Troubleshooting Phone-Induced Clicks in Speakers

  • Thread starter Thread starter Phymath
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Troubleshooting
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the phenomenon of audible clicks or interference in speakers when a cell phone rings nearby. Participants explore potential causes, including electromagnetic interference and the behavior of audio equipment in response to cell phone signals. The scope includes technical explanations and personal experiences related to audio equipment and cell phone interactions.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that the clicking in speakers may be due to the induction coil in the speaker picking up currents induced by changing magnetic fields from radio waves transmitting the call.
  • Others argue that the RF field from the transmitter is too weak to cause such interference and propose that the audio amplifier in the speaker system might be picking up electromagnetic radiation from the phone's ringer circuit.
  • Several participants note that the interference occurs specifically when the phone is ringing, not during a call, and some have experienced the interference even before the phone begins to ring.
  • One participant with experience in audio equipment design mentions that the buzz is likely due to the cell phone transmitter turning on and off at a rate of several hundred Hz during a conversation, which can be detected by sensitive audio equipment.
  • Another participant describes experiencing different types of interference, such as a "morse code" sound, when using different phone networks.
  • Some participants speculate that the clicking could be related to the phone responding to the tower's seek signal before ringing, involving short bursts of high-power signals.
  • One participant raises concerns about interference from other devices, such as a ceiling fan with a remote control, and questions how to identify or shield against such interference.
  • Another participant suggests that shielding could block the correct signals as well, complicating the issue further.
  • It is noted that audio amplifiers may amplify RF signals, leading to interference, but there is uncertainty about the exact source of the interference.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of views on the causes of the interference, with no consensus reached. Some believe it is due to the phone's transmission behavior, while others attribute it to the audio equipment's sensitivity to RF signals. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the exact mechanisms at play.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention various factors that could influence the interference, including the type of phone network, the design of audio equipment, and the proximity of devices. There are references to specific frequencies and technical behaviors, but these are not fully resolved or agreed upon.

Phymath
Messages
183
Reaction score
0
When ever my cell phone rings near any type of powered speaker I can hear clicks in my speakers, I was wondering if the clicking is occurring because the induction coil in the speaker has a current induced from the changing magnetic field in the radio waves transmitting the call? If so what's the relation between the pulsing clicking sounds and the frequency of wave.
This also occurs on certian CRTs the image gets distorted when the phone rings but not during the conversation...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Engineering news on Phys.org
Phymath said:
When ever my cell phone rings near any type of powered speaker I can hear clicks in my speakers, I was wondering if the clicking is occurring because the induction coil in the speaker has a current induced from the changing magnetic field in the radio waves transmitting the call?...

The RF field from the transmitter is far too weak to do that. And if it COULD happen, EVERY phone call being sent out by that transmitter would do it. You say the speaker is "powered." I assume you mean it's connected to or inside a piece of equipment that's turned on. In that case, the audio amp that supplies the signal to the speaker could be picking up EM radiation from the "ringer" circuit in the phone.
 
im curious pack rat, I've experienced the samething.
while the phone is on a call, it won't interfere, while it is ringing, but ONLY when it is ringing from an incoming call, (ie NOT just previewing a tone[which should be going thru the ringer circuit, no?])
I have tested it with mycomputer speakers, and it causes interference when a call is incoming. I hear the interference on the speakers even before the phone begins to ring.
 
neil_m said:
im curious pack rat, I've experienced the samething.
while the phone is on a call, it won't interfere, while it is ringing, but ONLY when it is ringing from an incoming call, (ie NOT just previewing a tone[which should be going thru the ringer circuit, no?])
I have tested it with mycomputer speakers, and it causes interference when a call is incoming. I hear the interference on the speakers even before the phone begins to ring.

All these things sound strange to me. I was the audio guy on Motorola CDMA and other cellular phones, made in Libertyville, IL. I made hundreds of ringers ring. So far all I have ever heard is the TDMA buzz in speakers on nearby audio equipment. The reason for the buzz is that the cell phone transmitter is turning on and off at a rate of several hundred Hz during a phone conversation. The RF envilope is detected by a susceptible low signal part in the audio equipment and that noise is added to the regular audio path. TDMA buzz is a problem in some phones and it was my job to get rid of it. The RF carrier was 1.9 GHz. TRansmitter power was 0.1 Watt. Distance to susceptible audio equipment was 5 feet.
 
wow, cool.
Well, i haven't gotten too technical, (cause i can't, haha) but i have done it with my phone which is on a TDMA network.
But, i would piss a friend off who left his phone ( nokia GSM network) next to his speakers by his bed. When he was trying to sleep I kept calling the phone and his speakers, ( i THINK it was the subwoofer tho), would just buzz , and bother him.
It is only incoming calls. The receiving phone causes the interferene. and it goes away if the receiving phone answers it stops.
I just tested using a GSm and a TDMA phone.
But now i got a different sound...like morse code...lol.. from the receiving GSM nokia..
that any help?
by the way how would you fix that?
 
I'm not an expert on cell phone strategies, but I thought the speaker-clicking was the phone responding to the tower's seek by transmitting a short burst of high-power signals announcing its availability and negotiating its required transmit power. A second or so later the cell phone actually begins ringing.

- Warren
 
chroot said:
I'm not an expert on cell phone strategies, but I thought the speaker-clicking was the phone responding to the tower's seek by transmitting a short burst of high-power signals announcing its availability and negotiating its required transmit power. A second or so later the cell phone actually begins ringing.

- Warren

I just verified similar behavior with my Nokia. It goes tick tick tick then buzzes in the FM radio. Any chance you worked for Motorola in Ft. Lauderdale and Ft. Worth?
 
chroot said:
I'm not an expert on cell phone strategies, but I thought the speaker-clicking was the phone responding to the tower's seek by transmitting a short burst of high-power signals announcing its availability and negotiating its required transmit power. A second or so later the cell phone actually begins ringing.

- Warren

Thats what i always thought it was. I've since unplugged my sub until i want to use it. Sometimes it buzzes and the phone won't ring at all, perhaps a nieghboor?

Also, i recentlly got a cieling fan the runs on a 350MHz FM remote and have had problems with erroneous opperations (i.e. turning on or off without input to the remote). I know that just about everything could be doing that, but is there any quick way to find out what it is? or sheild the fan?

Thanks,
-Burg
 
Shielding the fan will kill the correct signal too, so that doesn't help.
Trying to find a rare transient signal is like trying to catch a spy transmission. If you have a spectrum analyzer or a radio that happens to tune that frequency you might just snoop for a long time. Good luck.
 
  • #10
the audio amplifier picking up an RF with modulation digital or analogue
will only amplifier the audio frequency component, thus the signal could
be coming from anywhere in the phone, i thing it is RF that causes this
inteference or a beat of RF frequencies with audio frequency modulation
if audio amplifiers were picking up audio frequency signals that easily it
would make them highly unstable and useless
 
  • #11
i have the same problem!
i have a nokia too.
car speakers.. and the stereo at home makes that noise.
at times it won't ring but the speakers will still rattle.
 
  • #12
I have the same problem. I have found that it is from the transmitter and not from recievieing. It will start beeping on car speakers or amplifiers before my phone rings. I figure it to be somekind os interference.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
6K
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
5K
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K