Recent content by Demystifier

  1. Demystifier

    Today I Learned

    Today I learned that Terry Rudolph, the R from the famous PBR theorem, is a grandson of Erwin Schrodinger and his mistress. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terry_Rudolph
  2. Demystifier

    Undergrad On computing quantum waves exactly from classical action

    I have not studied the papers in detail, but at a first look the critique looks much more plausible.
  3. Demystifier

    Graduate Why is 0 K unattainable?

    If the Hamiltonian has a continuous spectrum, then, in the canonical ensemble with non-zero temperature, any given energy has non-zero probability density, but zero probability.
  4. Demystifier

    Graduate Why is 0 K unattainable?

    You are right that any state with definite energy has zero probability in that sense. But there is nothing wrong with that conclusion. We are talking about thermal equilibrium, i.e. thermal states in a canonical ensemble, while states with definite non-zero energy are not thermal states, so in...
  5. Demystifier

    Graduate Six Textbook Mistakes in Quantum Field Theory

    I think there were a few, but I can find only this one: https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/quantum-mechanics-myths-and-facts.143045/
  6. Demystifier

    Graduate Six Textbook Mistakes in Quantum Field Theory

    I joined this forum soon after writing this paper, so this is how I have chosen my name. :smile:
  7. Demystifier

    Graduate Is the variation of the metric ##\delta g_{\mu\nu}## a tensor?

    Under a coordinate transformation ##x^{\mu}\to x'^{\mu}=f^{\mu}(x)##, the two metrics transform as $$g'^{\alpha\beta}=\frac{\partial x'^{\alpha}}{\partial x^{\mu}} \frac{\partial x'^{\beta}}{\partial x^{\nu}} g^{\mu\nu}$$ $$\bar{g}'^{\alpha\beta}=\frac{\partial x'^{\alpha}}{\partial x^{\mu}}...
  8. Demystifier

    Graduate Is the variation of the metric ##\delta g_{\mu\nu}## a tensor?

    How did you verify this? They do transform as tensors under coordinate transformations, but their indices are not raised and lowered in the usual way. Which is understandable, because when you have two metrics, there is an ambiguity should one raise the indices with ##g^{\mu\nu}## or...
  9. Demystifier

    Undergrad Hawking radiation may smooth black hole singularities

    My confusion stems from the following. The Bardeen metric significantly deviates from the Schwarzschild only for small ##r##, close to ##r=0##. And yet, global properties significantly deviate from the Schwarzschild even for larger ##r##, e.g. close to ##r=2M##. How to understand that? What do I...
  10. Demystifier

    Graduate Is the variation of the metric ##\delta g_{\mu\nu}## a tensor?

    I believe there is no such quantity, because you study a variation of the object that defines the covariant and contravariant components.
  11. Demystifier

    Undergrad Hawking radiation may smooth black hole singularities

    Does it shed some light on the information paradox?
  12. Demystifier

    High School Seemingly odd quantum tunneling

    That's because tunneling is a consequence of superposition. For example, suppose that at time ##t## the particle can tunnel from the left to the right, through a barrier in the middle. This means that the wave function at ##t## is nonzero both at the left and at the right, i.e. the wave...
  13. Demystifier

    Graduate Is the variation of the metric ##\delta g_{\mu\nu}## a tensor?

    3. is just a definition of the dual tensor, i.e. the rule how to raise indices in the same world. In 2. you try to compare quantities from two different worlds.
  14. Demystifier

    High School Seemingly odd quantum tunneling

    No, the number of degrees of freedom is not directly related to the size of the system. It is more directly related to the number of particles. See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Degrees_of_freedom_(mechanics)