Bar forces (1-6) should be calculated?

  • Thread starter Dan123
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Forces
7 replies · 2K views · last reply
Dan123
Messages
8
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


The pictue shows a symmetrical framework. I should calculate the bar forces. and make a "Clear Cut".I*m not shure because of the left movable bearing (on the left side)!?

Truss diagram of a symmetrical framework with a top chord, bottom chord and diagonal members numbered 1 to 6. Loads 2F1 act at both top corners, F2 at two lower joints, F1 at the centre. Support A is a movable bearing on a 45-degree incline and B is a fixed support. Span is 3h and height is h.


Homework Equations


total x=0
total y=0
total M=0

The Attempt at a Solution


Here is my "Clear Cut" is it correctly?

Hand-drawn free-body diagram of a truss on grid paper: top and bottom chords with diagonal members, loads labeled 4F, 4F, 3F, 2F, 3F, support forces F_A, B_x and B_y, and a 45 degree angle marked at the left support.
 
Attachments
  • Truss diagram of a symmetrical framework with a top chord, bottom chord and diagonal members numbered 1 to 6. Loads 2F1 act at both top corners, F2 at two lower joints, F1 at the centre. Support A is a movable bearing on a 45-degree incline and B is a fixed support. Span is 3h and height is h.
    1.jpg
    33.4 KB · Views: 792
  • Hand-drawn free-body diagram of a truss on grid paper: top and bottom chords with diagonal members, loads labeled 4F, 4F, 3F, 2F, 3F, support forces F_A, B_x and B_y, and a 45 degree angle marked at the left support.
    2.jpg
    41.9 KB · Views: 773
You are right that the force at lower left acts at 45 degrees, but do you think it acts up or down on the frame?
 
haruspex said:
You are right that the force at lower left acts at 45 degrees, but do you think it acts up or down on the frame?

I'm not shure, but our professor said, we should just set it in one direction, and after we calculate it we can see which the right direction was (if it is negative, we have to switch the direction).

But do you know, how I can solve this ...? I'm not shure
 
Dan123 said:

Homework Statement


The pictue shows a symmetrical framework. I should calculate the bar forces. and make a "Clear Cut".I*m not shure because of the left movable bearing (on the left side)!?

View attachment 218785

Homework Equations


total x=0
total y=0
total M=0

The Attempt at a Solution


Here is my "Clear Cut" is it correctly?

View attachment 218786
i forgot...there is given

F, h, F1=2F and F2=3F
 
Dan123 said:
our professor said, we should just set it in one direction, and after we calculate it we can see which the right direction was (if it is negative, we have to switch the direction).
That's correct, but it seemed you were asking for comments on your diagram.
Dan123 said:
how I can solve this
That's not what you asked originally. As per forum rules you need to show an attempt at a solution. Apply the relevant equations you quoted.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Dan123
haruspex said:
That's correct, but it seemed you were asking for comments on your diagram.

That's not what you asked originally. As per forum rules you need to show an attempt at a solution. Apply the relevant equations you quoted.
ok, I will send my solution...or my try :)
 
haruspex said:
That's correct, but it seemed you were asking for comments on your diagram.

That's not what you asked originally. As per forum rules you need to show an attempt at a solution. Apply the relevant equations you quoted.
So here is my try...I can't finish it...I don't get the right answer (the right answer is: S1=6F ; S2=(√5)/2 F ; S3=1,5F ; S4=7F ; S5=(√5)/2 F ; S6=1,5F )

Handwritten truss analysis on grid paper: a truss diagram with loads 3F, 2F, 5F and reactions Ax, Bx, By, plus equilibrium equations for sum Fx, sum Fy, and moments about point B, ending with Fa = -32 sqrt(2).


Hand-drawn truss diagram on grid paper with red force arrows: 4F, 3F, 2F and 3F loads at the joints, a blue line marked cut, and support reactions at the left and right ends; below it, two separated sub-sections with their own red force arrows.


I thought of dividing it in two parts (special calculation method...?!

Could you pplease help me :)
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten truss analysis on grid paper: a truss diagram with loads 3F, 2F, 5F and reactions Ax, Bx, By, plus equilibrium equations for sum Fx, sum Fy, and moments about point B, ending with Fa = -32 sqrt(2).
    IMG_20180123_203046_376.jpg
    48.3 KB · Views: 321
  • Hand-drawn truss diagram on grid paper with red force arrows: 4F, 3F, 2F and 3F loads at the joints, a blue line marked cut, and support reactions at the left and right ends; below it, two separated sub-sections with their own red force arrows.
    IMG_20180123_203116_656.jpg
    45.2 KB · Views: 356
Dan123 said:
(the right answer is: S1=6F ; S2=(√5)/2 F ; S3=1,5F )
Doesn't look right to me.
I was suspicious that you may have specified the wrong values for the applied forces, so I made them arbitrary.
Consider the leftmost triangle and take moments about its lower right corner. Let N be the normal force from the lower left support, Gt the downward load at the top of the triangle, and Gr the load at the bottom right.
Take members 1 and 2 to be under compression, 3 under tension.
Y: N/√2-2S2/√5=Gr+Gt
X: N/√2=S2/√5-S3+S1
M: N/√2=Gt/2+S1
If I substitute the answers in the X and M equations I get N=5F√2, Gt=-F.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Dan123