| New Reply |
hybridisation of Mn in MnO4- |
Share Thread |
| Feb6-12, 11:56 PM | #1 |
|
|
hybridisation of Mn in MnO4-
What is the hybridisation of manganese in MnO4-
Configuration of manganese in 3d5 4s2 right? The paired electrons in 4s become unpaired - electron frm it jumps into the 4p orbital So now configuration looks like this - 3d5 4s1 4p1 Now manganese forms 4 sigma bonds and 3 pibonds so the hybridisation should be d2sp and the three d-orbitals form pi bonds But apparently this is not the case - hybridisation is sp3 I dont understand how - it doesnt even have 3 unpaired electrons in p-orbital Do the electrons from d-orbital jump to the p-orbital?? But why should they? |
| Feb7-12, 02:55 AM | #2 |
|
Recognitions:
|
Why shouldn't they jump to the p orbitals. All d, s and p orbitals are nearly degenerate energetically and the electrons distribute so as to minimize energy. You also did take it as granted that the s electron may jump to a p orbital.
The problem is that when you want to describe bonding in MnO4- by Valence Bond theory you do have to consider resonance between dosens of structures, not only one. Many of them being ionic ones with electrons jumping from Mn to O or the other way round. In this situation, it is hardly useful any more to use hybridized orbitals. Promoting d electrons to the p orbitals and forming then sp3 hybrids is maybe a possible first approximation. Then you get at least the sigma bonds to the O atoms and you can use the d orbitals for pi bonding. |
| Feb7-12, 03:03 AM | #3 |
|
|
Yeah - but cant the d-orbital electrons form the sigma bond
Why do they jump to the p-orbital(increase their energy) and then bond. They could have stayed in the d-orbital and 2 electrons could have formed sigma bond and other 3 pi bond |
| Feb7-12, 04:06 AM | #4 |
|
Recognitions:
|
hybridisation of Mn in MnO4-
You can also use sd3 orbitals or something in between sp3 and sd3. However, this is all quite speculative. However I would like to see a calculation from the last 30 years at least for confirmation and there is very little available. I would consider this kind of description of transition metal complexes as quite outdated.
|
| Feb7-12, 09:54 AM | #5 |
|
|
@ DrDu
Sorry i didnt understand - what is outdated? |
| New Reply |
Similar discussions for: hybridisation of Mn in MnO4-
|
||||
| Thread | Forum | Replies | ||
| Hybridisation of SO[SUB]2[/SUB] and SeO[SUB]2[/SUB] | Chemistry | 3 | ||
| hybridisation and geometry of clf3 | Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework | 0 | ||
| Urgent: Hybridisation | Biology, Chemistry & Other Homework | 2 | ||
| ethene is hydrogenated ethane is obtained | Materials & Chemical Engineering | 0 | ||
| explain the hybridisation of Cl atom in Cl2O7 or XeOF4? | Chemistry | 7 | ||