Checking the names of other passengers on a flight

  • Thread starter Thread starter Raghav Gupta
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Flight
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the feasibility and implications of accessing passenger names for booked flights through airline websites. Participants express concerns about privacy and security, arguing that even sharing just names could lead to misuse of information, such as stalking or discrimination based on names. The idea of creating apps that could exploit this data is highlighted, with examples illustrating potential negative outcomes, including prejudices and safety risks. Some suggest that passengers should be able to see who else is on their flight to facilitate ride-sharing, but others counter that this could compromise privacy and lead to unwanted attention. Alternatives like using social media or college forums for ride-sharing requests are proposed, emphasizing the importance of maintaining privacy and the need for individuals to take initiative in connecting with fellow travelers without relying on airlines to disclose sensitive information. Overall, the conversation underscores the tension between convenience and privacy in the context of air travel.
Raghav Gupta
Messages
1,010
Reaction score
76
If we have booked a ticket on a flight and want to check who are the passengers traveling onboard , can we check online through the flight's website?
Or are there security concerns for international as well as domestic flights?
If yes what harm it does to get only a name ( We are not requiring other details)?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You really can't see the harm that could be caused? Beyond the simple invasion of privacy if an airline was to make data like that public, once the data was available, people would do things with it. The app builders of the world would have a field day with data like that.
 
  • Like
Likes Ryan_m_b and Choppy
Borg said:
You really can't see the harm that could be caused? Beyond the simple invasion of privacy if an airline was to make data like that public, once the data was available, people would do things with it. The app builders of the world would have a field day with data like that.
But I am asking that data should be made available only to people who have booked the same flight early. Not publicly shown.
 
You can't trust people like that. It just wouldn't stay private. Just imagine an app where I can enter the flight that I was on and the name of the person who sat in the seat next to me along with some comments. Now call that app the My Annoying Seatmate app. Would you want YOUR name posted on that?
 
Raghav Gupta said:
But I am asking that data should be made available only to people who have booked the same flight early. Not publicly shown.
You are the public.
 
  • Like
Likes Ryan_m_b and russ_watters
Borg said:
You can't trust people like that. It just wouldn't stay private. Just imagine an app where I can enter the flight that I was on and the name of the person who sat in the seat next to me along with some comments. Now call that app the My Annoying Seatmate app. Would you want YOUR name posted on that?
But what only a name does? It is not a unique identity. There are many people with same names.
 
Raghav Gupta said:
want to check who are the passengers traveling onboard

Why?
 
  • Like
Likes Borg
Raghav Gupta said:
But what only a name does? It is not a unique identity. There are many people with same names.
What if your seatmate decides to take your picture without your knowledge and posts that also?
 
jtbell said:
Why?
So I get to know from our college (having many students) who are traveling in same flight and I can share a taxi with them.
 
  • #10
Borg said:
What if your seatmate decides to take your picture without your knowledge and posts that also?
But for taking pic of me the person has to encounter me in person which is only possible in airport or inside flight. As with only the detail of a name the person can't take a picture of me.
 
  • #11
Raghav Gupta said:
But for taking pic of me the person has to encounter me in person which is only possible in airport or inside flight.
Which is generally the same thing that we've been discussing. I'm giving you examples off the top of my head and you're treating them like that's the only way that the data could be misused. Whether you can refute my particular examples or not doesn't change the fact that this is private information that can be misused. Additionally, the airlines would encounter a firestorm of protests if they did something like that.
 
Last edited:
  • #12
In addition to what's been said I fear that if something like that were to happen we would see all sorts of horrible outcomes that result from prejudices, unfounded fears, and outright racist beliefs. People would refuse to get on airplanes or insist that other people be booted off for no reason other than the sound or associations with a given name.
 
  • Like
Likes Tosh5457, billy_joule, Ryan_m_b and 1 other person
  • #13
Borg said:
Which is generally the same thing that we've been discussing. I'm giving you examples off the top of my head and you're treating them like that's the only way that the data could be misused. Whether you can refute my particular examples or not doesn't change the fact that this is private information that can me misused. Additionally, the airlines would encounter a firestorm of protests if they did something like that.
Got it. Thanks for discussing the topic. I think I already knew the answer of this before posting thread but wanted to discuss some points.
 
  • #14
Choppy said:
In addition to what's been said I fear that if something like that were to happen we would see all sorts of horrible outcomes that result from prejudices, unfounded fears, and outright racist beliefs. People would refuse to get on airplanes or insist that other people be booted off for no reason other than the sound or associations with a given name.
Yeah, applying this logic to other places , even the movie hall doesn't show names of person who have pre-booked.
But PF shows who are the members or passengers online.
 
  • #15
Raghav Gupta said:
But PF shows who are the members or passengers online.

However, most usernames on PF are anonymous and cannot be traced easily to specific real people.
 
  • Like
Likes Raghav Gupta
  • #16
You can't compare Internet forum using nicknames and planes with real names. What if someone wants to get rid of someone then he could arrange plane accident so that the murder would look innocent?
I know I am exaggerating but there are some creepy people out there.
There are stalkers, kidnappers, pathologically jealous partners who won't let the other person go...
And of course people would refuse to travel with Muslims, or in India, they would refuse traveling with people from lower casts.
Etc, etc...
 
  • Like
Likes Raghav Gupta
  • #17
Raghav Gupta said:
So I get to know from our college (having many students) who are traveling in same flight and I can share a taxi with them.

The appropriate solution for this is a service that allows students at your college to post requests and offers to share rides to specific destinations. When I was an undergraduate more than 40 years ago, we used a bulletin board in the student center for this. (the kind that you post paper notes on, using thumbtacks :cool:)
 
  • #18
jtbell said:
The appropriate solution for this is a service that allows students at your college to post requests and offers to share rides to specific destinations. When I was an undergraduate more than 40 years ago, we used a bulletin board in the student center for this. (the kind that you post paper notes on, using thumbtacks :cool:)
Although that service is not available and nobody uses bulletin board for these kind of requests, facebook or whatsapp is the only alternative for now. The thing is that group is a limited personal one and not quite huge.
 
  • #19
I'm sure Facebook group or college discussion forum will work. Many people traveled together like this from my uni
 
  • #20
jtbell said:
However, most usernames on PF are anonymous and cannot be traced easily to specific real people.
And those who can do so by choice. And the purpose of the forum is communication, so *some* identity, fake or not, is required.
 
  • #21
If you want to know who might be getting the same flight as you: ask around, be social! Afterall if you had your stalking app what would you do, randomly email these people for a taxi ride?

In pretty much any privacy discussion I firmly believe that the onus should be on the person advocating a breach in privacy to justify it, not the other way round.
 
  • Like
Likes Borg
  • #22
Raghav Gupta said:
So I get to know from our college (having many students) who are traveling in same flight and I can share a taxi with them.
Contact them all prior to the flight, and ask 'are you on xxx flight to xxx?'. If so, ask if they want to share a taxi. You don't need to acquire the name of other passengers who aren't in your college.
 
  • #23
Raghav Gupta said:
Yeah, applying this logic to other places , even the movie hall doesn't show names of person who have pre-booked.
But PF shows who are the members or passengers online.
People can choose to be invisible on the PF users online list.
 
  • #24
StevieTNZ said:
People can choose to be invisible on the PF users online list.
I think only the gold members.
 
Back
Top