Deflect Asteroid w/ Collisions: Calculating Theta & MJ Interractions

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
dedocta
Messages
11
Reaction score
3
TL;DR
I'm looking for a way to calculate how much an asteroids trajectory would change, based off of a collision event.
In short, I was trying to look into feasibility of deflecting an asteroid with a collision of ~32MJ of direct energy. I wanted to know how many collisions are necessary to deflect at a given time out (distance away.)

I found this link, where the collision is perpendicular to the motion of the asteroid:

https://physics.stackexchange.com/q...an-asteroid-with-force-always-perpendicular-tSo, taking the following equation, and with the ideal scenario of a perpendicular collision we are left with an isosceles triangle, where we can solve for Theta based off of the distance away of the asteroid and the distance we want to deflect / modify trajectory.

𝑚(𝑣1^2)(1−cos(𝜃))

Diagram of an isosceles triangle showing an asteroid deflection: a horizontal black path with the asteroid at left, a red vertical arrow below labelled Object Colliding with Asteroid, a green line at angle theta labelled d, and a deflection distance shown at the right.


I then created an excel spreadsheet to calculate theta based off of the distance away and deflection distance, and asked how many 32MJ interractions it would take to change the trajectory by a certain distance at a certain time of collision. It would appear smaller asteroids it would be possible to change trajectories with this, however, not so much for the lower and upper bounds of the Chicxilub asteroid and another larger current NEO.

Would this be an acceptable way to do this? If so, I've been stuck on where to go next if the collision is not perpendicular, if anyone had any input?
 
Last edited:
Energy is largely useless for these calculations. It is all about momentum. A more massive object with the same energy in the asteroid reference frame will have a much larger effect on the orbit.

For short timescales (short compared to an orbit) the impact direction doesn't matter that much for the calculation: You give the asteroid a velocity change v that depends on your impact only, after time t its position will have changed by v*t. For longer timescales you have to consider orbital mechanics. As an extreme case: After one orbit the object will return to where it was, no matter how the impact was (neglecting perturbations by planets or similar). It might return earlier or later, however, that can work as deflection, too.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: dedocta