Flatland
- 218
- 11
Is it possible for some brown dwarves to be more massive than some stars?
The discussion centers on the characteristics and definitions of brown dwarfs in relation to stars, particularly whether brown dwarfs can be more massive than some stars and the implications of adding non-fusible materials like iron to them. The scope includes theoretical considerations of stellar and substellar objects, fusion processes, and the physical properties of brown dwarfs and stars.
Participants express differing views on the implications of mass and composition for brown dwarfs and stars, with no consensus reached on whether brown dwarfs can be more massive than stars or how the introduction of iron would affect fusion processes.
The discussion includes various assumptions about the behavior of materials under extreme conditions and the definitions of stellar classifications, which remain unresolved.
If the fusible nuclei are there.Chronos said:Fusion occurs in the core of a star.
No, it wouldn´t. The speed of iron falling into a star is enough to evaporate the iron, which would mix with hydrogen. Once hot iron vapour is mixed with hydrogen, there will be no efficient way to unmix them, unless they are cooled below the boiling point of iron, which is not the case inside even a brown dwarf.Chronos said:If you could somehow infuse a large amount of iron into a star, the denser iron would displace hydrogen from the core
Again no.Chronos said:- effectively serving as a stellar fusion extinguisher.