Are There Other Ways To Represent Vectors Besides Arrows?

9 replies · 3K views · last reply
mech-eng
Messages
826
Reaction score
13
TL;DR
Looking for the different vector representations
Hello. I wonder about the representation of vectors, so I wanted to ask: how many different ways vectors be represented?

As far as I know two: Geometrically and Algebraically.

There is only one way to represent vectors in geometrically: arrows, however there are several or more methods to represent vectors algebraically but they are basically one dimensional of numbers. Sometimes there are mathematical symbols between the elements of the list as in 2i + 3j - 4k.

But are those all?

Can another tools be used instead of arrows for geometrical representation?

In more than 3d-space, can there be other ways?
 
mech-eng said:
Summary: Looking for the different vector representations

Hello. I wonder about the representation of vectors, so I wanted to ask: how many different ways vectors be represented?

As far as I know two: Geometrically and Algebraically.

There is only one way to represent vectors in geometrically: arrows, however there are several or more methods to represent vectors algebraically but they are basically one dimensional of numbers. Sometimes there are mathematical symbols between the elements of the list as in 2i + 3j - 4k.

But are those all?

Can another tools be used instead of arrows for geometrical representation?

In more than 3d-space, can there be other ways?
How do you define "representation"?

Your questions have so many hidden assumptions that there cannot be a serious answer.
 
mech-eng said:
Summary: Looking for the different vector representations

Hello. I wonder about the representation of vectors, so I wanted to ask: how many different ways vectors be represented?

As far as I know two: Geometrically and Algebraically.

There is only one way to represent vectors in geometrically: arrows, however there are several or more methods to represent vectors algebraically but they are basically one dimensional of numbers. Sometimes there are mathematical symbols between the elements of the list as in 2i + 3j - 4k.

But are those all?

Can another tools be used instead of arrows for geometrical representation?

In more than 3d-space, can there be other ways?
There's Dirac notation, with its bras and kets:$$\ket \alpha, \bra \beta$$
 
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: mech-eng
fresh_42 said:
How do you define "representation"?

Your questions have so many hidden assumptions that there cannot be a serious answer.

Sorry for being vauge and poor statements. Here representation is "notation" or how we can show vectors on paper or in a digital medium, in a program such as Octave.
 
mech-eng said:
Sorry for being vauge and poor statements. Here representation is "notation" or how we can show vectors on paper or in a digital medium, in a program such as Octave.
Oh, I thought you were asking how to draw vectors that can be quite troublesome if they are functions, the vector space is infinite-dimensional, or the field isn't of characteristic zero.

My teachers often used Sütterlin ...

Handwritten German text in Sütterlin script, a cursive historical German handwriting style, describing the Sütterlin alphabet and its use in German schools before 1941.


... or Fraktur ##\vec{x}=\mathfrak{x}\, , \,\vec{y}=\mathfrak{y}\, , \,\vec{z}=\mathfrak{z}.##
 
  • Wow
Likes   Reactions: berkeman and PeroK
mech-eng said:
Summary: Looking for the different vector representations

Hello. I wonder about the representation of vectors, so I wanted to ask: how many different ways vectors be represented?
Maybe have a read through this Wikipedia artlcle and follow some of the References to get more ideas:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vector_(mathematics_and_physics)
 
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: mech-eng
mech-eng said:
However, I am aware of non-Euclidean geometries.
You're one step ahead of Euclid, then!
 
  • Haha
Likes   Reactions: berkeman
jedishrfu said:
Look to differential forms and to clifford algebra notation too.
e.g. Ch 16 of Burke's unfortunately unfinished Div Grad and Curl are dead (1995)
https://people.ucsc.edu/~rmont/papers/Burke_DivGradCurl.pdf
Figure 16-1 showing eight vector icons drawn as arrows crossing planes and cubes, with the caption 'The eight icons for vectors. All of these would be conventionally denoted by vector symbol.'


This is a simplified version of figures seen in Misner Thorne Wheeler's Gravitation (1973).

All of these are based on Schouten's work...
Two line diagrams labelled Abb. 1 and Abb. 2: Abb. 1 shows a parallelogram-like grid of solid and dashed lines with an arrow inside; Abb. 2 shows crossing lines labelled v_λ, n_λ and v_λ + n_λ.
Abb. 6: four numbered panels showing vector representations. Panel 1: a plain arrow. Panel 2: a line segment with a circular arrow around its midpoint. Panel 3: a closed curve with a circular arrow inside. Panel 4: a curved line crossing a dashed line with an arrow.

from pages 15 and 22 of
Ricci Calculus [Der Ricci-Kalkül (1924)]
https://gdz.sub.uni-goettingen.de/id/PPN373339186
and

Circular diagram of tensor types arranged in a ring, each sector with a geometric symbol: scalar, number, contravariant vector, covariant vector, contravariant bivector, covariant bivector, contravariant trivector, covariant trivector, and density variants, with labels such as v^k, w_λ, f^κλ, h_λλ, p^κλμ and ε^κλμ.


from p. 55 of Tensor Analysis for Physicists (1951)
https://www.amazon.com/dp/0486655822/?tag=pfamazon01-20
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jedishrfu, PeroK and mech-eng