B Determining Electron's Momentum and Position Simultaneously

  • B
  • Thread starter Thread starter lisathomas
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Electron
lisathomas
Messages
3
Reaction score
2
TL;DR Summary
Is it possible to retrospectively determine the position and speed of an electron at the same moment?
Hi. I am a high school science teacher (A&P, Chem, and Environ Bio & Eco) so my understanding is limited on subatomic particles...please forgive me if this is a really stupid idea.

I teach my chem students about electrons, orbitals, electrons' "address" using the four quantum numbers, 1s2 -1/2 spin. I use the example of an airplane's propellers or a fan's blades to explain that we can know how fast they are traveling or their exact position but not both at the same time. I was watching my fan in my bedroom this morning turning around and around and I would pick a blade and watch it then allow it to blur in with the rest as I watched all the blades turn at a slow speed. Then, I began to blink my eyes rapidly which allowed me to take "moment pictures" which allowed me to see the placement of each blade and the speed of my eyes opening and closing with the change in position of the blades allowed me to "measure" the speed. Is there some way we could do that in a lab with electrons?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
An atom is a bound energy state of its constituent particles. The electrons do not have classical trajectories, in terms of position as a function of time; or, momentum as a function of time.

QM involves an entirely different description of nature, based on states and state vectors, as opposed to classical trajectories. The ceiling fan analogy doesn't apply, I'm sorry to say.
 
  • Like
Likes Delta Prime and lisathomas
Wow! Thank you for the clear explanation.
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman and weirdoguy
Wish when I was in school I had a teacher curious enough to post this
 
  • Like
Likes ersmith and lisathomas
Oh, thank you! That is so kind.
 
Not an expert in QM. AFAIK, Schrödinger's equation is quite different from the classical wave equation. The former is an equation for the dynamics of the state of a (quantum?) system, the latter is an equation for the dynamics of a (classical) degree of freedom. As a matter of fact, Schrödinger's equation is first order in time derivatives, while the classical wave equation is second order. But, AFAIK, Schrödinger's equation is a wave equation; only its interpretation makes it non-classical...
I am not sure if this falls under classical physics or quantum physics or somewhere else (so feel free to put it in the right section), but is there any micro state of the universe one can think of which if evolved under the current laws of nature, inevitably results in outcomes such as a table levitating? That example is just a random one I decided to choose but I'm really asking about any event that would seem like a "miracle" to the ordinary person (i.e. any event that doesn't seem to...
Back
Top