How did meiosis and mitosis evolve in the course of evolution?

  • Thread starter Tiny_Explorer
  • Start date
11 replies · 2K views · last reply
Tiny_Explorer
Messages
18
Reaction score
5
User has been reminded to show more effort in their thread starts
How did the process of cell division evolved over time ?
 
Tiny_Explorer said:
How did the process of cell division evolved over time ?
What have you read on this so far?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: berkeman, pines-demon and BillTre
Slowly, with far more 'that doesn't help this organism, at all' than hitting the jackpot. Millions, billions of years. I would suppose amongst RNA based life across all kinds of water based environments, from salty oceans with deep water vents to shallow lakes. Some with meteor impact craters I would suppose, as well as drainage off all kinds of minerals.

That the replication is so reliable that billions of years on life has persisted and proliferated and species (usually) change slowly is testament to how reliably.

 
Ken Fabian said:
Slowly, with far more 'that doesn't help this organism, at all' than hitting the jackpot. Millions, billions of years. I would suppose amongst RNA based life across all kinds of water based environments, from salty oceans with deep water vents to shallow lakes. Some with meteor impact craters I would suppose, as well as drainage off all kinds of minerals.
For such an involved process, even trillions of years would seem inadequate for a single step. It is reasonable to look for simpler versions that may have worked well enough. But in the absence of any such operating today, that's a challenging exercise.
 
haruspex said:
For such an involved process, even trillions of years would seem inadequate for a single step. It is reasonable to look for simpler versions that may have worked well enough. But in the absence of any such operating today, that's a challenging exercise.
I disagree. The quantities of what would probably would be active RNA 'organisms' would be staggeringly large and the even just the top 10m of oceans and lakes represents a enormous volume containing a very large total mass of organisms that may share many traits but also vary greatly across a vast array of differing chemical condition. The chemical reactions happen quite quickly - WEHI animations like the one above usually show real time and a billion years is a lot of time when chemistry is running at those rates.

I'm not sure RNA replicates with the reliability of DNA. In any case living biochemistry would be making all manner of biologically active molecules - these organisms would not well optimised for determining what is food and rejecting what is not and replication of not-food would probably have been common.
.
It not like such complexity as a kinetochore would or could arise fully formed. DNA replication had to emerge first and whilst more reliable at replication is far from perfect over such long time scales - and initially those optimisations that detect when things go wrong and attempt to correct them would be absent. It will be amongst those things going 'wrong' that new biochemistry is generated.

Cell walls, microtubules for holding cells together, chemicals that can attatch to them and move along them - a succession of developments that DNA does readily forget, with each complex in itself yet not infinitely so would slowly build towards the truly complex biochemstry of meiosis and mitosis.
 
Just for a comparison - I did some rough calculations of how likely the unlikely might be for abiogenesis -
My own take on the odds of life originating by chance alone is to look at the scales of things - 1.3 billion cubic kilometres of liquid water (on Earth ie one planet) = 1,300,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 ml About 1,000,000 bacteria per ml live in sea water, so if the chemical precursors for those are present in primordial sea water we get enough to make... = 1,300,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 bacteria's worth.

Give it 500 million years of chemical reactions that happen at much faster than 1 per second per ml rates I'll be very conservative and say only 1 reaction per second... = 15,750,000,000,000,000 seconds x 1,300,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 bacteria's worth = 20,475,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 chances for random chemistry + selection make the appropriate complex chemistry for earliest ‘simple’ life.
 
Last edited:
Ken Fabian said:
Just for a comparison - I did some rough calculations of how likely the unlikely might be for abiogenesis -
No, that is a calculation of the incomprehensibly large number of opportunities, but in the absence of a credible calculation for the incomprehensibly small likelihood of any one such opportunity putting that degree of complexity together in a single step it gets us nowhere.
 
The processes of mitosis and meiosis are eukaryotic things. Eukayotes are advanced complex cells that are composites of two kinds of simpler prokaryotic cells. The more primitive prokaryotic cells don't have all that fancy division machinery. Prokaryotes are bacterial or archaeal cells. Bacteria divide by pinching off two cells from one without using the machinery of mitosis and meiosis. There are proteins that help the membranes bend to form a stem between the two incipient cells and to fuse the membranes when the cells separate. DNA is separated (in some way) by separation of places where the DNA is attached to the separating cells' membranes. Archaea are the simpler cells from which the eukaryotic host cell (to the bacterially derived mitochondria) comes from. They have some simpler versions of some eukaryotic division mechanism proteins.
Even more primitive cells would be lacking some of those functions and in its most primitive form could just rely on biophysical forces on enlarging membrane enveloped spheres. This would have a high degree of variability in the results of a division. There would strong selection to get division to more frequently produce two functional cells.
Selection should work in any population of dividing cells that are competing for resources. They don't necessarially need DNA or even RNA to do that.
 
@BillTre - you clearly know more about these things than I do. To me the issue raised by @haruspex is answered by the fact that such complex biological processes do exist and they evolved successfully within the time frame available. The how of it is beyond me.
 
Ken Fabian said:
@BillTre - the issue raised by @haruspex is answered by the fact that such complex biological processes do exist and they evolved successfully within the time frame available.
No, that does not answer my issue.
  1. The OP was looking for some possible steps which led up to cell division as we know it.
  2. Your response in post #3 suggested it did not need multiple steps because the number of opportunities for it to arise in one lucky shot was so vast.
  3. My objection is that I believe the likelihood of such luck is many orders of magnitude too small for such an explanation, so the OP is right to seek stepwise ones.
Now, we're both just guessing the magnitude of those odds, but now saying "well it happened somehow" doesn't settle it.
 
I did not intend the impression such things would emerge fully developed, in one shot. Even for the abiogenesis and bacteria. Citing bacteria was more about estimating the abundance of chemical precursors that might exist in primordial sea water - the kinds of chemicals a living thing might require, that living organisms in abundance have used up since and made rare.

A small initial success of something much simpler would have those vast numbers of opportunities to occur. It replicates and becomes more common; the complicated bits have something to develop from.

Empirical evidence is valid evidence it occurred.

The how and when are beyond my scope.
 
1. At first there was a primordial soup, in which lightning struck and small living creatures appeared. That's how I learned it.
2. For breed of resistant bacteria.
 
Last edited: