Checking integral solution steps against answer options

  • Thread starter prakhargupta3301
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Integrals
7 replies · 2K views · last reply
prakhargupta3301
Messages
58
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


The problem is attached. I'm new to these problems (calculus).
I'm not getting my answer as any of the options. I need your help to know whether me or the slide is wrong.
Multiple-choice physics problem slide: acceleration a of a body with initial velocity u changes with distance x as a = k^2 sqrt(x); find distance when velocity becomes 2u. Options (a) to (d) are expressions of the form (3u/2k) raised to different fractional powers.

Homework Equations


x_x[/B]

The Attempt at a Solution


Handwritten calculus working on ruled paper: a = k^2 sqrt(x), then the integral of a dx equals the integral of v dv from u to v, then the integral of k^2 sqrt(x) dx, evaluated from 0 to x and u to 2u, leading to x = (3u / 2k^2)^(2/3).

Thank you for reading.
 
Attachments
  • Multiple-choice physics problem slide: acceleration a of a body with initial velocity u is a = k^2 sqrt(x), find distance when velocity becomes 2u. Options (a) (3u/2k)^(3/4), (b) (3u/2k)^(4/3), (c) (3u/2k)^(3/2), (d) (3u/2k)^(2/3).
    cloc.PNG
    51.8 KB · Views: 519
  • Handwritten calculus working on ruled paper: a = k^2 sqrt(x), then the integral of a dx equals the integral of v dv from u to v, then the integral of k^2 sqrt(x) dx, evaluated from 0 to x and u to 2u, leading to x = (3u / 2k^2)^(2/3).
    IMG_20180619_034801.jpg
    23.7 KB · Views: 384
  • Multiple-choice physics problem slide: acceleration a of a body with initial velocity u changes with distance x as a = k^2 sqrt(x); find distance when velocity becomes 2u. Options (a) to (d) are expressions of the form (3u/2k) raised to different fractional powers.
    ?temp_hash=12720349bd7b2b5fb6e9c4da92df3e15.png
    51.8 KB · Views: 735
The slide is wrong in that x is not constant, k is constant. Your formulation is correct up to ∫ v dv as pointed out by haruspex.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: prakhargupta3301
haruspex said:
What is ∫v.dv?
It is an equation to solve kinematic equations.
a=dv/dt 1
v=dx/dt 2
Divide 1 by 2
a/v= dv/dt⋅dt/dx
a/v=dv/dx
a⋅dx=v⋅dv
Integrate LHS and RHS and you get 3rd equation of motion:
0x∫a⋅dx=uv∫v⋅dv
a⋅x0x=v2|uv
ax-0=v2/2-u2/2
2ax=v2-u2
 
Dr Dr news said:
The slide is wrong in that x is not constant, k is constant. Your formulation is correct up to ∫ v dv as pointed out by haruspex.
So, am I correct or not ? This was quite an ambiguous reply..
If not, can you point out the mistake clearly and correction. Please?
 
Your LHS (2/3) k^2 x^(3/2) is OK the RHS as you have corrected is v^2 / 2 with an upper limit of 2u and a lower limit of u.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: prakhargupta3301
prakhargupta3301 said:
=uv∫v⋅dv...=v2|uv
Quite so, but that does not seem to be what you wrote in your attachment in post #1. I do not see a 2 there.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: prakhargupta3301
Dr Dr news said:
Your LHS (2/3) k^2 x^(3/2) is OK the RHS as you have corrected is v^2 / 2 with an upper limit of 2u and a lower limit of u.
haruspex said:
Quite so, but that does not seem to be what you wrote in your attachment in post #1. I do not see a 2 there.
So, I was incorrect in believing v to be a constant! Silly me. (I pondered over this single question for an hour and didn't get any sleep last night xD)
Thank you both for helping me. Have a great day/night.