image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

Go Back   Physics Forums > Physics > Special & General Relativity


Reply

image Earths rotation and special relativity Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Jul2-09, 07:12 AM                  #1
git67

git67 is Offline:
Posts: 2
Earths rotation and special relativity

Now before you read this i would like to state that this is not for homework, and i am not very experienced in the study of physics, but i find it fascinating, and have a question i am curios about.

If according to the theory of relativity (i thinks its special relativity) mass which is traveling at a faster speed compared to slower mass, will experience time more quickly, Does that means if the rotation of earth was to increase in speed, would us humans appear to live longer to ourselves and would year we experience seem to go by faster?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 07:21 AM                  #2
George Jones

PF Mentor
 
George Jones's Avatar

George Jones is Offline:
Posts: 3,128
Re: Earths rotation and special relativity

Originally Posted by git67 View Post
Does that means if the rotation of earth was to increase in speed, would us humans appear to live longer to ourselves and would year we experience seem to go by faster?
No, unfortunately, time dilation does not work like this. We would see our own clocks tick normally, and our own bodies age at the usual rate.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 07:34 AM                  #3
git67

git67 is Offline:
Posts: 2
Re: Earths rotation and special relativity

so if there were 2 planets for instance, and the both originally moved that the same speed, but one planet's velocity increased, while the other planets velocity was unchanged. would the latter planet observing the higher velocity planet, find that the inhabitants lived longer in relation to how long the unchanged planets lived? (disregarding the perceived time the faster planets inhabitants experienced? (this may very well be a stupid question, but i want to understand more about relativity
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 07:47 AM                  #4
George Jones

PF Mentor
 
George Jones's Avatar

George Jones is Offline:
Posts: 3,128
Re: Earths rotation and special relativity

I think you want to learn about something called "the twin paradox."

My wife is several years younger than me. If I get in a rocket and move away from and then back to the Earth at high enough speed (with respect to the Earth) for long enough, when I return, my wife will be older than me, event though I think I age normally, and my wife thinks she ages normally.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 07:52 AM                  #5
DaleSpam

DaleSpam is Online:
Posts: 3,721
Recognitions:
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Re: Earths rotation and special relativity

http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physic...n_paradox.html
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 10:41 AM       Last edited by stone1; Jul2-09 at 10:47 AM..            #6
stone1

stone1 is Offline:
Posts: 12
Re: Earths rotation and special relativity

But what is the source of the aging difference? How can you say who moved? From your persepctive, your wife moved and so she should come back even younger than you? Is the acceleration/deceleration the source of the difference? You accelerated/decelerated while your wife's frame of reference is stationary.

Imagine that you both are rotating around a star but in oposite directions. While passing each other you take a glimpse and you both look equally young. The next time you pass by each other, what determines who looks younger and who looks older?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 10:55 AM                  #7
Matterwave

Matterwave is Offline:
Posts: 161
Re: Earths rotation and special relativity

The usual resolution of the Twin's paradox is to state that the "rest" frame is "preferred" since it has no acceleration; while the rocket ship's frame of reference accelerated twice. This brings you to the realm of General relativity, as special relativity is not readily equiped to deal with accelerations.

I have seen on Wikipedia a way to resolve this without resorting to the acceleration argument, but I've since forgotten. You may want to check that article out.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul2-09, 11:19 AM       Last edited by DaleSpam; Jul2-09 at 11:38 AM..            #8
DaleSpam

DaleSpam is Online:
Posts: 3,721
Recognitions:
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Re: Earths rotation and special relativity

Originally Posted by stone1 View Post
But what is the source of the aging difference? How can you say who moved? From your persepctive, your wife moved and so she should come back even younger than you? Is the acceleration/deceleration the source of the difference? You accelerated/decelerated while your wife's frame of reference is stationary.

Imagine that you both are rotating around a star but in oposite directions. While passing each other you take a glimpse and you both look equally young. The next time you pass by each other, what determines who looks younger and who looks older?
The wife always looks younger. The laws of physics are irrelevant, this is a much more fundamental law that all husbands learn quickly.

However, if you want to change the objects of interest to clocks, then please see the FAQ I posted above. It answers all of the questions you have raised.
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Earths rotation and special relativity
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Rotation in special relativity ballzac Advanced Physics 4 May20-09 07:43 PM
getting energy from earths rotation with a giant powerball nailed to the ground giordano bruno General Physics 3 Oct17-06 08:27 AM
Earths rotation speeds up? errorist Earth 3 Jan9-05 09:04 PM
[SOLVED] gravitational force -airplane motion and earths rotation surendra General Physics 30 Aug29-04 02:38 AM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image