Register to reply

How many molecules make a droplet

by karen_lorr
Tags: droplet, molecules
Share this thread:
karen_lorr
#1
Oct13-11, 05:47 AM
P: 51
Hi

I am just wondering about this. How many molecules does it take before you can use the word Droplet in the atmosphere?

As an example, one H20 molecule floating around (interacting occasionally with others, but generally just floating around) would be Vapour.

If two H20 molecules combine (into a dimmer) for a while, is this a water droplet.

What about three or four molecules formed into a polymer – is this a water droplet, or is it still vapour

Say we have some vapour in the air. It raises and adiabatically cools. The molecular speed is reduced sufficiently to prevent the breaking of the hydrogen bonds in a dimmer or polymer, at what stage/number does it become liquid, as opposed to a conglomeration of vapour

Many thanks
Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on Phys.org
Mapping the optimal route between two quantum states
Spin-based electronics: New material successfully tested
Verifying the future of quantum computing
sophiecentaur
#2
Oct13-11, 07:30 AM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
sophiecentaur's Avatar
P: 11,948
Work out the mass of a single molecule of water - easy - using the mass of a proton, for a start - then Two for the Hydrogen atoms and add the Protons and Neutrons in an oxygen atom etc.
Work out the mass of a 'drop' of water (say 1mm^3), using the density of water value that you can easily find.

Divide one by the other and get a pretty big number!
Andy Resnick
#3
Oct13-11, 07:51 AM
Sci Advisor
P: 5,513
Quote Quote by karen_lorr View Post
I am just wondering about this. How many molecules does it take before you can use the word Droplet in the atmosphere?
Semantics aside, the question itself involves fairly complicated physics: nucleation is a non-equilibrium process. The problem can be approximated by field theories, as an extension of mean-field theory, and a linear approximation is called 'kinetic theory'.

While the basic kinetic results are reasonably easy to understand qualitatively (there is a critical droplet radius below which the droplet evaporates, and above which the droplet continues to grow in size), the quantitative results require understanding the application of fluctuations to thermodynamic processes.

Note also that temperature is a key variable and that in the atmosphere, water droplets generally nucleate around a contaminant and the water is not in a liquid phase.

Landau and Lifgarbagez v. 10 pp 427-431 is a good place to start regarding nucleation and kinetic theory. See also:

http://aerosols.ucsd.edu/classes/sio...Lecture05b.pdf
http://facstaff.unca.edu/cgodfrey/co...nucleation.pdf

karen_lorr
#4
Oct13-11, 08:16 AM
P: 51
How many molecules make a droplet

Hi Andy

Thanks for that - I will study the Köhler curve and get to the bottom of this :-)

What I am trying to (not very well at the moment) understand is how vapour changes to liquid.
I understand that in Heterogeneous nucleation (above around -40c) vapour will condense around nuclei but I just don't understand Homogeneous Nucleation. I also understand the Bergeron Process of ice over liquid (due to variations in the vapour pressures)
But (sorry about the silly questions)
At lower temperature (from 0c to -40c) do h2o molecules slow down enough to stop them re-bounding away so form hydrogen bonds.
What actually creates the liquid from vapour
sophiecentaur
#5
Oct13-11, 08:45 AM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
sophiecentaur's Avatar
P: 11,948
Quote Quote by sophiecentaur View Post
Work out the mass of a single molecule of water - easy - using the mass of a proton, for a start - then Two for the Hydrogen atoms and add the Protons and Neutrons in an oxygen atom etc.
Work out the mass of a 'drop' of water (say 1mm^3), using the density of water value that you can easily find.

Divide one by the other and get a pretty big number!
jeez, that was a dumb first response, wasn't it?

On a higher level - does that mean that the threshold size for a droplet to exist will vary for different pressures and temperatures and that a nucleus of a certain size must be present before one can form? Does every droplet need to have had a nucleus, initially?
karen_lorr
#6
Oct13-11, 09:04 AM
P: 51
Quote Quote by sophiecentaur View Post
that a nucleus of a certain size must be present before one can form? Does every droplet need to have had a nucleus, initially?
Not really but it depends on what you call a nucleus. The droplets can be simply bonded supercooled molecules

Quote Quote by sophiecentaur View Post
Does every droplet need to have had a nucleus, initially?
No, as I understand it. As a cloud rises and adiabatically cools the molecular energy is reduced (so they slow dow, to put it in my terms ;-). This allows hydrogen bonds to form and with less agitation the dimmers stay bonded, then grow into polymers and so on.

My question was, at what stage do you call a polymer a droplet. Of course some polymers will not have a curved surface so will disapate, but many will.
So assuming (just an average mass here by the way)
O = 16g/mol plus H = 1.1g/mol
So my calculator say that the average H2O
((H = 1.1g/mol X 2 = 2.2) + (O = 16g/mol) = 18.2))

With a mass of 18.2g/mol ? at what stage will a polymer (for example a (H20)2 or (H20)3 or (H20)4 etc etc) become a droplet
Does it take (H20)6 or (H20)200 or what ?

Is there (dependent on the temp and vapour pressure) a curvature minimum required ???

Hope someone can answer


Oh and wikithingy is simply wrong about this so I ignored it. The page needs rewritting. Any page that states that air can "hold" # amount of water needs redoing.
Sammy8
#7
Oct13-11, 09:10 AM
P: 4
I think its a rather simple fix. A droplets requirements are for the liquid to do 2 things. Accumilate (or seperate), and then drop. The amount needed for this would differ depending on the liquid. For instance corn syrup would be more molecules then water.
karen_lorr
#8
Oct13-11, 09:18 AM
P: 51
Sammy8
I like that answer ;-)
I like simple.

So a simpler dimmer - (H20)2 - can be a droplet (or it IS a droplet) until in splits. If it doesn't agetate apart then it provides a substrate for other bond on to.

Is that right (sorry about the dim questions, just trying to understand)
sophiecentaur
#9
Oct13-11, 01:23 PM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
sophiecentaur's Avatar
P: 11,948
Quote Quote by karen_lorr View Post

Oh and wikithingy is simply wrong about this so I ignored it. The page needs rewritting. Any page that states that air can "hold" # amount of water needs redoing.
Didn't you know "The air is like a sponge" take it from there.
klimatos
#10
Oct13-11, 06:29 PM
P: 409
Quote Quote by karen_lorr View Post
How many molecules does it take before you can use the word Droplet in the atmosphere?
I don't believe there is any "official" number. The mean size of a cloud droplet is about 10 microns, but obviously it must grow into that size from the cloud condensation nucleus (CCN). Most of this growth is from condensation, not accretion. This is because droplets of that size have a terminal velocity of some 1 cm per second, and falling droplets tend simply to push other droplets out of the way rather than coalesce with them.

By the way, it is unlikely that more than 0.1% of all condensation involves dimers, and polymers in atmospheric water vapor are even more rare.

An excellent introduction to cloud physics is:

R. R. Rogers, M. K. Yau; A Short Course in Cloud Physics; Third Edition; Elsevier, New York, 1989.
Sammy8
#11
Oct13-11, 06:34 PM
P: 4
Not dim at all. I think you got it, but I can clarify im sure. When I said accumilate it would be as the original post had mentioned atmospheric. Seperating would be a mass or majority of liquid, and some slowly overflows untill it seperates and then drops. If it cant meet those standards, then it would be a different classification.

Now the real question is, does the same amount of H2O molecules make a drop in either atmospheric or majority conditions? Assuming ofcourse that the drop off the majority doesnt have to travel down a surface to begin the droplet.

Quote Quote by karen_lorr View Post
Sammy8
I like that answer ;-)
I like simple.

So a simpler dimmer - (H20)2 - can be a droplet (or it IS a droplet) until in splits. If it doesn't agetate apart then it provides a substrate for other bond on to.

Is that right (sorry about the dim questions, just trying to understand)
Dotini
#12
Oct14-11, 07:18 AM
PF Gold
P: 508
Quote Quote by sophiecentaur View Post
Does every droplet need to have had a nucleus, initially?
I'm not sure droplets in ground fog need a nucleus. But for clouds to coalesce high in the atmosphere, nucleation is needed.

Respectfully,
Steve
klimatos
#13
Oct15-11, 01:25 PM
P: 409
Quote Quote by Dotini View Post
I'm not sure droplets in ground fog need a nucleus. But for clouds to coalesce high in the atmosphere, nucleation is needed.
Ground fog is simply a cloud on the ground. There is no significant difference between the two populations of droplets. Both require CCN.
sophiecentaur
#14
Oct15-11, 04:48 PM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
sophiecentaur's Avatar
P: 11,948
Quote Quote by klimatos View Post
Ground fog is simply a cloud on the ground. There is no significant difference between the two populations of droplets. Both require CCN.
That has to make sense. How would a water molecule know where it was and how to behave?
cmb
#15
Oct15-11, 05:04 PM
P: 628
Quote Quote by karen_lorr View Post
How many molecules does it take before you can use the word Droplet in the atmosphere?
As your question necessarily requires, by definition, the atmosphere for the droplet to be in, then an answer could be the number of molecules in the atmosphere, which I reckon is around 1.12 x 10^44.
klimatos
#16
Oct15-11, 07:52 PM
P: 409
Quote Quote by karen_lorr View Post

1) I am just wondering about this. How many molecules does it take before you can use the word Droplet in the atmosphere?

2) As an example, one H20 molecule floating around (interacting occasionally with others, but generally just floating around) would be Vapour.

3)If two H20 molecules combine (into a dimmer) for a while, is this a water droplet.What about three or four molecules formed into a polymer – is this a water droplet, or is it still vapour

4)Say we have some vapour in the air. It raises and adiabatically cools. The molecular speed is reduced sufficiently to prevent the breaking of the hydrogen bonds in a dimmer or polymer, at what stage/number does it become liquid, as opposed to a conglomeration of vapour
1) Unless there is some phenomenological difference between an agglomeration of water molecules and a droplet, the question is meaningless scientifically and therefore purely semantic.

2) At 25°C, the average water vapor molecule undergoes more than a billion inter-molecular collisions with other vapor molecules each second, at equilibrium vapor pressure. Statistical mechanics tells us that some proportion of these collisions will result in bonding. This bonding is extremely ephemeral. The next collision may result in the breaking of the first bond or may result in a second bonding.

3) It is a liquid if being a liquid is useful to your undertaking. It is a vapor if being a vapor is useful to your undertaking. Call it whatever you like. Its physical characteristics and parameters remain the same, regardless of terminology.

4) Vapor temperature measures the mean of a distribution of kinetic energies. This curve will be flatter at high temperatures and more peaked at lower temperatures. However, its range of values remains essentially the same. Some molecules will always have energies in excess of bonding values. Thus every agglomeration of molecules or droplet will be undergoing both gross condensation and gross vaporization in any giver time interval.
gary350
#17
Oct16-11, 12:17 PM
P: 32
One germ is too small to see but if you have a whole tablespoon full of germs can you see them.
jetwaterluffy
#18
Oct16-11, 02:29 PM
P: 227
It would have something to do with water's surface tension, I imagine, but I don't actually know the answer. (I thought "polymer" refers to something covalently bonded, not something with temporary hydrogen bonds. Again though, I don't actually know.)


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Do high power microwaves ionise water molecules and/or rearrange food molecules? General Discussion 10
Fuel Droplet Vaporization Mechanical Engineering 3
Stream break into droplet General Physics 1
Spherical droplet - potential Introductory Physics Homework 3
Project which involve a falling water droplet Classical Physics 2