Einstein's Train: Light Travel Time Explained

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
David Lewis
Messages
847
Reaction score
259
TL;DR
Einstein's Train -- M' will see B before A whether the events are simultaneous in Train frame or Embankment frame.
https://www.physicsforums.com/attachments/269029
Lightning strikes A and B simultaneously in the Embankment frame.
M' sees the flash at B before the one at A.
But if the flashes are simultaneous in the Train frame, does M' still see B before A?
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of Einstein's train thought experiment: a train moving right at speed v above an embankment line, with points A, M and B marked on the embankment and M' marked at the train's midpoint.
    einsteins train.png
    10 KB · Views: 234
If the events are simultaneous in the train frame, then M' sees the events simultaneously(the light from the events reach him at the same time) and M doesn't.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: David Lewis
David Lewis said:
Summary:: Einstein's Train -- M' will see B before A whether the events are simultaneous in Train frame or Embankment frame.

But if the flashes are simultaneous in the Train frame, does M' still see B before A?
No. Why would they?
 
To answer the question in the title ("Does Einstein's train account for light travel time?"):
Yes. The entire argument is based on considering the consequences of light travel time between the strikes and the observers' eyes.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: David Lewis, vanhees71 and Ibix
If the flashes are simultaneous in the Train frame, does M' see B before A?
Dale said:
No. Why would they?
Because when the light reaches M', he will be closer to B than to A.
I forgot, however, that when an observer sees two equidistant events happen at the same time then they are simultaneous in his frame.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: cianfa72 and Dale