Calculate the line of sight velocity dispersion of the cluster in km/sec

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating the line of sight velocity dispersion of a star cluster using spectroscopy data of calcium H and K lines. The original poster presents measured wavelengths from five stars and seeks assistance in determining both the velocity dispersion and the distance to the star cluster.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the Doppler shift effect and its relevance to the problem. The original poster attempts to calculate individual velocities based on the provided wavelengths. There is also a mention of confusion regarding the definition of velocity dispersion and how to compute it. Additionally, questions arise about the second part of the problem concerning distance calculation.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided calculations for the velocity dispersion and expressed uncertainty about the distance calculation. There is a lack of consensus on the correct approach to the second part of the problem, with various interpretations being explored.

Contextual Notes

Participants note confusion regarding the definitions and formulas involved, particularly for velocity dispersion and distance calculation. The original poster's motivation for seeking help is influenced by external factors, such as a challenge from a parent.

ladybug1829
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Please Help :)

"Calcium H and K lines have rest frame wavelengths of 3968.5 A (angstrom). Spectroscopy of 5 stars in a cluster revealed that the Ca H line was detected at
3970.1 A
3966.3 A
3967.5 A
3971.0 A
3968.2 A
in each of these five stars. Calculate the line of sight velocity dispersion of the cluster in km/sec. The rms of the proper motions of these 5 stars was measured to be 1.3 arcseconds / year. Calculate the distance to the star cluster.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org


ladybug1829 said:
I have no idea how to do this. My dad said if I can find the answer online he will buy me a new car. He is trying to prove to me that people online are wasting their lives. Anyone that can help please?

... what?

People online do waste their lives but... what?
 


Except for physics forums.
 


Your dad is teaching astronomy or physics? This is a problem that has to do with the doppler shift effect of the light the stars emmit as they move closer or further from earth.

I could help if this was a simple case with stars moving in the line that connects them with Earth but this isn't the case , a star movemnt doesn't necessarily follow this line.

Ok i ll try to use the formula from wikipedia [tex]f_i=(1-\frac{v_i}{c})f_0[/tex] where [tex]v_i[/tex] is the velocity of the star i relative to Earth and i=1...5. Solving for [tex]v_i[/tex] we have

[tex]v_i=(1-\frac{f_i}{f_0})c=(1-\frac{\lambda_0}{\lambda_i})c[/tex]

We know that [tex]\lambda_0=3968.5A[/tex] and also the values for the [tex]\lambda_i[/tex] so we can now compute [tex]v_i[/tex].

[tex]v_1=120,9Km/s, v_2=-166,4Km/s, v_3=-75,6Km/s, v_4=188,8km/s, v_5=-22,6Km/s[/tex]. The mean value of these 5 velocities is 9,02km/s and the dispersion is 179,78km/s.

Got no clue how to answer the second question for the distance.
 
Last edited:


Thanks :) Anyone else know the second part?
 


btw, i am not sure at all how velocity dispersion is defined. if it is [tex]\sqrt{ \sum_{i=1}^{5}\frac{(v_i-m)^2}{5}}[/tex] where m is the mean value then it is 129,4Km/s.
 
Last edited:


1".3arc = (1.3/3600) degrees = (1.3/3600) X (TT / 180) Radians
= 6.302577854 X 10^-6 Radians
= proper motion / distance.
=> distance = proper motion / 6.302577854 X 10^-6 Radians
= 158,665.2356 X proper motion.

Derive the rms value of the five (divide by 5 to get mean square) that gives standard deviation. And to get the 'proper motion' put that in this equation to get 'Distance'.


Someone else gave me this. I am sooo confused lol
 


ladybug1829 said:
I have no idea how to do this. My dad said if I can find the answer online he will buy me a new car. He is trying to prove to me that people online are wasting their lives. Anyone that can help please?
Physics Forums is not the place to have other people do your homework for you. Probably best to look elsewhere.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K