Do Cold Temperatures Confuse Dogs into Thinking They're Penguins?

  • Thread starter Thread starter nitsuj
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Head
Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
13 replies · 4K views
nitsuj
Messages
1,387
Reaction score
98
Just happened to see this joke in the news paper (tabloid) today. Weather has gone from +10 to -23 (windchill) in a matter of two days.

That said, do dogs lay eggs when it's cold out. :rolleyes: (there is no news/politics context that I know of)
bADJOKE_zps98e73ba0.png
 
on Phys.org
That said, do dogs lay eggs when it's cold out.

Yes. :approve: Dogs do lay eggs sometimes. However, it is extremely difficult to locate a dog's eggs and many people have taken a hobby of spotting dog's eggs.
 
The joke was over your head. They're trying to allude to the fact that the dogs are so confused they don't even know if they're a dog or some egg-laying vertebrate.

Like Drakkith said, probably not the best joke ever.
 
Apparently confusing weather causes your mind to be confused about other things non-weather related, like what species you are.

It's a bad joke, not over your head. You just tried to think about it in a direction it wasn't going, like I did. I thought there was a relation between winter and egg-laying, since there's a common belief that there's a relation between summer and shedding. Also, it sort of implies that the dog equivalent to laying eggs is shedding fur.

I don't think I'm smart at all, but "over my head" usually implies, at least to me, something is too smart or clever, but in this case I think it was too dumb.
 
Mech_Engineer said:
The joke was over your head. They're trying to allude to the fact that the dogs are so confused they don't even know if they're a dog or some egg-laying vertebrate.

Like Drakkith said, probably not the best joke ever.

I think you're right Mech_Engineer. That also seems to be the consensus here at work, to interpret it literally...weather makes animals "dumb" so the animals said/thought something "dumb".

I was making my own bad joke with the "Do dogs lay eggs in the winter?" question, to LerroyJenkins point about the "logic" with that interpretation, the joke implies it's the case as the "wacky" weather was a temperature variance.

The joke was so not funny to me I had to assume I was missing something.

This "news" paper (tabloid) is about a grade 10 reading level, editorial maybe grade 12...maybe. It just throws me for a loop when they include a grade level 2 joke in the editorial.

Drakkith rightly said it was a BAD joke.
 
http://www.aip.org/history/einstein/images/ae27.jpg
A. Einstein said:
People slowly accustomed themselves to the idea that the physical states of space itself were the final physical reality.

It reminded me of this one.
 
Forgot to mention the author of the comic is Susan Dewar. She won the "top prize" in Political Cartooning Division of the National Business Writing Awards-1987. Pretty remarkably to make a career out of cartooning. particularly in this day
 
Last edited:
Ivan Seeking said:
It is a little known fact that dogs do lay eggs. But they usually eat them which is why this often goes unnoticed.

I noticed my dog eats less when the weather is colder, now I know why! :smile:
 
Ivan Seeking said:
It is a little known fact that dogs do lay eggs. But they usually eat them which is why this often goes unnoticed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vNwJDm5srik

That poor dog was fast asleep!

Nothing like a pet to bring out the silly in an owner :biggrin:.
 
nitsuj said:
Just happened to see this joke in the news paper (tabloid) today. Weather has gone from +10 to -23 (windchill) in a matter of two days.

That said, do dogs lay eggs when it's cold out. :rolleyes: (there is no news/politics context that I know of)



bADJOKE_zps98e73ba0.png


The dogs are shaped like penguins. The weather has confused them so much they aren't sure whether they are dogs or penguins.

Not very funny.