
#1
Oct910, 09:25 AM

P: 7

I'm building a giant set of monkey bars for a gym and I'm curious about the strength of material I plan to use.I'm going to use two 4x4 3/16 thick steel tubing that will run 20 feet long and sit on top of the same material at each end 9 feet high.I will brace the top corners at each end.
I'm curious if 3/16 will work or should I use 1/4 inch thick? It wont have any large loads on it.It's just for chin up bars and maybe a punching bag hanging from it. Thanks for your help. 



#2
Oct910, 01:38 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 2,110

TK9320: I think 12 to 15 people could easily fit in this space doing chinups simultaneously. Please let us know the maximum number of people that can fit in this space.




#3
Oct910, 02:02 PM

P: 7

I dont think they will ever have 20 people on it at the same time though. Thanks 



#4
Oct910, 02:25 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 2,110

Strength of 4x4 steel tubing?
TK9320: What is the distance between your two horizontal beams?




#5
Oct910, 02:44 PM

P: 7





#6
Oct910, 03:27 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 2,110

OK, I misinterpreted something earlier. My fault. Let me make sure I understand. You have two horizontal beams, 52 inches apart. And these two beams have one chinup bar on each end, located 7 feet from each end. Therefore, the distance between the two chinup bars is 6 feet. Plus, there is a punching bag bar in the center. And we can call this one "frame." It sounds like you have five of these frames, side by side, in the room, correct? Therefore, does each adjacent frame share a horizontal beam? In other words, you have six horizontal, 20footlong beams in the room, right? And each of the six 20foot beams sits on a vertical 4 x 4 inch tube at each end, correct?




#7
Oct910, 03:37 PM

P: 7





#8
Oct910, 04:13 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 2,110

I cannot imagine, yet, how there are ten chinup bars on each end. By the way, did you know you can attach a diagram when you post? You could scan (or photograph) a freehand sketch, or draw a rough diagram using Start > Programs > Accessories > Paint, if you wish.




#9
Oct910, 05:17 PM

P: 7





#10
Oct910, 05:33 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 2,110

Try going to the link I posted, then click the imageshack link, then upload your pictures. I think you can use the "image resize" pulldown menu in imageshack, if you wish. But it is probably not required. Then post direct links to the pictures.




#11
Oct910, 05:38 PM

P: 7




#12
Oct1010, 03:59 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 2,110

TK9320: Nice job uploading the diagrams. Assuming up to 20 people are doing chinups simultaneously, with an average mass per person of 91.8 kg, and assuming one punching bag in the center, I think you can use a dynamic amplification factor of daf = 2.0. I think the steel square tube minimum tensile yield strength is probably Sty = 275 MPa. You could use a yield factor of safety of FSy = 1.50. Therefore, for your 101.6 x 101.6 x 4.7625 mm square tubes, we have the following.
L = 6100 mm, M = 6.1803e6 N*mm, I1 = 2.8902e6 mm^4.For your 101.6 x 101.6 x 6.35 mm square tubes, we have the following. L = 6100 mm, M = 6.1803e6 N*mm, I2 = 3.6745e6 mm^4.Therefore, if you want to use 101.6 x 101.6 mm square tubes, then it appears they would need to have a wall thickness of 6.35 mm. By the way, it appears your structure needs to be stabilized in the lateral direction. No end view is shown, so we do not know if you provided a corner brace on the ends. The above results assume no one is hanging (bouncing) on the structure near midspan, which might be an unwise assumption. 



#13
Oct1010, 04:11 PM

P: 7





#14
Oct1010, 04:43 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 2,110

It depends on where they are hanging. More people near midspan creates higher stresses.




#15
Oct1010, 09:25 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 2,110

I can make the structure fail using 14 people, 101.6 x 101.6 x 6.35 mm steel tubes, and daf = 2.0. I put two people on the bar holding the punching bag, one person on each beam at x = +/450 mm from midspan, two people on each chinup bar at x = +/914 mm from midspan, and one person on each outside chinup bar at x = +/1524 mm from midspan. This gives the following stress level (and I haven't even subtracted for the holes in the beam).
M = 7.2828e6 N*mm, sigma = daf*M*c/I2 = 201.37 MPa.However, I think using daf = 2.0 for all people simultaneously is conservative, and can be reduced to daf = 1.75, which gives the following. M = 7.2828e6 N*mm, sigma = daf*M*c/I2 = 176.20 MPa.Therefore, if you want to use 101.6 x 101.6 mm square tubes, this still indicates they would need to have a wall thickness of 6.35 mm. Or, you might want to try 152.4 x 101.6 x 4.7625 mm rectangular tubes (which I have not tried). Post the material specification for your tubes, if you have it. 



#16
Oct1110, 09:25 PM

Sci Advisor
HW Helper
P: 2,110

TK9320: However, the results in post 15 do not include self weight. When we include self weight, the second Ry in post 15 becomes Ry = 106.5 %, which indicates the two square beams are overstressed. It seems you need to use 152 x 102 x 4.763 mm rectangular tubes for your two horizontal beams. These would have the same weight as the square tube beams in post 15, but would instead give the following results for the post 15 load case using daf = 1.75, except including self weight.
L = 6100 mm, M = 8.3974e6 N*mm, I3 = 7.5903e6 mm^4. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
3x3 or 4x4 square tubing bending strength  Mechanical Engineering  10  
Strength of mild steel square tubing?  Materials & Chemical Engineering  0  
strength of square tubing  Mechanical Engineering  10  
strengths of steel tubing  General Engineering  2  
Impact Strength (mild steel tubing)  General Engineering  1 