Denlinger theorem 2.9.6 (a): upper and lower limit inequality

  • Topic:
  • Thread starter Math Amateur
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Limits Theorem
2 replies · 2K views · last reply
Math Amateur
Gold Member
MHB
Messages
3,920
Reaction score
48
I am reading Charles G. Denlinger's book: "Elements of Real Analysis".

I am focused on Chapter 2: Sequences ... ...

I need help with the proof of Theorem 2.9.6 (a)Theorem 2.9.6 reads as follows:
View attachment 9250
View attachment 9251
In the above proof of part (a) we read the following:

" ... $$ \forall \ m, n \in \mathbb{N}, \ \underline{x_n} \leq \underline{ x_{n + m} } \leq \overline{ x_{n + m} } \leq \overline{ x_m }$$. Thus, $$\text{sup} \{ \underline{x_n} \ : \ n \in \mathbb{N} \} \leq \text{inf} \{ \overline{x_n} \ : \ n \in \mathbb{N} \}$$... ... "
My question is as follows:Can someone explain exactly why $$ \ \underline{x_n} \leq \underline{ x_{n + m} } \leq \overline{ x_{n + m} } \leq \overline{ x_m } \ $$ implies that $$ \ \text{sup} \{ \underline{x_n} \ : \ n \in \mathbb{N} \} \leq \text{inf} \{ \overline{x_n} \ : \ n \in \mathbb{N} \}$$ ... ... Hope that someone can help ...

Peter
===============================================================================

It may help MHB readers to have access to Denlinger's definitions and notation regarding upper and lower limits ... so I am providing access to the same ... as follows:
View attachment 9252
View attachment 9253
Hope that helps ...

Peter
 
Attachments
  • Printed statement of Theorem 2.9.6, Elementary Properties of Upper and Lower Limits, parts (a) to (d), with the proof of part (a) and (b) below, including inequalities between lim inf and lim sup of x_n and subsequences.
    Denlinger - 1 - Theorem 2.9.6 - PART 1 ... .png
    23.8 KB · Views: 193
  • Printed proof excerpt: limits preserve inequalities give lim over m of x_{n_m} >= lim over m of x_m, and limsup of x_{n_m} <= limsup of x_m, concluding lim x_n <= lim x_{m_k} <= limsup x_{n_k} <= limsup x_n, ending with a QED box.
    Denlinger - 2 - Theorem 2.9.6 - PART 2 ... .png
    6.2 KB · Views: 183
  • Page from a textbook, section 2.9 Upper and Lower Limits, with Definition 2.9.1 of the upper limit of a real sequence: for bounded-above sequences, the n-th tail supremum is defined, and the upper limit is the limit of these tail suprema, with the case of unbounded-above sequences set to plus infinity.
    Denlinger - 1 - Start of Section 2.9 - PART 1 ... .png
    23.2 KB · Views: 186
  • Printed page from a real analysis text giving Definition 2.9.2 of the lower limit of a real sequence {x_n}, with case 1 for bounded-below sequences defining x_n as inf{x_k : k >= n}, and case 2 setting the lower limit to -infinity when unbounded below.
    Denlinger - 2 - Start of Section 2.9 - PART 2 .png
    22.5 KB · Views: 192
Last edited:
Peter said:
Can someone explain exactly why $$ \ \underline{x_n} \leq \underline{ x_{n + m} } \leq \overline{ x_{n + m} } \leq \overline{ x_m } \ $$ implies that $$ \ \text{sup} \{ \underline{x_n} \ : \ n \in \mathbb{N} \} \leq \text{inf} \{ \overline{x_n} \ : \ n \in \mathbb{N} \}$$ ... ...
Leaving out the two intermediate parts in that string of inequalities, you see that $\underline{x_n} \leqslant \overline{ x_m }$ (for all $m$ and $n$ in $\Bbb{N}$). Keeping $m$ fixed and letting $n$ vary, it follows that $\overline{ x_m }$ is an upper bound for the sequence $\{ \underline{x_n}\}$. Therefore $\sup\{ \underline{x_n}\} \leqslant \overline{ x_m }$.

Now let $m$ vary. That last inequality shows that $\sup\{ \underline{x_n}\}$ is a lower bound for the sequence $\{\overline{ x_m }\}$, and therefore $\sup\{ \underline{x_n}\} \leqslant \inf \{\overline{ x_m }\}$.
 
Last edited:
Opalg said:
Leaving out the two intermediate parts in that string of inequalities, you see that $\underline{x_n} \leqslant \overline{ x_m }$ (for all $m$ and $n$ in $\Bbb{N}$). Keeping $m$ fixed and letting $n$ vary, it follows that $\overline{ x_m }$ is an upper bound for the sequence $\{ \underline{x_n}\}$. Therefore $\sup\{ \underline{x_n}\} \leqslant \overline{ x_m }$.

Now let $m$ vary. That last inequality shows that $\sup\{ \underline{x_n}\}$ is a lower bound for the sequence $\{\overline{ x_m }\}$, and therefore $\sup\{ \underline{x_n}\} \leqslant \inf \{\overline{ x_m }\}$.

Thanks Opalg ...

Appreciate your help ...

Peter