Directional derivative notation in Duistermaat and Kolk

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
Math Amateur
Gold Member
MHB
Messages
3,920
Reaction score
48
I am reading "Multidimensional Real Analysis I: Differentiation" by J. J. Duistermaat and J. A. C. Kolk ...

I am focused on Chapter 2: Differentiation ... ...

I need help with an aspect of D&K's notation for directional derivatives ... ...

D&K's definition of directional and partial derivatives reads as follows:
Textbook page titled 2.3 Directional and partial derivatives, with Formula (2.11), Definition 2.3.1 of directional and partial derivatives, and a note on partial mappings.

I am assuming that under D&K's definitions and notation one can write:##D_v f(a) = \begin{pmatrix} D_v f_1 (a) \\ D_v f_2 (a) \\ D_v f_3 (a) \\ ... \\ ... \\ ... \\ D_v f_p (a) \end{pmatrix}####= Df(a)v#### = \begin{pmatrix} D_1 f_1(a) & D_2 f_1(a) & ... & ... & D_n f_1(a) \\ D_1 f_2(a) & D_2 f_2(a) & ... & ... & D_n f_2(a) \\ ... & ... & ... & ... &... \\ ... & ... & ... & ... &... \\ ... & ... & ... & ... &... \\ D_1 f_p(a) & D_2 f_p(a) & ... & ... & D_n f_p(a) \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} v_1 \\ v_2 \\ ... \\ ... \\ ... \\ v_n \end{pmatrix}##

## = \begin{pmatrix} D_1 f_1(a) v_1 + D_2 f_1(a) v_2 + \ ... \ ... \ + D_n f_1(a) v_n \\ D_1 f_2(a) v_1 + D_2 f_2(a) v_2 + \ ... \ ... \ + D_n f_2(a) v_n \\ ... \ ... \ ... \ ... \ ... \\ ... \ ... \ ... \ ... \ ... \\ ... \ ... \ ... \ ... \ ... \\ D_1 f_p(a) v_1 + D_2 f_p(a) v_2 + \ ... \ ... \ + D_n f_p(a) v_n \end{pmatrix} ##Is the above a correct use of notation according to D&K's schema of notation ...

Peter
=========================================================================================

Proposition 2.3.2 may well be relevant to the above post ... so I am providing the same ... as follows:
Printed text of Proposition 2.3.2: if f is differentiable at a, it has directional derivatives D_v f(a) = Df(a)v and is partially differentiable, with Df(a)v = sum over 1 to n of v_j D_j f(a).

Printed proof text from a textbook: "Proof. Assertion (i) follows from Formula (2.11). The partial differentiability in (ii) is a consequence of (i); the formula follows from Df(a) ∈ Lin(R^n, R^p) and v = Σ_{1≤j≤n} v_j e_j (see (1.1))."
 
Attachments
  • Textbook page titled 2.3 Directional and partial derivatives, with Formula (2.11), Definition 2.3.1 of directional and partial derivatives, and a note on partial mappings.
    D&K - Start of Section 2.3 on Directional and Partial Derivatives ... .png
    30.5 KB · Views: 1,138
  • Printed text of Proposition 2.3.2: if f is differentiable at a, it has directional derivatives D_v f(a) = Df(a)v and is partially differentiable, with Df(a)v = sum over 1 to n of v_j D_j f(a).
    D&K - 1 - Proposition 2.3.2 ... .... PART 1 ... .png
    16.8 KB · Views: 803
  • Printed proof text from a textbook: "Proof. Assertion (i) follows from Formula (2.11). The partial differentiability in (ii) is a consequence of (i); the formula follows from Df(a) ∈ Lin(R^n, R^p) and v = Σ_{1≤j≤n} v_j e_j (see (1.1))."
    D&K - 2 - Proposition 2.3.2 ... .... PART 2 ... .png
    9.9 KB · Views: 455
What you have written makes sense. You have broken things up more than the text did, into component functions ##D_jf_i(a)## for ##1\leq i\leq p##. The text has not stated a choice of notion for those component functions. Other possibilities for writing them would be ##D_jf(a)_i## and ##D_jf(a)^i##. The latter uses a superscript rather than subscript to align with how these things tend to be written in tensor calculus.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Math Amateur
andrewkirk said:
What you have written makes sense. You have broken things up more than the text did, into component functions ##D_jf_i(a)## for ##1\leq i\leq p##. The text has not stated a choice of notion for those component functions. Other possibilities for writing them would be ##D_jf(a)_i## and ##D_jf(a)^i##. The latter uses a superscript rather than subscript to align with how these things tend to be written in tensor calculus.

Thanks Andrew ...

Appreciate your help ...

Peter