Tiny_Explorer
- 18
- 5
User has been reminded to show more effort in their thread starts
How did the process of cell division evolved over time ?
What have you read on this so far?Tiny_Explorer said:How did the process of cell division evolved over time ?
For such an involved process, even trillions of years would seem inadequate for a single step. It is reasonable to look for simpler versions that may have worked well enough. But in the absence of any such operating today, that's a challenging exercise.Ken Fabian said:Slowly, with far more 'that doesn't help this organism, at all' than hitting the jackpot. Millions, billions of years. I would suppose amongst RNA based life across all kinds of water based environments, from salty oceans with deep water vents to shallow lakes. Some with meteor impact craters I would suppose, as well as drainage off all kinds of minerals.
I disagree. The quantities of what would probably would be active RNA 'organisms' would be staggeringly large and the even just the top 10m of oceans and lakes represents a enormous volume containing a very large total mass of organisms that may share many traits but also vary greatly across a vast array of differing chemical condition. The chemical reactions happen quite quickly - WEHI animations like the one above usually show real time and a billion years is a lot of time when chemistry is running at those rates.haruspex said:For such an involved process, even trillions of years would seem inadequate for a single step. It is reasonable to look for simpler versions that may have worked well enough. But in the absence of any such operating today, that's a challenging exercise.
My own take on the odds of life originating by chance alone is to look at the scales of things - 1.3 billion cubic kilometres of liquid water (on Earth ie one planet) = 1,300,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 ml About 1,000,000 bacteria per ml live in sea water, so if the chemical precursors for those are present in primordial sea water we get enough to make... = 1,300,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 bacteria's worth.
Give it 500 million years of chemical reactions that happen at much faster than 1 per second per ml rates I'll be very conservative and say only 1 reaction per second... = 15,750,000,000,000,000 seconds x 1,300,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 bacteria's worth = 20,475,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 chances for random chemistry + selection make the appropriate complex chemistry for earliest ‘simple’ life.
No, that is a calculation of the incomprehensibly large number of opportunities, but in the absence of a credible calculation for the incomprehensibly small likelihood of any one such opportunity putting that degree of complexity together in a single step it gets us nowhere.Ken Fabian said:Just for a comparison - I did some rough calculations of how likely the unlikely might be for abiogenesis -
No, that does not answer my issue.Ken Fabian said: