Alkylation of acetyl anions They say only primary halides are used, so ?

  • Thread starter Lo.Lee.Ta.
  • Start date
  • #1
217
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

"Remember that the alkyne must be a terminal alkyne and the halide must be primary. More than one combination of terminal alkyne and halide may be possible."
-This is what it says in the solutions manual of my Ochem book.

In the first practice problem, they asked what you'd add to form
CH3CH2CH2C(triple bond)CCH3.

So the answer is CH3CH2CH2C(triple bond)C with 1. NaNH2 and 2. CH3Br
~OR~ HC(triple bond)CCH3 with 1. NaNH2 and 2. CH3CH2CH2Br

But I thought they said only primary halides can be used...?

Encyclopedia Britannica defines an alkyl halide as this: "In a primary alkyl halide, the carbon that bears the halogen is directly bonded to one other carbon, in a secondary alkyl halide to two, and in a tertiary alkyl halide to three."

primaryhalide.gif


But how come we used a secondary halide in the 2nd possible reaction?
CH3CH2CH2Br is a secondary halide, right?

In the second practice problem, it asks how we can form (CH3)2CHC(triple bond)CCH2CH3

So the answer is only one possible reaction: (CH3)2CHC(triple bond)CH with 1. NaNH2 and 2. CH3CH2Br

But why can't we also have another possible reaction using HC(triple bond)CCH2CH3 with
1. NaNH2 and 2. (CH3)2CHBr ?

Thanks so much for your help! :)
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
chemisttree
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
3,421
450
"Remember that the alkyne must be a terminal alkyne and the halide must be primary. More than one combination of terminal alkyne and halide may be possible."
-This is what it says in the solutions manual of my Ochem book.

In the first practice problem, they asked what you'd add to form
CH3CH2CH2C(triple bond)CCH3.

So the answer is CH3CH2CH2C(triple bond)C with 1. NaNH2 and 2. CH3Br
~OR~ HC(triple bond)CCH3 with 1. NaNH2 and 2. CH3CH2CH2Br

But I thought they said only primary halides can be used...?

Encyclopedia Britannica defines an alkyl halide as this: "In a primary alkyl halide, the carbon that bears the halogen is directly bonded to one other carbon, in a secondary alkyl halide to two, and in a tertiary alkyl halide to three."

primaryhalide.gif


But how come we used a secondary halide in the 2nd possible reaction?
CH3CH2CH2Br is a secondary halide, right?
No. CH3CH2CH2Br is a primary halide. CH3Br isn't though.

In the second practice problem, it asks how we can form (CH3)2CHC(triple bond)CCH2CH3

So the answer is only one possible reaction: (CH3)2CHC(triple bond)CH with 1. NaNH2 and 2. CH3CH2Br

But why can't we also have another possible reaction using HC(triple bond)CCH2CH3 with
1. NaNH2 and 2. (CH3)2CHBr ?

Thanks so much for your help! :)
Because (CH3)2CHBr is a secondary halide.
 

Related Threads on Alkylation of acetyl anions They say only primary halides are used, so ?

  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
2K
Top