysics 13
What happends to light before it reaches us? General Astronomy 3
The edge of the universe General Astronomy 7
Why is the sky blue yet the light that reaches the earth white? General Physics 4
Spacecraft reaches edge of solar system: CNN General Astronomy 6