Register to reply

Hybridisation of Mn in MnO4-

by jd12345
Tags: hybridisation, mno4
Share this thread:
jd12345
#1
Feb6-12, 11:56 PM
P: 260
What is the hybridisation of manganese in MnO4-
Configuration of manganese in 3d5 4s2 right? The paired electrons in 4s become unpaired - electron frm it jumps into the 4p orbital
So now configuration looks like this - 3d5 4s1 4p1
Now manganese forms 4 sigma bonds and 3 pibonds so the hybridisation should be d2sp and the three d-orbitals form pi bonds
But apparently this is not the case - hybridisation is sp3
I dont understand how - it doesnt even have 3 unpaired electrons in p-orbital
Do the electrons from d-orbital jump to the p-orbital?? But why should they?
Phys.Org News Partner Chemistry news on Phys.org
Building the ideal rest stop for protons
Direct reaction heavy atoms to catalyst surface demonstrated
Cagey material acts as alcohol factory
DrDu
#2
Feb7-12, 02:55 AM
Sci Advisor
P: 3,564
Why shouldn't they jump to the p orbitals. All d, s and p orbitals are nearly degenerate energetically and the electrons distribute so as to minimize energy. You also did take it as granted that the s electron may jump to a p orbital.
The problem is that when you want to describe bonding in MnO4- by Valence Bond theory you do have to consider resonance between dosens of structures, not only one. Many of them being ionic ones with electrons jumping from Mn to O or the other way round.
In this situation, it is hardly useful any more to use hybridized orbitals.
Promoting d electrons to the p orbitals and forming then sp3 hybrids is maybe a possible first approximation. Then you get at least the sigma bonds to the O atoms and you can use the d orbitals for pi bonding.
jd12345
#3
Feb7-12, 03:03 AM
P: 260
Yeah - but cant the d-orbital electrons form the sigma bond
Why do they jump to the p-orbital(increase their energy) and then bond.
They could have stayed in the d-orbital and 2 electrons could have formed sigma bond and other 3 pi bond

DrDu
#4
Feb7-12, 04:06 AM
Sci Advisor
P: 3,564
Hybridisation of Mn in MnO4-

You can also use sd3 orbitals or something in between sp3 and sd3. However, this is all quite speculative. However I would like to see a calculation from the last 30 years at least for confirmation and there is very little available. I would consider this kind of description of transition metal complexes as quite outdated.
jd12345
#5
Feb7-12, 09:54 AM
P: 260
@ DrDu
Sorry i didnt understand - what is outdated?


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Hybridisation of SO 2 and SeO 2 Chemistry 3
Hybridisation and geometry of clf3 Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework 0
Urgent: Hybridisation Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework 2
Ethene is hydrogenated ethane is obtained Materials & Chemical Engineering 0
Explain the hybridisation of Cl atom in Cl2O7 or XeOF4? Chemistry 7