Understanding Quark Colours and Particle Interactions

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the concept of quark colors and their relevance in particle physics, particularly in relation to the interactions of particles such as quarks, leptons, and mediators. Participants explore the necessity of color neutrality, the roles of various particles, and the nature of nuclear forces.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants explain that quarks possess a property called color, with three types: red, green, and blue, and that hadrons must be color-neutral to exist.
  • Others discuss the implications of color in relation to the Pauli exclusion principle, suggesting that the introduction of color as an additional quantum number allows for the formation of baryons and mesons.
  • There are varying interpretations of the role of leptons, with some suggesting they can act as force mediators due to their charge, while others assert that their primary role is as matter fields.
  • Participants question whether pions or muons mediate the nuclear force, with some asserting that charged pions are involved in modeling interactions between nucleons.
  • One participant mentions Yukawa's theory, which posits that the neutral pion field mediates interactions between fermionic fields, specifically protons.
  • There is a discussion about the classification of mediator particles and the nature of interactions they facilitate, with some confusion about the distinctions between different types of particles.
  • Some participants express frustration with the complexity of particle physics and the abundance of particles, indicating a need for clearer explanations.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of views on the roles and interactions of quarks, leptons, and mediators, indicating that multiple competing interpretations exist. The discussion remains unresolved on several points, particularly regarding the specific roles of leptons and the mediators of nuclear force.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note limitations in their understanding and the complexity of the subject matter, suggesting that existing educational resources may not adequately cover the intricacies of particle physics.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be of interest to students and enthusiasts of particle physics, particularly those seeking to understand the interactions and classifications of fundamental particles.

davidmerritt
Messages
17
Reaction score
0
Hello, trying to get my head around the (MANY) particles I'm learning about at the moment.

First question is about quark colours. I understand the different types of quark (up , down, strange, charmed, bottom and top) but I don't understand how the colours work, why is it necesary for the colours to neutralise, can someone outline its relevence to the exclusion principle in their answer too (please).

Second question is a really easy one I guess. I've seen that you can classify certain certain mediator particles in terms of their interaction. So a gloun is the mediator for a short range strong attraction, a gravition for long range gravitational interaction. But what are the purposes of leptons and hadrons etc.. are they just formed after collisions or are they too force mediators

Another question is it the pion that mediates nuclear force or muons?

there's so god damn many of them! HELP APPRICIATED!

David
 
Physics news on Phys.org
davidmerritt said:
Hello, trying to get my head around the (MANY) particles I'm learning about at the moment.

First question is about quark colours. I understand the different types of quark (up , down, strange, charmed, bottom and top) but I don't understand how the colours work, why is it necesary for the colours to neutralise, can someone outline its relevence to the exclusion principle in their answer too (please).

Second question is a really easy one I guess. I've seen that you can classify certain certain mediator particles in terms of their interaction. So a gloun is the mediator for a short range strong attraction, a gravition for long range gravitational interaction. But what are the purposes of leptons and hadrons etc.. are they just formed after collisions or are they too force mediators

Another question is it the pion that mediates nuclear force or muons?

there's so god damn many of them! HELP APPRICIATED!

David



I had written a big answer post,but for technical reasons which come from me being an idiot,it was lost,so now i can tell u only that in Yukawa's theory(1935) the neutral pion field mediates the interraction between fermionic fields which are taken as the protons.
The so-called Yukawa coupling involves a matrix which is usually selected as the Gamma 5 to compensate the fact that the field describing the boson pi 0 is a pseudoscalar.

Daniel.
 
Hi

i will try to answer, without entering into details (i will let detailled field theory explanation for someone else... i don't have the time now... sorry ... :p )

The color : The nature of a quark is called flavour. there are 6 different flavours (the ones you have cited). Each quark have also a quantum number of color. There are 3 different color : red, green and blue. In the Nature, the matter is colorless.

So, you cannot compose quarks as you wish to form hadrons (hadrons are particles composed by quarks). There are two types of hadrons, the baryons (composed by three quarks, one of each color, so the total is colorless) and the mesons (composed by one quark and one antiquark, the anitquark having the anticolor associated to the color of the quark, so the result is colorless).

Why do we need to have color ? I will explain with baryons (composed of three quarks). Take the delta++ particle (3 u quarks) or the omega- (3 s quarks). The spin is 3/2. So you have three quarks of the same flavour with a spin projection equal to +1/2 and their orbital momentum is 0. So we have a symmetric wave function, and that's violating Pauli's principle. A solution is to introduce an additionnal quantum number : the color.

The color part of the wave function will be antisymmetric (so now, Pauli is ok) ==> And each quark will have a different color.

We imposed that the hadronic states are invariant under a color transformation, so we need color singlets. (i don't remember the real reason, sorry, maybe someone else will complete).

Quarks and leptons : they are simply needed to form all the matter of the universe. We need both to form atoms... (in fact i don't think i have really understood the question... :p )

Nuclear force : I will just add a word to dextercioby's answer : the charged pions can be used to modelise the interacitons between a proton and a neutron. There are also models based on 2 pions exchanges to modelize the baryon-baryon interaction.

I hope it will help you.

Cya

Major
 
Last edited:
Cheers for the help , I've been digging out some elementary particle physics notes. Particle physics is a very interesting topic, though the level of detail is higher than other topics in physics in my opinion. The main textbook I use (University Physics with Modern Physics by Young and Freedman, 11ed, which is generally excellent) only includes a brief chapter on particle physics and obviously they've tried to cram a little too much in their making it more use as a dictionary of particles, with only limited explanations of the role of quark properties and colours (to be fair its only aimed at 1st/2nd level students).


(if anyone else is interested the notes for the 3rd year course EPP are available for download from the University of Nottingham in the UK at www.nott.ac.uk/physics[/URL] and click on the current students --> module pages --> 3rd year they are very well written)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Just thought I'd post answering some of the questions I asked above. Been reading up today.

The colour can be seen as a type of charge it seems, with chronodynamics explaining the forces between quarks of different colours. Hence the colours and neutrality are important to explain how quarks interact, and hence how gluons and quarks interact.

Indeed Leptons are fundamental particles and in a way can act as force mediators. As leptons are charged they are involved in electromagnetic interaction.

I think that's correct... but if you know different please post!
 
1.The colors of the quarks and gluons are red,yellow,blue.By mixing two colors (actually two different color quark fields) one gets the color of the antiquark.Antigluons are identical to gluons and hence have the same color.The analogy with optics is not random,since by combining all three colors,the result is "white",i.e.color number zero.The colors of the antquarks can be:green,indigo,orange.
2.The leptons are semiinteger spinor massive/massless fields which bear the name "matter fields".They may never intermediate a fundamental interaction,at least not in the Standard Model.That's the job for "vector bosons"/"gauge bosons",which are integer spin vector fields either massless (the photon,the gluon) or massive (the electroweak bosons:W plus,minus ans Z).Quarks are massive semiinteger spinor fields.Those are the bricks of the SM.The rest is merely speculation.So far...

Daniel."Shoot-before-u-read".
 
The most common names given to the colors is red, green, blue for the quarks, antired, antigreen and antiblue for the anti-quarks. But it doesn't really matter what colors we choose to describe this; all that matters is the combinations (any color + its anti-color) or (one of each 3 colors or one of each 3 anti-colors) be color neutral; the rest is just nomenclature.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 46 ·
2
Replies
46
Views
8K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 25 ·
Replies
25
Views
5K