EngWiPy
- 1,361
- 61
Suppose I have a random variable whose moments are not defined, can I still use the characteristic function to find the CDF of that random variable?
The discussion centers on whether the characteristic function can be used to determine the cumulative distribution function (CDF) of a random variable when its moments are not defined. Participants explore the implications of having a random variable with undefined moments, particularly in the context of summing independent identically distributed (i.i.d.) random variables.
Participants do not reach a consensus on whether the characteristic function can be effectively used to find the CDF in the context described. Multiple viewpoints and uncertainties remain regarding the implications of undefined moments.
Participants highlight limitations related to the definitions of moments and the specific conditions under which the characteristic function can be applied. There are unresolved mathematical steps regarding the evaluation of integrals and the practical application of characteristic functions in this context.
EngWiPy said:Suppose I have a random variable whose moments are not defined,
Stephen Tashi said:Distinguish between "not defined" and "not known".
Do you have a random variable known to be from a family of distributions (e.g. Cauchy) whose moments do not exist?
-or do you have a random variable whose moments exist but are not known numerical values?
Stephen Tashi said:Since you know the CDF, I don't understand your question in post #1 about "finding" the CDF.
EngWiPy said:can I still use the characteristic function to find the CDF of that random variable?
Stephen Tashi said:So what you mean to ask is "If I have a random variable X whose moments do not exist, can I use its characterisic function to find the CDF of Y = X1 + X2 + ...XN where each Xi is an independent realization of X?"
The characteristic function of X exists even if its moments do not. Y has a characteristic function that is the product of N copies of the characteristic function of X. Whether these facts suggest a practical way to find the CDF of Y in your specific problem, I don't know.