A geometric puzzle: Area enclosed by three circular arcs

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter bob012345
  • Start date
  • Featured
7 replies · 4K views · last reply
bob012345
Gold Member
Messages
2,486
Reaction score
1,145
TL;DR
Find the area enclosed by the three circular arcs.
This figure is bounded by three circular arcs of equal radius R. The arcs are tangent where they meet. Find the enclosed area in terms of R.

Closed curvilinear shape in red outline with three cusp-like corners, formed by three concave circular arcs of equal radius meeting tangentially at the vertices.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Gavran, Filip Larsen, Charles Link and 2 others
Good one!

Geometric diagram of three equal circles of radius R, each touching the other two, with an inverted equilateral triangle whose vertices sit on the circles, labelled R on the two upper radii.
The area of the equilateral triangle of side ##2R## is ##A_1=R^2\sqrt{3}.##
Each 60° "pizza" piece is 1/6 of the area of a circle so the 3 pieces together have area ##A_2=\frac{1}{2}\pi R^2.##
The answer is the difference ##\Delta A=R^2\left(\sqrt{3}-\frac{1}{2}\pi\right)=0.161 R^2.##
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Charles Link and bob012345
Exagonal (L=R) area minus half circle (R=R) area?
Exagon vertex are 3 circle centers plus 3 figure vertex
 
That was perhaps a bit too easy, even though I tried to obscure it a bit. So, as an additional exercise, what is the radius ##R## of the large circle in terms of the radius ##r## of the smaller circles?

Geometric figure: three equal small circles, each tangent to two others, with centres joined by a dashed equilateral triangle, all inscribed in a larger circle that touches the three outer circles.
 
##h## = height from big circle center to inner triangle
##r## = inner radius
## 3 r h = A ##, (Triangle area)
## A = r^2 sqrt(3) ##
## h = r / sqrt(3) ##
## sqrt(r^2+h^2) = sqrt(r^2+3 r^2) = r\, sqrt(3) ##
## R = r (1+sqrt(3)) ## (R is big radius)
 
Roberto Pavani said:
## R = r (1+sqrt(3)) ## (R is big radius)
Here is a sanity check. From the picture in post #4, ##R## is just a little bit larger than ##2r##.
 
You are right... my mistake... a calculation error:
Roberto Pavani said:
##h## = height from big circle center to inner triangle
##r## = inner radius
## 3 r h = A ##, (Triangle area)
## A = r^2 sqrt(3) ##
## h = r / sqrt(3) ##
## h^2 = \frac{r^2} {3} ##
Roberto Pavani said:
## sqrt(r^2+h^2) = sqrt(r^2+3 r^2) = r\, sqrt(3) ## <--- Mistake

## \sqrt {r^2+h^2} = \sqrt {r^2+ \frac {r^2}{3} } = \frac {2 r}{\sqrt 3} ##
Roberto Pavani said:
## R = r (1+sqrt(3)) ## (R is big radius) <-- mistake, uses the wrong value
## R = r + \frac {2 r}{\sqrt 3} = r (1 + \frac 2 {\sqrt 3} ) ##
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Gavran, Charles Link and bob012345
bob012345 said:
This figure is bounded by three circular arcs of equal radius R. The arcs are tangent where they meet. Find the enclosed area in terms of R.
Geometric diagram of an equilateral triangle with side R and three red circular arcs, each centred at a vertex and passing through the other two vertices, with 60° angles marked at the corners.


## \begin{align}
A&=\frac{R^2\sqrt{3}}{4}-3(\frac{R^2\pi}{6}-\frac{R^2\sqrt{3}}{4})\nonumber\\
&=R^2(\sqrt{3}-\frac{\pi}{2})\nonumber\\
\end{align}\\ ##