Calculate Vector Diff: 8m 20° North & 6m 80° East

  • Thread starter Thread starter astrololo
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Vector
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves calculating the vector difference between two movements: one of 8 meters at an angle of 20 degrees north of west, and another of 6 meters at an angle of 80 degrees south of east. The context is within vector mathematics, specifically focusing on Cartesian coordinates.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the trigonometric methods used to resolve the vectors into components. There is confusion regarding the angles and directions described, particularly the phrase "north of the south." Some participants question the interpretation of the negative components in the context of vector representation.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with the problem, clarifying the vector components and discussing the appropriate method for combining the vectors. There is recognition of a misunderstanding regarding whether to add or subtract the vectors, with some suggesting that the question may be misinterpreted.

Contextual Notes

There is a noted confusion about the wording of the problem, specifically whether it asks for the vector sum or the difference between the two vectors. Participants are also addressing the implications of negative components in their calculations.

astrololo
Messages
200
Reaction score
3

Homework Statement


John move 8m 20 degrees north of the west. After, he moves another time 6 m 80 degrees south of the east. Calculate the difference between the two vector of his movement in cartesian form.

Homework Equations


Vector =ai +bj

The Attempt at a Solution



By using trigonometry, I found the following triangles : (-7.51, 2.74, 8)
(1.035, -5.91, 6)

So :

D=(1.035i-5.91j)-(-7.51i+2.74j)

D=8.545i-8.65j

I don't know why it isn't workng. I know that my answer isn't good. But I know that my steps are good.[/B]
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
What is a degree "north of the south"?

You'll also have to elaborate on the trigonometry you used.
 
axmls said:
What is a degree "north of the south"?

You'll also have to elaborate on the trigonometry you used.
Oh, sorry I meant north of west. Not south. The trigonometry that I used is sin angle =opposite side/ hypoth and cos angle = adjacent side / hypoth to find the composents of my triangle
 
astrololo said:

Homework Statement


John move 8m 20 degrees north of the west. After, he moves another time 6 m 80 degrees south of the east. Calculate the difference between the two vector of his movement in cartesian form.

Homework Equations


Vector =ai +bj

The Attempt at a Solution


It's not clear to me what you mean by
By using trigonometry, I found the following triangles : (-7.51, 2.74, 8)
(1.035, -5.91, 6)
What information do those numbers give us about the triangles? Those cannot be lengths of side or angles because they have negative numbers.
You write, as a "relevant equation", "Vector ai+ bj" so I would think that you would be aware that the vector "8m 20 degrees north of the west" gives a= -8 cos(20) and b= 8 sin(20): (-8 cos(20))i+ (8 sin(20))j. Similarly, "6 m 80 degrees south of east" gives 6 cos(80)i- 8 sin(80)j. Add those.

Another way to do this is to draw those two vectors and see that they form two sides of a right triangle of length 6 and 8 with angle between them of 70 degrees.

So :

D=(1.035i-5.91j)-(-7.51i+2.74j)

D=8.545i-8.65j

I don't know why it isn't workng. I know that my answer isn't good. But I know that my steps are good.
 
"What information do those numbers give us about the triangles? Those cannot be lengths of side or angles because they have negative numbers."

Sorry I included the negatives to indicate their direction.

You write, as a "relevant equation", "Vector ai+ bj" so I would think that you would be aware that the vector "8m 20 degrees north of the west" gives a= -8 cos(20) and b= 8 sin(20): (-8 cos(20))i+ (8 sin(20))j. Similarly, "6 m 80 degrees south of east" gives 6 cos(80)i- 8 sin(80)j. Add those.

I think you did an error. It's 6*sin(80) not 8*sin(80). Also, how come that we add them ? I thought that we needed to substract the initial one from the final. I mean, the formula is vector S = vector R - vector R initial (R being the position)
 
Help please !
 
astrololo said:
I thought that we needed to substract the initial one from the final. I mean, the formula is vector S = vector R - vector R initial (R being the position)

I'm a little confused by the wording of the question. Typically it would be asking for the vector from the starting point (the origin) to the final position, in which case you would add them. It seems odd to ask for the difference of the two vectors, but if that's the case, I believe your answer is correct.
 
axmls said:
I'm a little confused by the wording of the question. Typically it would be asking for the vector from the starting point (the origin) to the final position, in which case you would add them. It seems odd to ask for the difference of the two vectors, but if that's the case, I believe your answer is correct.
No, sorry this my error. The question is asking for the final position, not for the difference of final position and initial position. So this is why we're adding the initial position plus the second diplacement of the object.
 
The final position is given by the vector sum of the two vectors you use to get to the final position. That's how we define addition of vectors (just think about how we add two vectors graphically).
 
  • #10
axmls said:
The final position is given by the vector sum of the two vectors you use to get to the final position. That's how we define addition of vectors (just think about how we add two vectors graphically).
Yes, but my mistake was thinking that the question asked for the difference between the final and initial position. (The displacement from initial to final) Now I understand that this wasn't the case.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K