2D life form can exist with alimentary canal

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter MartinRek
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    2d Form Life
5 replies · 5K views · last reply
MartinRek
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Hi,
as I read in one of Hawking books, he predicted that a 2D life-form with an alimentary canal can not exist because it would fall apart. I was wondering about that, because I thought of an easy solution for this: with two movable chainings its still possible. I have made a graphic and attached it to this post. In general its a bit off-topic (sorry for that) but I wanted to get some feedback on it.
Martin
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a 2D life-form drawn as a closed outline with an alimentary canal running through it, with food dots at the mouth and sediment dots at the exit. Top: labelled 'Stephen Hawking: 2D life-form with alimentary canal falls apart'. Bottom: three panels labelled 'chainings' showing the canal split by movable chainings.
    2dlifeform_alimentarycanal.jpg
    32.5 KB · Views: 3,323
Your life-form would hinge open at one chaining when the other is open.
What about shaping the canal like a loose-fitting jigsaw-puzzle piece?

To hold together it would still require some structural rigidity.
 
Yes, but that's only a design issue - you can build / design the chainings strong - maybe they build somehow the backbone of this life form - the graphic should just explain that there exist a way.
 
You could have lots of them along the canal too ... and you'd need to pay attention to how they hook together.

The two sides of the creature could have different charges ... the canal could be filled with a 2D version of a sticky jelly ... etc etc.
 
Amoeabas solved that. Just involve the food and push it inside in a sack.
 
Amoebas are 3D life forms, a "sack" is a 3D container ... OP is talking about 2D.