Register to reply

Mistakes about illuminance

Share this thread:
a b
#1
Sep11-11, 04:04 PM
P: 16
Hello everybody,
this question is about an exercise but I post it here because it is not homework, it is an exercise that I've done to learn by myself. I hope it is ok.
It is an exercise from Irodov book (exercise 5.12)
The exercise says:
A small spherical lamp, uniformly luminous with radius R= 6.0 cm is suspended at an height h of 3 metres above the floor;
The luminance of the lamp is L=2.0*10^4 cd/m2, indipendent of direction.
Find the illuminance of the floor directly below the lamp.

the solution that the book (and my teacher) gives is

[tex]I= \pi\frac{R^{2}}{h^{2}} L = 25.13\, \, lux [/tex]


I tried to solve it in this way:
the simmetry of the problem gives us many advantages; we can obtain the total luminous flux of the lamp by multiplying the luminance by the total surface and by 2 pi steradians (half of the maximum solid angle, because i assume the sphere doesn't radiate inside itself)

[tex]F=L (2 \pi) (4 \pi R^{2} )= L (8 \pi^{^2} R^{2} )[/tex]

then, to have the illuminance of the floor just below the lamp, we can divide the total flux by the area of the sphere having radius h:

[tex]I= L (8 \pi^{^2} R^{2} )/ (4 \pi h^{2})= 2 \pi L \frac{R^{2}}{h^2}=50.27\; lux[/tex]

but as you can see it is exactly twice the solution given by the book.
I suppose i am wrong, but i cannot understand why. can you help please?
Thank you in advance, sorry for my english
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Scientists develop 'electronic nose' for rapid detection of C. diff infection
Why plants in the office make us more productive
Tesla Motors dealing as states play factory poker

Register to reply

Related Discussions
Are these mistakes? Special & General Relativity 7
MTW mistakes. Science & Math Textbooks 2
Spot the mistakes Precalculus Mathematics Homework 5
Is it possible to control the illuminance of atoms? General Physics 1
Avoiding mistakes General Discussion 2