Einstein equations don't work at large scale?

  • Level: High School 
  • Thread starter gen x
  • Start date
161 replies · 13K views · last reply
gen x said:
I am so disappointed that physics is not 100% truth like math.
Math is not the truth, it merely needs to be self consistent. Physical theories must be self consistent, and also agree with observation.
gen x said:
Can physics be set from axioms, from first principles that are "truth"?
How would know they are the truth? You don't know it for mathematical axioms either. They are just assumed.
 
Last edited:
gen x said:
Because this seems logic to me.
Logic depends on assumptions. What if your assumptions are wrong? Or worse, not even wrong?

gen x said:
Why you think that is not case in reality?
I said no such thing. I made no positive statement at all. I don't even know if the alternatives you stated are the only possible ones.
 
A.T. said:
How would know they are the truth? You don't know it for mathematical axiom either. They are just assumed.
Try prove that a=a is wrong.

PeterDonis said:
Logic depends on assumptions. What if your assumptions are wrong? Or worse, not even wrong?
Yes then we are stuck. If I look that way, it turn out that we can't know nothing.
 
gen x said:
Yes then we are stuck. If I look that way, it turn out that we can't know nothing.

Think of all the things we have that our ancestors could only dream of. Building them and using them is something we know how to do. We expand that knowledge continuously. Math, science, and engineering continuously grow. As do other disciplines.
 
A.T. said:
That is not a proof.
what is proof?
Matterwave said:
Try this one:

##(\exists x)(\forall y)[\emptyset \in x\land (y\in x\rightarrow y\cup \{y\}\in x)]##
I don't even know what this mean
 
gen x said:
what is proof?
A finite sequence of deductions following rules of inference. One of the rules allows you to cite an axiom.

If x=x is one of your axioms, you may prove it by simply saying so.

If not, you will have to start from other axioms and prove it.

Citing a few examples is not a proof.

gen x said:
I don't even know what this mean
It is an axiom of ZF set theory. The axiom of infinity. If it seems obviously true to you, you can make an argument why.

You seem to think the axioms of mathematics are obviously true. That mathematics gives you 100% truth while physics fails. That was my interpretation of your posts so far . So I'd like to know why this axiom is obviously true.
 
gen x said:
Try prove that a=a is wrong.
gen x said:
what is proof?
You ask me to prove something, but don't even know what a proof is.

For someone who invokes "logic" all the time, you seem to know very little about it. For starters, the lack of proof that something is false, does not imply that it is true.
 
gen x said:
Try prove that a=a is wrong.
Assume ##a\ne a##. Then ##a=a## is wrong.

gen x said:
If I look that way, it turn out that we can't know nothing.
Sure we can know things. What we cannot do is be certain about our knowledge. What you are complaining about isn’t the inability to know things, it is the inability to be certain.

The solution to that is simply to approach your knowledge with a bit of humility. Recognizing your limitations doesn’t detract from your abilities, it just removes some pride and hubris. And that is a good thing
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: zonde, gen x, Matterwave and 3 others